Idea I've been mulling over that I'd like some input on

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • #1
    Admiral in the Red Army
    Afrobean
    • Dec 2003
    • 13262

    Idea I've been mulling over that I'd like some input on

    I've been trying to think of a way to gimp alliances without removing the blue roles they're based on.

    I think I have something relatively effective.

    It would be a standard game with seer, guardian, psychic, whatever. Completely normal. The special thing comes in that no one is allowed to tell anyone anything about their role whatsoever. In fact, they wouldn't even be allowed to tell that they're blue.

    The seer wouldn't be able to tell anyone that they're the seer. They wouldn't be able to tell anyone that they had seer'd someone. The best they would be allowed is to say something to the effect of "my gut tells me..."

    The guardian wouldn't be able to contact someone they saved and say "I'm the guardian." If they believe they're seer'd, they're not allowed to tell the person that they're the guardian.

    Psychic is a little different. They can say how many wolves are left, but they can't make it seem as though they KNOW how many there are. They also can't say they're the psychic.

    I'd also like to not have MW in such a game and bring back the framing. It seems like a more effective alliance gimp.

    The problem comes up that this would all be on the honor system. The only medium I could actually police would be the thread, so I'd have to be sure none of you losers would cheat. I'm also unsure of what reprecussions should come from cheating.
  • #2
    auauauau
    Omeganitros
    • Jun 2003
    • 8897

    Re: Idea I've been mulling over that I'd like some input on

    So, when a seer seers a human, the best he can do is say "I don't think he's a wolf, guys..."? And there's no stating you're human?

    Comment

    • #3
      FFR Hall of Fame
      FFR Simfile Author
      aperson
      • Jul 2003
      • 3435

      Re: Idea I've been mulling over that I'd like some input on

      Restricting information flow isn't the way to gimp alliances, restricting information is.

      Comment

      • #4
        Admiral in the Red Army
        Afrobean
        • Dec 2003
        • 13262

        Re: Idea I've been mulling over that I'd like some input on

        Originally posted by aperson
        Restricting information flow isn't the way to gimp alliances, restricting information is.
        I know, but everyone loves their blues and isn't quick to wanna play a game with less blues.

        Comment

        • #5
          FFR Veteran
          iggymatrixcounter
          • Nov 2003
          • 1924

          Re: Idea I've been mulling over that I'd like some input on

          Rather than not having the seer tell who he is, you could just have all that information posted publically. (I.E. the host would say who was seered and who was guarded.)

          I've also thought about (in the case of the guardian and seer) that everyone sends in their "seer" choice and their "guard" choice, and a random person's choices are what is used. This way the roles are there but no one has absolute authority over it and therefore couldn't reveal himself as a seer or guardian.
          lastfm
          PANDORA

          Comment

          • #6
            Admiral in the Red Army
            Afrobean
            • Dec 2003
            • 13262

            Re: Idea I've been mulling over that I'd like some input on

            Originally posted by iggymatrixcounter
            Rather than not having the seer tell who he is, you could just have all that information posted publically. (I.E. the host would say who was seered and who was guarded.)

            I've also thought about (in the case of the guardian and seer) that everyone sends in their "seer" choice and their "guard" choice, and a random person's choices are what is used. This way the roles are there but no one has absolute authority over it and therefore couldn't reveal himself as a seer or guardian.
            Guardian coming out isn't huge, so consensus guarding is a decent idea, but consensus seering is not.

            That's like giving the humans two chances to lynch a wolf each day.

            Comment

            • #7
              FFR Player
              nforcer06164
              • Mar 2003
              • 4772

              Re: Idea I've been mulling over that I'd like some input on

              Afro, the only problem here is, there is NO way to enforce this. At all.

              PROUD OWNER OF TWO OMEGA FAVORS. YEAH, NICE TRY.
              Giant NES Controller (4 FEET) progress: PAINT IS DONE!
              Download my Wii Music Suite v1.0, and PM me with your input!

              Originally posted by Squeek
              My mind says "GOGOGOG" and my hands go "wut no scru u ***"

              Comment

              • #8
                FFR Veteran
                iggymatrixcounter
                • Nov 2003
                • 1924

                Re: Idea I've been mulling over that I'd like some input on

                No I didn't mean everyone voted for who to guard and who to seer.

                I meant everyone would send in a seer report and who they would guard in a PM to the host and one random person's choices would be used.

                EDIT: nevermind I got what you said the second time I read it.
                lastfm
                PANDORA

                Comment

                • #9
                  Retired BOSS
                  FFR Simfile Author
                  Tasselfoot
                  • Jul 2003
                  • 25185

                  Re: Idea I've been mulling over that I'd like some input on

                  Afro, I tried to come up with a way for this to work in TWG22. Whorli wanted to use the vigi, but as we know, it is a flawed role. So I tried to help her work it so that the vigi couldn't tell anyone he was the vigi. She got all confused, and it wasn't used in the game.

                  I'd imagine there was some discussion about it in the TWG22 signup thread if you wanted to look into it.
                  RIP

                  Comment

                  • #10
                    FFR Hall of Fame
                    FFR Simfile Author
                    aperson
                    • Jul 2003
                    • 3435

                    Re: Idea I've been mulling over that I'd like some input on

                    Originally posted by Tasselfoot
                    Afro, I tried to come up with a way for this to work in TWG22. Whorli wanted to use the vigi, but as we know, it is a flawed role. So I tried to help her work it so that the vigi couldn't tell anyone he was the vigi. She got all confused, and it wasn't used in the game.

                    I'd imagine there was some discussion about it in the TWG22 signup thread if you wanted to look into it.
                    I will be submitting a hosting application for the next TWG, and trust me, I have quite a few ways to make a game of incompletion work.

                    Comment

                    • #11
                      Retired BOSS
                      FFR Simfile Author
                      Tasselfoot
                      • Jul 2003
                      • 25185

                      Re: Idea I've been mulling over that I'd like some input on

                      Good for you. We'll see when you submit it, won't we.
                      RIP

                      Comment

                      • #12
                        User6773

                        Re: Idea I've been mulling over that I'd like some input on

                        Having a no AIM, no PM game kind of has a similar effect. I like the idea of a no AIM, no PM (NANP) game because it makes sure that everything said is said publicly.

                        Comment

                        • #13
                          FFR Hall of Fame
                          FFR Simfile Author
                          aperson
                          • Jul 2003
                          • 3435

                          Re: Idea I've been mulling over that I'd like some input on

                          Originally posted by chardish
                          Having a no AIM, no PM game kind of has a similar effect. I like the idea of a no AIM, no PM (NANP) game because it makes sure that everything said is said publicly.
                          Totaly unenforcable outside of the bounds of reason, though.

                          I don't think you could trust someone to hold to those rules.

                          Comment

                          • #14
                            User6773

                            Re: Idea I've been mulling over that I'd like some input on

                            Originally posted by aperson
                            Totaly unenforcable outside of the bounds of reason, though.

                            I don't think you could trust someone to hold to those rules.
                            It's more black-and-white than "you can't tell anyone your role, but you can insinuate it."

                            Comment

                            • #15
                              FFR Player
                              blahblah18
                              • Aug 2004
                              • 1662

                              Re: Idea I've been mulling over that I'd like some input on

                              you should be able to let wolves communicate outside then
                              but for now... postCount++

                              Comment

                              Working...