TWG XV Host Voting 4 srs

[Tasselfoot]

Kilga.... that is a bad idea. Do this:

The 3 wolves are picked first. They contact you with who they want as their 4th. THEN you choose the seer, guardian, psychic, vigilante. This insures the wolves get who they want and also that they don't pick any blues.


PS - If I'm not a wolf... pick me and make me MW. Also, Vigilante... do not, under ANY circumstances, kill someone without being 100% sure they are a wolf. In the past 2 vigilante games that we've had, 1 didn't get a kill and the other killed a human because of stupidity. It is better to not use your ability than to kill a human. Also, with 4 wolves and 18 people, the wolves have a slight edge, especially with the ability to pick their 4th. To balance that, the vigilante MUST be accurate in their kill.

[Kilgamayan]

Mmm.

All right, then, I guess I'll do that.

Also, I may hand the Witness out as a special role. This way, they can choose when to use it (as opposed to it randomly popping up), but they may also get killed before it happens in return.

I'll let you all know what I've decided when I hand out special roles.

EDIT:

It's 9 to 0, can we just say he wins so we can get a time for sign ups set?

Not unless Tps wants to give up.

[Tasselfoot]

That would be good Kilga... Vigilante having their 1 kill at any time + Witness having their 1 free wolf seering at any time seems fairly equal to 18 players and 4 wolves... Witness pretty much knocks the wolves down to 3 though...

IMO, Witness uses their power night 1, announces it day 1... they are now a 100% confirmed human and there are only 3 wolves left. So... maybe that is a little too powerful.

[JurseyRider734]

Yeah. I'm always late but I am going to put in Kilga even though it's done. Make sure i'm here for the signups next time =(

[blahblah18]

what tass said about witness is dead-on accurate

[_BBQ_]

Mmm.

All right, then, I guess I'll do that.

Also, I may hand the Witness out as a special role. This way, they can choose when to use it (as opposed to it randomly popping up), but they may also get killed before it happens in return.

I'll let you all know what I've decided when I hand out special roles.

EDIT:

It's 9 to 0, can we just say he wins so we can get a time for sign ups set?

Not unless Tps wants to give up.

but the wolf can easily post first because the wolf is supposed to be notified the witness saw them and the wolf can be like im a witness and person x is a wolf.

[Kilgamayan]

Yeah, the other thing about announcing it early is that it doesn't necessarily give the witness enough time to prove their humanity. And even if the psychic sees that a human has died, no one else human will know unless they get in contact with someone somehow.

It'll be a game-time decision.

[Tasselfoot]

This is how I see it...

Only the psychic has the ability to confirm/deny the story of the events on day 1, as clearly... the witness attacks the wolf, wolf comes back and attacks the witness. day 2, psychic says if a wolf or human died. Yes, the does mean the psychic has to announce himself... but, figure the guardian will then protect them in the future, or something like that. Then, there are now TWO confirmed humans... or, in the case of the wolves coming out against the witness and then again coming out against the psychic, the worst that happens are 1 human and 1 psychic are lynched in exchange for 2 wolves over the 1st 4 days... which seems to be much much much better for the humans than the wolves.

[Tps222]

Ummm, I give up.

Maybe next time....

[lightdarkness]

Kilga wins

Make your sign up topic