XOON 4 submissions open

[moches]

Re: XOON 4 submissions open

(Scylaax) Acid Vision
See Gundam's notes. Solid file with a bit of replay value. Accepted.

(Ophi) Horatio
Patterns in this are annoying as hell (oh gee, trills....) Agree with Gundam, file seems generic and sort of been there, done that. I dunno if color notes will make it much better. Bad song choice. Rejected.

(Ophi) Necrofantasia
Okay, Gundam has basically done all my work for me with his review. He hit it pretty much nail on. I'm honestly torn about this file so Maybe/Pending until I hear from TranceCore.

(Scylaax) Nothing Beats
Pretty good jack theory. Hands seem overused at times. The beginning of the solo isn't straight 16ths, listen a bit more carefully. Regardless, Accepted

(Ophi) Phantom Ensemble
Good file overall that could be fixed up to be a bit more relevant (pitch relevancy in the solo could have been better, overall hand abuse.) Maybe/Pending

(Wineandbread) Poquito Mas
Surprisingly decent. Freezes at the end were not needed. 48th trills are also insane compared to the rest of the file. Fix that and I'd accept. Maybe/Pending

(CBR) Rawest Forest
See Kommisar's notes. He nailed it. Maybe/Pending

(Ophi) The Flameout
Wow either I'm lazy as hell today or Gundam's doing a really good job. Probably both hahaa. File isn't anything special sorry dude :sad face: Rejected.

(Scylaax) Tick
Okay this wasn't a short file hehe. Not a bad file but lacks a bit of zest for me as well as feeling rather unpolished. Not that it's not well made, but it's a bit of a toughie to read. Maybe/Pending

[Gundam-Dude]

Re: XOON 4 submissions open

(Scylaax) Acid Vision
Measures 58-62 are pretty inconsistent with the rest of the file. Straightforward and technical MA file. Only thing that irked me are the missing stops/BPM Gimmicks. Lightly Accepted.

(OperationStrawbarry) Biometrics Warrior HD Test
Dumpload of inconsistencies. Generic and found no replay value in this. Rejected.

(Ophi) Horatio
Technically perfect but I didn't find much replay value in this (actually found this to be pretty generic). There was a lack of rainbow note theory as well which would've spiced up the chart and made it infinitely better. Rejected.

(Ophi) Necrofantasia
You hit my soft spot for Touhou metal files. After Measure 92, there are a bunch of missing hand placements which are inconsistent with the rest of the file. Pretty much an easier version of Nick's chart but a bit overlayered and underlayered in sections. Maybe/Pending until I hear from moches or TranceCore.

(Scylaax) Nothing Beats
Nice Jack theory. Solo was pretty cool too. Accepted

(Ophi) Phantom Ensemble
More Touhou metal oh god yes. Cool file. Only complaint is that from Measure 46-57 or so your steps weren't very song relevant and seemed randomly placed at times. Accepted

(Wineandbread) Poquito Mas
Freezes for the hands near the end weren't necessarily needed. File is rather short and there wasn't anything notable in this that would make me replay this. Decent file and all but not enough to warrant an accept from me at this point. Rejected

(CBR) Rawest Forest
Very FFR-esque but pretty much see Kommi's notes on your file. Rejected.

(Ophi) Tewi Within
Touhou metal orgasm. You sure love one-handed trills. Alright file overall though it is underlayered during sections. Think I like Scylaax's version more despite your file being shorter and straightforward so Rejected.

(Ophi) The Flameout
Too short of a file. Straightforward but I found no replay value in this. There was absolutely nothing notable in this chart that would warrant an accept from me so Rejected.

(Scylaax) Tick
Haha didn't realize this was a Touhou remix until it finally built up. For a short file, there wasn't anything notable in this that stood out. Didn't find very much replay value in this either and it was lacking some rainbow theory. Rejected

[dood gone krazee]

Re: XOON 4 submissions open

I've gotten feedback on my file so far and have decided to make two charts.

One that is layered and fits the song appropriately.
And one that is layered even more, representing the song less, but therefore giving difficulty since most people want hard files. :\
Might finish tomorrow. Still have until the 18th to submit though.

[Wineandbread]

Re: XOON 4 submissions open

Last minute submission (take 2) sent

It's better than my last one imo

[Gundam-Dude]

Re: XOON 4 submissions open

I already did that song but it's unreleased because it's not that good

[dood gone krazee]

Re: XOON 4 submissions open

ver tru ver tru.
still, im planning on doing Vanishment of Hatsune Miku if you guise dun hurry up! D;<

Lmfao I was going to do that one too. Not for this pack though, a future Xoon.

Kommi why the **** did you change your username

[WTFBrandon]

Re: XOON 4 submissions open

but ya not judgin for da pack =<

ver tru ver tru.
still, im planning on doing Vanishment of Hatsune Miku if you guise dun hurry up! D;<

[dood gone krazee]

Re: XOON 4 submissions open

send ya stuff before its too late. you have less than a week left and i still havent gotten any dgk submissions



mike hurry da fuc up step somethin

Half done with Anti The Holic and a day of nothing tomorrow, don't worry they're coming. 8)

[Rin-Dude]

Re: XOON 4 submissions open

but ya not judgin for da pack =<

[WTFBrandon]

Re: XOON 4 submissions open

Auto-accept from me and kommi if your file is fun and structured well (e.g. Love Ward, Cinnamon Roll & 0). Either way, I automatically get dibs on all Vocaloid related graphics.

ugh, add brandon to that list ya ******

[Rin-Dude]

Re: XOON 4 submissions open

send ya stuff before its too late. you have less than a week left and i still havent gotten any dgk submissions



mike hurry da fuc up step somethin

[Choofers]

Re: XOON 4 submissions open

Oh **** son, send me some vocoloid.

[dood gone krazee]

Re: XOON 4 submissions open

Okay I cut Anti The Holic to about 2 minutes 49 seonds instead of 5 minutes. Will finish this along with maybe a MAD. (Xepher Shuzo Mix) that'll equal 4 files in 2-3 weeks, record time. 8)

[Gundam-Dude]

Re: XOON 4 submissions open

that too

[Rin-Dude]

Re: XOON 4 submissions open

vocaloid increases your chances from me by 40%