KeyBoard Ultimix: Now Accepting!

[kommisar[os]]

Re: KeyBoard Ultimix: Now Accepting!

experience as in if you can make good simfiles, you know what a good simfile consists of

for example : http://www.flashflashrevolution.com/...p?songid=20101

[BEN.(SPEIRS) 7.5]

Re: KeyBoard Ultimix: Now Accepting!

:P

[SulferDragon]

Re: KeyBoard Ultimix: Now Accepting!

Nah, I'm not sick, but I am kind of sleep deprived. I have this weird feeling of being hyper and tired at the same time, makes it hard to concentrate.

Maybe I should drink more coke, haha >_>

[BEN.(SPEIRS) 7.5]

Re: KeyBoard Ultimix: Now Accepting!

Get well soon Sulfer

I'll start judging once school dies down a bit - it's pretty damn hectic at the moment =/

[Professor Raine]

Re: KeyBoard Ultimix: Now Accepting!

>_> Let's avoid arguments so this thread won't get locked.

[SulferDragon]

Re: KeyBoard Ultimix: Now Accepting!

This is supposed to be a simfile pack, not a free critique thread. I could easily just reject the files without an explanation, but I at least tell you what's wrong. I'm not going into full detail saying, "*insert measures* are blah blah." I don't want to sound rude, but I have other things to do. If you can't figure it out then get better, and come back to the file later on.

[moches]

Re: KeyBoard Ultimix: Now Accepting!

Mute City Remix - ? - It didn't seem to make much sense at all. Make it better then the FFR version and I can accept it.

Midnight Dragon - +? - Some parts are stepped bad, but some parts are alright. With some work it could be decent.

Final Fantasy 3 Battle - +? - Not bad actually, but still needs work. There are a lot of sixteenths that go to nothing, some that are completely ignored, and it fades out really really bad xD. Layer it more, or something.

I'm really, really, really, REALLY sorry to bug you like this at 11 PM.

Mute City Remix- I'm pretty sure I understepped measures 1 to 12. I think 13 to 28 were stepped decently. After that, I guess it fell apart. I'll take another look.

Midnight- Which parts?

FF3- Heavy or Oni?

[Professor Raine]

Re: KeyBoard Ultimix: Now Accepting!

I said I'm not feeling well...

Oh, sorry man. I didn't notice that.

[SulferDragon]

Re: KeyBoard Ultimix: Now Accepting!

I said I'm not feeling well, but okay, you asked for it...


Mystic Mansion: Very inconsistent use of jumps/hands. Too many/inconsistent use of holds. Far to long for such an easy file. Has a lot more potential for layering (considering you obviously were).

[Professor Raine]

Re: KeyBoard Ultimix: Now Accepting!

Ummm, and since we're on the topic, got any critique for me Sulfur?

[SulferDragon]

Re: KeyBoard Ultimix: Now Accepting!

Blah, I haven't played everything, because I'm not feeling well.

Here's what I did though:


Spinning With You - ? - repetitive in general. bad song for stepping. understepped at parts.

Mute City Remix - ? - It didn't seem to make much sense at all. Make it better then the FFR version and I can accept it.

Midnight Dragon - +? - Some parts are stepped bad, but some parts are alright. With some work it could be decent.

Final Fantasy 3 Battle - +? - Not bad actually, but still needs work. There are a lot of sixteenths that go to nothing, some that are completely ignored, and it fades out really really bad xD. Layer it more, or something.

EHHS - ? - Quit out cuz it clearly wasn't better then other files I've played of this song. Maybe try stepping something that hasn't already been done 50 times?

Beethoven Virus - ? - So understpped. Some parts are offbeat, neeeds more jumps on da percusionz.

BB Euro - > - Quit out. WAAAAYYY understepped, YNS, etc.

Arrabbiata - ? - See EHHS.

Nothing accepted here, at least not from me >_>

Like in number of sims released or what?

No, you just really need more simfile experience. Simfile count means nothing. Play some of the popular sims, lurk around, and learn from what you see.

[moches]

Re: KeyBoard Ultimix: Now Accepting!

Nope, sorry. You need quite a bit more experience.

Like in number of sims released or what?

[SulferDragon]

Re: KeyBoard Ultimix: Now Accepting!

I've got too much time on my hands. Can I judge next round?

Nope, sorry. You need quite a bit more experience.

[verra]

Re: KeyBoard Ultimix: Now Accepting!

Yay! Finally I get to see if it got in .

[moches]

Re: KeyBoard Ultimix: Now Accepting!

I've got too much time on my hands. Can I judge next round?