Re: FFR Community Pack 4 Released!
sigged
<3
I think stargroup basically hit the nail on the head: my perception of a file has to do with seeing 1) what the stepartist set out to achieve and 2) how well that objective is executed. it's really a matter of whether what you do is reflective of the song, imo.
the tricky part (and where a lot of the disagreement about "fun factor" and "technicality" and all that jazz) becomes separating your personal taste with what you have to evaluate above. there's so many ways to play/interpret this game. I wouldn't say any of them are wrong. the problem is that people paint in broad strokes, saying that something is "overly technical" when it's clear that it wasn't specifically made for them in the first place. it's like, I hate horror films, but does that mean that I'm going to shit on a well-made movie just because I don't like it and no matter how good it was I wouldn't have liked it in the first place? that's not fair to the creator (in any medium), imo. he/she has no obligation to me.
and that's fine, it's personal taste. at least they're well-made.
but like bmah said, I'd love to hear what more people think about the pack (aka more reviews whores)
I think stargroup basically hit the nail on the head: my perception of a file has to do with seeing 1) what the stepartist set out to achieve and 2) how well that objective is executed. it's really a matter of whether what you do is reflective of the song, imo.
the tricky part (and where a lot of the disagreement about "fun factor" and "technicality" and all that jazz) becomes separating your personal taste with what you have to evaluate above. there's so many ways to play/interpret this game. I wouldn't say any of them are wrong. the problem is that people paint in broad strokes, saying that something is "overly technical" when it's clear that it wasn't specifically made for them in the first place. it's like, I hate horror films, but does that mean that I'm going to shit on a well-made movie just because I don't like it and no matter how good it was I wouldn't have liked it in the first place? that's not fair to the creator (in any medium), imo. he/she has no obligation to me.
and that's fine, it's personal taste. at least they're well-made.
but like bmah said, I'd love to hear what more people think about the pack (aka more reviews whores)
Comment