Public opinion poll on Etterna Chord cohesion removal

Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • #16
    ur worst nitemare
    FFR Simfile Author
    lurker
    • Jan 2003
    • 1659

    Re: Public opinion poll on Etterna Chord cohesion removal

    if you're near the top of game (and you fucking are) you don't need common goals as much
    people like you are not my primary concern
    some feathery f**k

    Comment

    • #17
      ur worst nitemare
      FFR Simfile Author
      lurker
      • Jan 2003
      • 1659

      Re: Public opinion poll on Etterna Chord cohesion removal

      but anyway if the debate is seriously about adding an on/off switch then honestly fuck that shit
      some feathery f**k

      Comment

      • #18
        FFR Player
        DeadSignal
        • Jan 2012
        • 136

        Re: Public opinion poll on Etterna Chord cohesion removal

        Originally posted by MSB Khelly
        Why does the sm community always have an all or nothing attitude to everything
        you are entirely free to feel this way

        nor is anyone attempting to claim otherwise


        however, the game meta's positive evolution over the years (even more noticeably so over the past couple of years) has been spearheaded by forward-thinking people that sought viable alternatives to the status quo instead of aimlessly bitching about it under a plethora of different pretexts, regardless of their actual validity

        it's too easy to be other people's judge and jury, but ultimately if you have nothing constructive to contribute in a thread dedicated to such matters - you should not say anything in them for everyone's sake including your own


        that is all
        Last edited by DeadSignal; 05-12-2017, 04:20 PM. Reason: initially quoted the wrong thing lozl

        Comment

        • #19
          The Dominator
          Dynam0
          • Sep 2005
          • 9024

          Re: Public opinion poll on Etterna Chord cohesion removal

          just take it out, stupid mechanic

          Comment

          • #20
            FFR Player
            EtienneSM
            • Jan 2013
            • 1753

            Re: Public opinion poll on Etterna Chord cohesion removal

            Fuck the mashers

            Take it out
            Quality quotes:

            Originally posted by KgZ
            enjoy having every guy ask if they can get some love on their weiner
            Originally posted by Izzy
            I also like the nps scale. The standard ITG scale for harder files is blown out of proportion and no longer makes sense.
            Originally posted by kommisar
            nps is still a better idea for ratings
            Originally posted by klimtkiller
            there is 1 tip for people going to college. When you're in college, you'll be 16, which is the age where (where i live) you can get laid lawfully. basically, get laid asap when they look the best.
            Originally posted by Rapta
            My logic is that the brain processes in 60 FPS so I play 60 FPS.

            Comment

            • #21
              I am leonid
              FFR Simfile Author
              FFR Music Producer
              leonid
              • Oct 2008
              • 8080

              Re: Public opinion poll on Etterna Chord cohesion removal

              Take it out. The problem with CC is that it is inconsistent with the rest of the system (and the rest of all the vsrgs) in terms of when to reward and when to punish. It allows players to split chords into disastrous degrees and still get marvs, and at the same time also drops fuck all if they hit three notes out of a quad perfectly and miss one note. Lower the judge option if you want sm to be more forgiving towards mashing. Spread a quad into four notes 1pixel away from one another and suddenly you are playing a different game. It makes zero sense. CC is an objectively wrong mechanic. Remember what GENRE we are talking about. It should reward accuracy and consistency. Nothing else matters
              Last edited by leonid; 05-12-2017, 08:06 PM.



              Proud member of Team No

              Comment

              • #22
                Batch Manager
                Game Manager
                FFR Simfile Author
                DossarLX ODI
                • Mar 2008
                • 15027

                Re: Public opinion poll on Etterna Chord cohesion removal

                I'm surprised nobody mentioned the phenomenon of having the "color gimmick" and how it's basically a way to bypass chord cohesion. For example, place one 4th note, and then three more 4th notes after it and make the BPM something stupid like 1 million and put it back to normal after (this creates a quad with no chord cohesion). Not even mentioning accuracy or consistency, being able to create the same pattern two different ways but having to register it differently is more problematic in my eyes.
                Last edited by DossarLX ODI; 05-12-2017, 09:13 PM.
                Originally posted by hi19hi19
                oh boy, it's STIFF, I'll stretch before I sit down at the computer so not I'm not as STIFF next time I step a file

                Comment

                • #23
                  ur worst nitemare
                  FFR Simfile Author
                  lurker
                  • Jan 2003
                  • 1659

                  Re: Public opinion poll on Etterna Chord cohesion removal

                  you and leonid both thought of that and that's honestly a way better reason than anything i had thought of before
                  some feathery f**k

                  Comment

                  • #24
                    FFR Player
                    Ristyy
                    • Nov 2016
                    • 141

                    Re: Public opinion poll on Etterna Chord cohesion removal

                    just make it an option

                    Comment

                    • #25
                      FFR Player
                      MinaciousGrace
                      • Dec 2007
                      • 4317

                      Re: Public opinion poll on Etterna Chord cohesion removal

                      the issue isnt whether or not cc should be removed its whether to scale or not scale down the additional points in each chord after removal to retain the same point distribution of files before/after


                      for the record:
                      cc is being removed and it will not be optional
                      dp is being removed and it will not be optional unless you theme it back in, in which case why stop there just go full retard and use sm6 scoring for +9 points for each mine you don't hit

                      I shouldn't even be spending time arguing why further fracturing the community by giving players a myriad of options for playing, which are at best stupid and at worst objectively wrong (as leonid has pointed out), is stupid and irresponsible

                      if you don't care about scores being comparable and think "wow more options is objectively better" then just fuck off and play j2l1 sm5default with nofail 6x nojumps added mines super shuffle noholds and haste mod

                      the important part of that is the "fuck off" part

                      this entire community and more importantly everything that it has generated, which you are an active recipient of, has only arisen because a group of players came together and agreed upon a consensus for set of defined rules for what constitutes valid score comparison

                      it is literally the foundational principle of the community-- to make any argument in any direction invoking "who cares just let people do whatever they want" is automatically invalid and you can feel free to go on reddit and co-ruminate with the other people there on how cmods are cheating and the like

                      if any of you ever want to see a functional leaderboard and scores/stats tracking site then you all have to adhere to a single standard of scoring anyway
                      Last edited by MinaciousGrace; 05-12-2017, 10:32 PM.

                      Comment

                      • #26
                        I am leonid
                        FFR Simfile Author
                        FFR Music Producer
                        leonid
                        • Oct 2008
                        • 8080

                        Re: Public opinion poll on Etterna Chord cohesion removal

                        Don't scale anything; treat quad as if you hit four notes. As mentioned before, you can simulate a "quad" by putting four notes really close together. IMO the actual quad and the simulated quad should count the same way



                        Proud member of Team No

                        Comment

                        • #27
                          FFR Player
                          MinaciousGrace
                          • Dec 2007
                          • 4317

                          Re: Public opinion poll on Etterna Chord cohesion removal

                          and let me be clear the reason dp and cc aren't optional isn't because I'm vehemently opposed to the concepts in principle (which I am, but that isn't the reason)

                          the reason is because I'm not writing separate calculators and/or replay systems and/or scoring systems and then making those systems interact functionally with each other just so some of you can feel like special snowflakes

                          this isnt osumania where "chord cohesion" is going to be some fucking retarded score multiplier mod hahahahaha!!!! great system real sense logic!!!

                          i'm not making more work for myself when i'm already thanklessly doing everything in the first place just because some of you cry about change when, and this is important, none of you would fucking notice or care after a month of play anyway (unless you just blindmash handstream in which case idk either stop blindmashing handstream or quit not my problem)

                          so lets keep it on topic and idk at least try to formulate some sort of argument beyond "but that's what i want"

                          Comment

                          • #28
                            FFR Player
                            MinaciousGrace
                            • Dec 2007
                            • 4317

                            Re: Public opinion poll on Etterna Chord cohesion removal

                            Originally posted by leonid
                            Don't scale anything; treat quad as if you hit four notes. As mentioned before, you can simulate a "quad" by putting four notes really close together. IMO the actual quad and the simulated quad should count the same way
                            for the record i initially came up with the idea of scaling for a number of reasons but after a lengthy amount of testing and thinking about how it affects numerous systems and further planned development i am leaning towards unscaled

                            also it took you like what 10 minutes to formulate literally the strongest argument for unscaling that i've seen thus far (and the only legitimate one other than my own reasons)

                            smh i mean i guess this is the community that took a half decade to figure out mirror isnt cheating

                            Comment

                            • #29
                              FFR Player
                              Chocille
                              • Jun 2013
                              • 135

                              Re: Public opinion poll on Etterna Chord cohesion removal

                              chord cohesion sucks

                              you don't get good with chord cohesion
                              see how all the top bms players play?
                              they dont need that, because bms made them good
                              bms doesn't use chord cohesion

                              now get good and stop complaining
                              Last edited by Chocille; 05-12-2017, 10:51 PM.

                              Comment

                              • #30
                                FFR Player
                                Ristyy
                                • Nov 2016
                                • 141

                                Re: Public opinion poll on Etterna Chord cohesion removal

                                well dang i guess if it's not an option, i'd lean towards having each note count as a whole note; especially since as mentioned you can make 4 separate notes count as 4 whole notes already. I don't have anything to add other than what's already been said :\
                                Last edited by Ristyy; 05-12-2017, 10:57 PM.

                                Comment

                                Working...