Winter Wind Etude

[ipekili]

Re: Winter Wind Etude

lol this thread and bump

but srsly, i'd love to see a vid of you playing it on piano

unfortunately i don't have it completed yet. when, not if, i win the competition, there might be a video of the winner

[popsicle_3000]

Re: Winter Wind Etude

lol this thread and bump

but srsly, i'd love to see a vid of you playing it on piano

[ipekili]

Re: Winter Wind Etude

I don't think he's trying to improve his piano skills (let alone finger dexterity) by playing Winter Wind Etude lol, he's playing the file just because he enjoys listening to it.

yes indeed. that is another reason why i play it. so what if i'm mashing the keys, i'm still hearing it which helps me in playing it on the real piano

[EzExZeRo7497]

Re: Winter Wind Etude

I don't think he's trying to improve his piano skills (let alone finger dexterity) by playing Winter Wind Etude lol, he's playing the file just because he enjoys listening to it. As much as I discourage mashing and all I don't see a problem with a new player just playing a file to a song that they really enjoy, although they're nowhere near the skill to play it. It's just that the player wouldn't enjoy the file fully because they're not able to hit the patterns properly, but since they just like the song and not care about the score I don't see a reason why mashing shouldn't be allowed. He's playing casually. Nothing wrong with that. He could be playing files that's more geared towards his skill level, but it's his choice to play whatever he wants anyway.

qqwref's posts are uncalled for (or at least, way too blunt), there's nothing wrong with mashing when you're playing casually. They do what they want. If they don't wish to improve and just play that file, it's not anyone's problem except the player's.

basically

or maybe because some ppl just like playing along to a song they enjoy? Which is obviously the case since OP is trying to learn it on the piano. It was unnecessary to say, let ppl play what they want.

Good luck with the competition ipekili

[DossarLX ODI]

Re: Winter Wind Etude

Mashing files way out of your skill level isn't going to improve finger dexterity, which directly relates to the OP that wanted to learn Winter Wind Etude on piano. Mashing on the piano isn't going to improve any dexterity or technique whatsoever.

The main problem here is that a legitimate suggestion is being given (with a sarcastic "AAAing it on FFR is a good start" post, but that really means to play properly instead of mashing in this case) and then a bandwagon comes in rejecting said suggestions that are valid

What was also mentioned is also completely legitimate: Since it is so easy to pass songs on FFR because 1 good or perfect makes up for every miss or boo, anyone can mash through the harder songs and pass. Sure, you can just mash everything however you want, but it's not going to improve any dexterity or technique. Same goes for mashing on the piano.

[hi19hi19]

Re: Winter Wind Etude

Quality bump, excellent thread overall


p.s. Good luck in your competition man

[L.B.D.D]

Re: Winter Wind Etude

oh right people were bashing qqwref for making unnecessarily hostile posts towards somebody who was talking about trying to play winter wind etude on the piano

[L.B.D.D]

Re: Winter Wind Etude

daddy dossar to the rescue of kid kkwref

but will he be able to fend off the playground bullies from our classic nerd qrwfeff? ??




ps these are really helpful posts that relate to winter wind etude on the piano

AAAing it on FFR is a good start.

You can stop posting scores now, ipekili. You're obviously just mashing through the file, without the skill to actually play it. Maybe work up to it by working on songs you can read and hit properly. (And there are threads in the Brag Board for random FFR scores, anyway.)

wait..

[DossarLX ODI]

Re: Winter Wind Etude

Maybe work up to it by working on songs you can read and hit properly.

ipekili, what qqwref was suggesting was starting at a lower difficulty first so you can read AND hit the song you are playing. 1000+ boos isn't an indicator of reading or hitting the song, and it's never a good idea to start that high in anything.

Also the posts that bashed qqwref in this thread were incredibly stupid. Get off of him already guys

[Tim Allen]

Re: Winter Wind Etude

way to give him a piece of your mind 3 months later

[ipekili]

Re: Winter Wind Etude

oh and btw, if i am able to play the whole thing on the piano in 2 years (march 2015) i will be playing it in a chopin competition in miami FL. the winner gets an all expence paid trip to poland!!! oh, and qqwref, please leave this post. must i remind you that i am still new to ffr. i haven't been a member for even half a year yet. please stop being a downer to newer players. who cares if i'm just mashing the keys? i can still see the arrows and begin to learn the patterns.

[Choofers]

Re: Winter Wind Etude

you know ipekili if you mash enough and don't get any misses you can be in the top 200 scores because ffr scoring engine blows

[ninjaKIWI]

Re: Winter Wind Etude

Look at the scores - 1000+ boos. He's not playing along with it at all.

ipekili, if you can use the R^3 engine, you may want to try playing the song at a lower rate so you can actually read it. That way you will be able to get a feel for the chart. You won't improve at all by just smashing the keys for three minutes.


So could you.

You're not a newer member that I'm trying to keep into the game.

[qqwref]

Re: Winter Wind Etude

or maybe because some ppl just like playing along to a song they enjoy? Which is obviously the case since OP is trying to learn it on the piano.

Look at the scores - 1000+ boos. He's not playing along with it at all.

ipekili, if you can use the R^3 engine, you may want to try playing the song at a lower rate so you can actually read it. That way you will be able to get a feel for the chart. You won't improve at all by just smashing the keys for three minutes.

You could have said it in a much nicer way.

So could you.

[ninjaKIWI]

Re: Winter Wind Etude

I happen to think mashing through hard charts is a waste of time, and that new players ought to play songs they can actually follow. It's an easy trap to fall into since FFR makes it far too easy to pass files. But hey, if you need to call me names for some reason, go ahead.

You could have said it in a much nicer way.