Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

[Patashu]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

HEY

got permission for Syrsa.

Sv: Re: Sv: requesting permission to use your music for www.flashflashrevolution.com
yes, but whatever song it is, I allow you to use.
Sent to: patashu

http://www.youtube.com/user/SYRSAmusic#p/u

[TC_Halogen]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

I've gone through and tabulated how many points each file has gotten for whatever group they were sitting in, based on how many points they have. Files are in order from point values.

Based off of this:

BTW I was thinking of 13 points or more as borderline but that's a bit harsh.
So, new idea is like these, this time.

[Accept]
+ + + (15)
+ + +. (14)
+ +. +. (13)
+ + +? (13)
+ + ? (12)
+ +. +? (12)
+. +. +. (12)
+ + - (11)

[Borderline]
+ +. ? (11)
+. +. +? (11)
+ +? +? (11)
+ +. - (10)

[Reject]
+. +. ? (10)
+. +? +? (10)

Group 1
Judges:
Korygon, Patashu, psychoangel691

Chopin - Valse Op.69 No.2: [+], [+], [+] (15)
Cette Annee: [+], [+], [+] (15)
Csikos Post - [+], [+], [+] (15)
Chase You Down: [+], [+], [+] (15)
Bit Blue: [+], [+], [+] (15)
Arrrrr: [+], [+], [+] (15)
Loituma: [+], [+], [+.] (14)
C7 Funk: [+], [+], [+.] (14)
Badinerie: [+.], [+], [+] (14)
Blame it on Bad Luck: [+], [+.], [+.] (13)
Chopin - OP.10 No.9: [+.], [+], [+.] (13)
Bury the Hatchet: [+], [+.], [+.] (13)
Clockwork - [+], [+.], [+.] (13)
All of Yours (Heavy): [+.], [+], [+?] (12)
Banjo Kazooie Theme: [+.], [+.], [+.] (12)
11ELEVEN: [+.], [+.], [+.] (12)
Above: [+.], [+.], [+.] (12)
Black and White: [+.], [?], [+.] (10)
Action Winter Journey: [+.], [?], [+?] (9)
Dead Hooker Smoothie - [+?], [?], [?] (7)
Adcar: [?], [?], [?] (6)
Death Match - [?], [?], [-] (5)
Lazy Summer Days: [-], [-], [-] (3)
Battlefield: [-], [-], [-] (3)
Death Moon - [-], [-], [-] (3)
Darkshark AAA'd this - [--], [--], [--] (0)

Group 2
Judges:
jimerax, TC_Halogen, Silvuh

***Directly Perfectly: [<], [<], [<]

Floating Through Time: [+], [+], [+?] (13)
Greensleeves: [+], [+.], [+.] (13)
Grocery Escape Plan: [+.], [+?], [+] (12)
Directly Perfectly [Short Edit]: [+.], [+.], [+?] (11)
Extreme Dishwasher Race: [+?], [+.], [+.] (11)
Dreamin' In The 80's [+.], [+.], [+?] (11)
Eating Crow: [+?], [+?], [+] (11)
Death Traveller: [+.], [+.], [?] (10)
Disco 80's: [+.], [+.], [?] (10)
Experiment: [+?], [+], [?] (10)
Lunar Dial: [+?], [+?], [+?] (9)
ESC - Amplified T Squared Mix: [+?], [+?], [?] (8)
Hate: [+?], [?], [+?] (8)
Holy War: [?], [?], [+?] (7)
Gene Gadget Zone: [-], [+.], [?] (7)
For FFR v2: [?], [?], [?] (6)
Happy Guy Falls Off A Not So Happy Mountain: [?], [?], [?] (6)
Fruhlingsrauschen: [?], [-], [?] (5)
Dumpstream: [+?], [-], [-] (5)
Honey Cookie: [+?], [-], [-] (5)
Dizzay: [?], [-], [-] (4)
deco stop: [?], [-], [-] (4)
Epileptic Crisis: [-], [?], [-] (4)
Field of Snow v2: [-], [-], [-] (3)
Hand Throw: [-], [-], [-] (3)

Group 3
Judges:
Gundam-Dude, who_cares973, Vote4Nixon

***{Lazy Summer Days}: [...], [-], [...]
***Loituma: [+.], [+.], [...]
***Field of Snow: [?], [?], [...]

Down: [+], [+], [+.] (14)
It's Only Natural: [+.], [+.], [+] (13)
Jamais Deux: [+.], [+.], [+] (13)
Over the Ocean: [+], [+.], [+.] (13)
Overdrive: [+], [+], [?] (12)
Pathos: [+.], [+.], [+.] (12)
Little Star: [+?], [+], [+.] (12)
Metropolis: [+.], [+.], [?] (10)
Kirby 64: [+.], [?], [+.] (10)
Northern Lights: [+?], [+.], [+?] (10)
Honki Sentai Majirenaa: [+?], [+.], [+?] (10)
Opening (SSBM): [+?], [+.], [?] (9)
Monday: [-], [+.], [+?] (8)
NaiNai69: [+.], [-], [+?] (8)
Infectious: [+?], [?], [+?] (8)
Naruto Theme - Sea. 4: [?], [+.], [?] (8)
Perfect Insanity: [?], [?], [+.] (8)
Lightning Strikes Again: [?], [?], [+?] (7)
Luigi's Mansion: [+?], [?], [?] (7)
Over the Rave F.O.R. Remix: [+?], [?], [?] (7)
naTivEfAcE: [-], [?], [+?] (6)
It's Raining Lolis!!: [+?], [-], [?] (6)
Islamey: [?], [?], [-] (5)
It's a Zombie's World: [-], [?], [-] (4)
Oh lord, your wife just got run over by an ice cream truck: [-], [?], [-] (4)
In A Trance Redux: [-], [-], [-] (3)

Group 4
Judges: kommisar, i love you, bmah

**Saikyou OX Keikaku: [-], [<], [<] (?)

The Fusion: [+], [+], [+] (15)
Yellow Lasers: [+], [+], [+] (15)
RAN: [+], [+], [+] (15)
No Running Water: [+], [+], [+.] (14)
Prokofiev: [+.], [+], [+] (14)
Sparkle Downer: [+], [+], [+.] (14)
Song of the Second Moon: [+?], [+], [+] (13)
Sakura Blue Sky: [+], [+.], [+.] (13)
Smash Podcast: [+], [+.], [+.] (13)
Voodoo People: [+], [+.], [+.] (13)
Run Kirby Run: [+.], [+.], [+.] (12)
Pure Ruby: [+.], [+.], [+.] (12)
Try to Star: [+.], [+.], [+.] (12)
White Walls: [+.], [+.], [+.] (12)
Rondo a Capriccio: [+.], [+.], [+?] (11)
Wolf by Night, Human in Dreams: [+.], [-], [+.] (9)
Mathematics: [+?], [+?], [+?] (9)
This Could've Been Nice: [+?], [+.], [?] (9)
Radiant Moonlight: [-], [-], [+?] (5)
Take up the Cross: [-], [-], [+?] (5)
Pokemon: [-], [-], [?] (4)
Shooogun: [-], [-], [?] (4)
Yellowknife: [-], [-], [?] (4)
Perseverence: [-], [-], [-] (3)

Are there going to be any changes to the point values?

edit: if no change; then 41 queued O_O, also lmfao at group 2's acceptance ratio

[woker-X]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

HEY

got permission for Syrsa.

Sv: Re: Sv: requesting permission to use your music for www.flashflashrevolution.com
yes, but whatever song it is, I allow you to use.
Sent to: patashu

http://www.youtube.com/user/SYRSAmusic#p/u

u.u

I think you didn't see this haha

http://www.flashflashrevolution.com/vbz/showpost.php?p=3333324&postcount=16274

edit:

I have the fixes for Greensleeves (Silvu's notes), do I send just the sm?? (or dwi)

[i love you]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

lmfao at group 2 xd

[TC_Halogen]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

swear to god, it looks like JX, Silvuh and I could not agree very often - one of us would have a rating that stands out from the other two, it's hilarious.

[who_cares973]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

now we just need songs that arent ripped from youtube and we'll be golden

gunna fix up my files and send in fixes

[Patashu]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

u.u

I think you didn't see this haha

http://www.flashflashrevolution.com/...ostcount=16274

haha nope

[AsphyxZero]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

Since I have a bit of time tonight, I'm going to fix up My Half and send it, if the batch is still open.

[bmah]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

Wow, those ratios are messed up. For big disagreements, I thought we already applied a measure to mitigate something like that - how effective WAS that measure when you see the end results of file acceptances? Haha, in any case, we need to sort crap like this out. The ratios scream out that something isn't quite right.

[Patashu]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

What if that quarter of the batch is just that much worse?

[TC_Halogen]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

I won't lie - our batch did have some weaker files. The batch that Kayla had seemed noticeably stronger in terms file quality - I was glancing over while working on One Winged Angel a while ago.

[Bluearrowll]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

This page should probably be posted somewhere on the judge page and maybe this page as well.

http://www.flashflashrevolution.com/vbz/showpost.php?p=3340237&postcount=16338

[bmah]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

I won't lie - our batch did have some weaker files. The batch that Kayla had seemed noticeably stronger in terms file quality - I was glancing over while working on One Winged Angel a while ago.

While this may be true, my suspicions regard the level of detail and scrutiny between various judges. That's what's fishy. Beyond quality of the files themselves, you have to inspect it this way - how files were evaluated.

[TC_Halogen]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

Fair enough. But what can be done to compensate for such a high amount of "error"?

[bmah]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

Nothing but experience. Which means that let's hope that simfilers AND judges learn from each batch judgment.