Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

[Zageron]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

Finally. Can ether Tass or JX please send me Corneria back. I lost the files.

[Tasselfoot]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

posted. silvuh gets the Most Shafted award... 7 songs +d by jx, 3 queue'd and 4 rejected by me.

Also, 3 things...

1. if you file was queue'd, but there are small/minor fixes suggested... and you decide to implement these suggestions... your new file will NOT be re-judged. it'll just replace the current one. so you don't need to worry about that.

2. i'm sorry, but because I'm leaving for PA in about 24 hours, i can't give people much time at all to submit for the next batch. In fact, I'm closing it in about 2 hours... I have to make sure it gets uploaded and out to Rebirth and jx before I leave. Otherwise, it's 3 weeks until I get back and can get them the notes to even start the batch.

3. I'm going to try to implement the before suggested/agreed upon batch cap... if you all forget... 2 songs + 1 resubmit + 1 file for every song queue'd in the previous batch [only including batches in which you submitted at least one song]. so most people will have a 3 song cap, with at most 1 resubmit [most people will have 0 this time around anyway... no time to resubmit]. so most people will have 2. people like Sulfer, Silvuh, EW will have a larger cap. I don't promise this to be perfect this time around... I will be lenient. Mostly because I just don't have the time to do it properly right now before I leave tomorrow. Too many other important things to finish.

questions? let the bitching begin...

[Professor Raine]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

Uhhhh.......did you even get Strip Mine, cause it's not in the batch and I remember sending it in with The Concept of Love.

EDIT: Was the Ska Cha Cha Silvuh did by Hideki Naganuma as well?

[Tasselfoot]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

no idea.

yes... but since jx got that permission, i'm assuming he knows what it covers. talk to him about it.

[jimerax]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

let me check.

[Tasselfoot]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

just downloaded strip mine. it'll be in this batch.

[Silvuh]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

Yeah, I wasn't sure about the permission when I stepped it, but his name is in the thread with no notes to it... So I stepped it anyway ('cause it's a fun song) at the thought of "I'll just see what happens".

I did the quick fix on Otter's Dance. I had a separate file for Quickdraw I'll send in now. Procrastination on a Paper was the only one I had actually fixed up earlier. And I'm sending one I didn't send in last time.

I guess I give up on Shind Bad now. I don't know what's wrong with it currently...

Oh, and I'm sending that Forsaken Neon (uncut) file, if I may.

EDIT: Sent.

P.S. Hurrah, I never knew being shafted could be so much fun.

[dean_machine]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

Well, I don't feel like putting a lot more steps in my simfile because it would just go to more difficult to hear background music, so I'll just upload it to the sim db.

[Tasselfoot]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

current batch is, shockingly, only at 99 files... and, the only person who jumped out at having more than 3 files is DJ Cristo (and SulferDragon... but he's ok). rebirth has 4, operationstrawberry has 4... maybe unkdavar has 3/4... rest is all less.

so, i won't be capping anything. but i will be locking down the batch around 3pm EST on Thursday. doesn't give y'all much time... but it's the best i can do.

[SulferDragon]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

Hey, I would have only sent 4 files if you hadn't taken an eternity to finish this batch. I did two of those within the last 5 days.

Anyway... typical batch quoting business.

Boss Battle #1 (SulferDragon) [+?] - doubles could go with streams on middle 8ths

Wait, what? I'm confused...

Rock Armor (SulferDragon) [+?] - BPM should be half, m52-56, m116-120 coulf be more PR. melody is so unclear..

Whatever... I don't see what's wrong with the melody though.

Violet Leaves (SulferDragon) [+?] - felt missing some notes for drums (conga or bongo), basically going for them?

Fair enough.

Far Away From Home - SulferDragon - long 24th minirolls seem out of place in difficulty

Midnight Dragon, helloooooo!! I basically consider this an easier version of that.

Melted Marble - SulferDragon - what game is this from? overdoubled in places throughout

Sonic, Marble Zone.

Don't worry Tass, no more Darkesword =P

P.S. Staying up past my bedtime to see the batch notes ftw!

[rshadow8888]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

Tass, if all you think is that the repeating sound notes in the beginning should be jacks, could I just change that, leave the rest of the file the same and get it in without getting rejudged?

[Xandertrax]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

Sonata quasi una Fantasia (Xandertrax) [?] - wow we have this song...

Huh? This isn't in-game...

but quite offsync(especially around m25, after m34)

I synced it up exactly to the midi. It doesn't seem offsync at all to me, and the assist tick lines up...

m36, 94 would be ok by classic rule but reallllly annoying on FFR.

What would you suggest? I really don't see what else could go there besides trills.

[Tasselfoot]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

rshadow: no. besides, i don't want any more christmas music... we have what we need this year.

sulfer: but it isn't midnight dragon... plus, the rest of that song is challenging. besides, i still queue'd both of those... just my input. you can ignore it or you can embrace it.

[rshadow8888]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

rshadow: no. besides, i don't want any more christmas music... we have what we need this year.

ok.

just so you know, i sent the same note in my email containing my re-submition. dont bother reading it. I just wasnt sure if you would see this one.

[jimerax]

Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

replayed back some songs.

Wait, what? I'm confused...

maybe I was talking about double placement after m16.

Huh? This isn't in-game...
I synced it up exactly to the midi. It doesn't seem offsync at all to me, and the assist tick lines up...
What would you suggest? I really don't see what else could go there besides trills.

1. I didn't mean that, just surprised at permission of sonata 3.
2. sry seems it was just a gap off, like 30ms late.
3. being technically correct (PR) isn't always a good thing especially for FFR, I'd say rolls even if they don't fit the music too well (or half-speed trills). need other judge's opinion about it.