Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2

Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • #5911
    FFR Player
    FissionMailed1
    • Feb 2012
    • 1267

    Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2 (Batch #1 complete)

    Originally posted by SKG_Scintill
    This ain't no simfile database, this is a community site!
    I think you misinterpreted my post, so I'll try phrasing it differently. I am not advocating throwing all standards of quality out the window, but there needs to be a line drawn for what is fair game for judges and what isn't.

    Originally posted by Wayward Vagabond
    If people play the files and enjoy them why does it matter if they go with the guidelines?
    Because the entire foundation of judging is based on objective quality, not subjective song preferences.


    YOUR THROBBING MULTIFARIOUS LUSTFUL DESIRES ARE COMPLETED N YOUR HYPER-ORANGE SELF, YOU MAKE ME LOVE AGAIN, YOU'VE CHANGED MY HEART, MY MELANCHOLIA DISAPPEARS WHEN YOU ARE INSIDE OF ME, MY HUMAN RAGE IS TEMPERED WHEN I AM INSIDE YOU, THE SECRET IS COMMUNICATION, LONGEVITY, STAMINA, REPETITION, FURY, SOULFUL KISSING, EARPLUGS. YOU FUCKING CORPORATE COCKS AND CUNTS.

    MY ANXIETY COMPLETE, MY DESIRE REPLETE, THE TASTE OF ORANGE BLOOD AND CUM AND GREENBACKS RUNNING DOWN MY FACE. THE STREETS WILL RUN ORANGE WITH YOUR MIXTURE OF CHEETOS AND HUNDRED DOLLAR BILLS REGURGITATED AND EATEN AND SHIT OUT AGAIN AND EATEN AGAIN.

    YOU ARE MY SCULPTURE, MY SCULPTRA, MY SELF-DEFINITION. MY DEFINITION OF HUMANITY, MY HARMONY. MY HEART AND MY MIND.

    YOU ARE SO ORANGE. SO CRUNCHY. SO CONSUMABLE.

    THE NEW ORANGE UNDERGROUND IS THE ORANGE UP MY ASS. AND YOUR ASS.

    I LOVE YOU CHEETOS.

    Comment

    • #5912
      FFR Player
      04im
      • Apr 2013
      • 863

      Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2 (Batch #1 complete)





      hold da fuk up




      pizza or sushi for tmrw lunch
      "Blacker than a moonless night, hotter and more bitter than hell itself... that is coffee." 2diep4yuo
      #teamtwerk #bootyhunters

      Comment

      • #5913
        Spun a twirly fruitcake,
        FFR Simfile Author
        SKG_Scintill
        • Feb 2009
        • 3877

        Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2 (Batch #1 complete)

        Rhythm Gaming Science. Study coming to a Lincoln University near you soon!

        No, there is too little objective about simfiles to properly judge them.
        Even if there was, all files would look the same.

        A judge has his/her taste. Good thing we have several judges with different tastes huh?





        Originally posted by bluguerilla
        So Sexy Robotnik (SKG_Scintill) {.0001/10} [--]
        ___
        . RHYTHMS PR LAYERING
        . ZOMG I HAD TO QUIT OUT TERRIBLE
        .

        Comment

        • #5914
          FFR Player
          FissionMailed1
          • Feb 2012
          • 1267

          Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2 (Batch #1 complete)

          Originally posted by SKG_Scintill
          No, there is too little objective about simfiles to properly judge them.
          Even if there was, all files would look the same.
          So, what exactly is the point of a judging system, then? I disagree about all files looking the same. There are still multiple ways to step a song, what matters is that the methodology used in stepping them is consistent.


          YOUR THROBBING MULTIFARIOUS LUSTFUL DESIRES ARE COMPLETED N YOUR HYPER-ORANGE SELF, YOU MAKE ME LOVE AGAIN, YOU'VE CHANGED MY HEART, MY MELANCHOLIA DISAPPEARS WHEN YOU ARE INSIDE OF ME, MY HUMAN RAGE IS TEMPERED WHEN I AM INSIDE YOU, THE SECRET IS COMMUNICATION, LONGEVITY, STAMINA, REPETITION, FURY, SOULFUL KISSING, EARPLUGS. YOU FUCKING CORPORATE COCKS AND CUNTS.

          MY ANXIETY COMPLETE, MY DESIRE REPLETE, THE TASTE OF ORANGE BLOOD AND CUM AND GREENBACKS RUNNING DOWN MY FACE. THE STREETS WILL RUN ORANGE WITH YOUR MIXTURE OF CHEETOS AND HUNDRED DOLLAR BILLS REGURGITATED AND EATEN AND SHIT OUT AGAIN AND EATEN AGAIN.

          YOU ARE MY SCULPTURE, MY SCULPTRA, MY SELF-DEFINITION. MY DEFINITION OF HUMANITY, MY HARMONY. MY HEART AND MY MIND.

          YOU ARE SO ORANGE. SO CRUNCHY. SO CONSUMABLE.

          THE NEW ORANGE UNDERGROUND IS THE ORANGE UP MY ASS. AND YOUR ASS.

          I LOVE YOU CHEETOS.

          Comment

          • #5915
            Spun a twirly fruitcake,
            FFR Simfile Author
            SKG_Scintill
            • Feb 2009
            • 3877

            Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2 (Batch #1 complete)

            That's exactly why judges are and have to be subjective.
            To be a bit more clear, methodology alone will only get you so far. In other words, not very.
            Last edited by SKG_Scintill; 05-6-2013, 03:01 AM.





            Originally posted by bluguerilla
            So Sexy Robotnik (SKG_Scintill) {.0001/10} [--]
            ___
            . RHYTHMS PR LAYERING
            . ZOMG I HAD TO QUIT OUT TERRIBLE
            .

            Comment

            • #5916
              FFR Player
              FissionMailed1
              • Feb 2012
              • 1267

              Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2 (Batch #1 complete)

              Originally posted by SKG_Scintill
              That's exactly why judges are and have to be subjective.
              Where is the line drawn? This is the fundamental question I am getting at, and searching for an answer for. You can use "subjective" as a justification for nearly everything to either rate a file highly or downright reject it.


              YOUR THROBBING MULTIFARIOUS LUSTFUL DESIRES ARE COMPLETED N YOUR HYPER-ORANGE SELF, YOU MAKE ME LOVE AGAIN, YOU'VE CHANGED MY HEART, MY MELANCHOLIA DISAPPEARS WHEN YOU ARE INSIDE OF ME, MY HUMAN RAGE IS TEMPERED WHEN I AM INSIDE YOU, THE SECRET IS COMMUNICATION, LONGEVITY, STAMINA, REPETITION, FURY, SOULFUL KISSING, EARPLUGS. YOU FUCKING CORPORATE COCKS AND CUNTS.

              MY ANXIETY COMPLETE, MY DESIRE REPLETE, THE TASTE OF ORANGE BLOOD AND CUM AND GREENBACKS RUNNING DOWN MY FACE. THE STREETS WILL RUN ORANGE WITH YOUR MIXTURE OF CHEETOS AND HUNDRED DOLLAR BILLS REGURGITATED AND EATEN AND SHIT OUT AGAIN AND EATEN AGAIN.

              YOU ARE MY SCULPTURE, MY SCULPTRA, MY SELF-DEFINITION. MY DEFINITION OF HUMANITY, MY HARMONY. MY HEART AND MY MIND.

              YOU ARE SO ORANGE. SO CRUNCHY. SO CONSUMABLE.

              THE NEW ORANGE UNDERGROUND IS THE ORANGE UP MY ASS. AND YOUR ASS.

              I LOVE YOU CHEETOS.

              Comment

              • #5917
                Spun a twirly fruitcake,
                FFR Simfile Author
                SKG_Scintill
                • Feb 2009
                • 3877

                Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2 (Batch #1 complete)

                One emphasizes on rhythm, one emphasizes on intensity, one emphasizes on it being playable index, one emphasizes on patterns.

                All of these (and not limited by these) can make a file that can be an accepted file on FFR.
                The fact is that it represents the music in a way for the community to enjoy.
                Judges work together to figure out if that's true.





                Originally posted by bluguerilla
                So Sexy Robotnik (SKG_Scintill) {.0001/10} [--]
                ___
                . RHYTHMS PR LAYERING
                . ZOMG I HAD TO QUIT OUT TERRIBLE
                .

                Comment

                • #5918
                  FFR Player
                  FissionMailed1
                  • Feb 2012
                  • 1267

                  Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2 (Batch #1 complete)

                  Yes, I agree on the subjective factors you described in terms of judging files subjectively, but it still doesn't account for the edge factors such as what a particular judge enjoys for music, or what they think the community would enjoy.

                  There really isn't much more I can argue, and I can see where you are coming from, but in my opinion judging should be kept as objective (in my perception of objective) as possible. Hopefully what I'm getting at is more understood though, even though it most likely won't impact how judging is performed.

                  This might as well be my last post on this, I feel that I explained my position thoroughly enough.


                  YOUR THROBBING MULTIFARIOUS LUSTFUL DESIRES ARE COMPLETED N YOUR HYPER-ORANGE SELF, YOU MAKE ME LOVE AGAIN, YOU'VE CHANGED MY HEART, MY MELANCHOLIA DISAPPEARS WHEN YOU ARE INSIDE OF ME, MY HUMAN RAGE IS TEMPERED WHEN I AM INSIDE YOU, THE SECRET IS COMMUNICATION, LONGEVITY, STAMINA, REPETITION, FURY, SOULFUL KISSING, EARPLUGS. YOU FUCKING CORPORATE COCKS AND CUNTS.

                  MY ANXIETY COMPLETE, MY DESIRE REPLETE, THE TASTE OF ORANGE BLOOD AND CUM AND GREENBACKS RUNNING DOWN MY FACE. THE STREETS WILL RUN ORANGE WITH YOUR MIXTURE OF CHEETOS AND HUNDRED DOLLAR BILLS REGURGITATED AND EATEN AND SHIT OUT AGAIN AND EATEN AGAIN.

                  YOU ARE MY SCULPTURE, MY SCULPTRA, MY SELF-DEFINITION. MY DEFINITION OF HUMANITY, MY HARMONY. MY HEART AND MY MIND.

                  YOU ARE SO ORANGE. SO CRUNCHY. SO CONSUMABLE.

                  THE NEW ORANGE UNDERGROUND IS THE ORANGE UP MY ASS. AND YOUR ASS.

                  I LOVE YOU CHEETOS.

                  Comment

                  • #5919
                    VICES
                    FFR Simfile Author
                    FFR Music Producer
                    Coolboyrulez0
                    • Aug 2006
                    • 10046

                    Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2 (Batch #1 complete)

                    damn this thread is mad gay
                    https://soundcloud.com/cbrbreakcore
                    https://cbrrecords.bandcamp.com/

                    Comment

                    • #5920
                      FFR Player
                      04im
                      • Apr 2013
                      • 863

                      Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2 (Batch #1 complete)

                      "Blacker than a moonless night, hotter and more bitter than hell itself... that is coffee." 2diep4yuo
                      #teamtwerk #bootyhunters

                      Comment

                      • #5921
                        caveman pornstar
                        FFR Simfile Author
                        FFR Music Producer
                        dore
                        • Feb 2006
                        • 6317

                        Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2 (Batch #1 complete)

                        Originally posted by FissionMailed1
                        Yes, I agree on the subjective factors you described in terms of judging files subjectively, but it still doesn't account for the edge factors such as what a particular judge enjoys for music, or what they think the community would enjoy.

                        There really isn't much more I can argue, and I can see where you are coming from, but in my opinion judging should be kept as objective (in my perception of objective) as possible. Hopefully what I'm getting at is more understood though, even though it most likely won't impact how judging is performed.

                        This might as well be my last post on this, I feel that I explained my position thoroughly enough.
                        To a certain extent, a judge must be subjective, because if you start having too many objective rules you start to include obviously useless file as acceptable. To explain that, I refer to my two criteria for judging: 1) What did the author intend, and 2) How well did they execute their intentions. The majority of scoring comes from the second, more objective bubble, but you have to include the first otherwise somebody could submit a chart with the same bleep bloop 16th run for 40 minutes with the same stream copied over and over and it would be objectively acceptable. At the same time, a judge can't just reject a song because they don't like it, but there still has to be the ability to make the judgment that a song is unacceptable for the game. I'm might give a song that intrigues me a little benefit of the doubt on certain things over a boring, generic piece of crap song, but I'm not going to reject that song over its music unless the chart fails to execute the stepartist's intentions (assuming the stepartist isn't trolling ).

                        For example, I submitted a song (once under Tass, once under the new system) that was 4 seconds long and about vaginas that got rejected heartily because it was deemed not worthy of being in the game. The chart/song are a complete joke, and so I'm fine with the judges' decision on that one. Subjectivity allows you to filter out troll submissions, and while some troll submissions are worthwhile, the judges are there to decide that. I'm not familiar with the song that sparked this debate, so I'm assuming it's pretty trolly judging by the fFr DrAmAz going on because of it
                        http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IREnpHco9mw

                        Comment

                        • #5922
                          FFR Player
                          FissionMailed1
                          • Feb 2012
                          • 1267

                          Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2 (Batch #1 complete)

                          Originally posted by dore
                          I'm not familiar with the song that sparked this debate, so I'm assuming it's pretty trolly judging by the fFr DrAmAz going on because of it

                          While it might not be everybody's cup of tea, it certainly isn't a troll submission. There is musical merits to it, even if it is a bit out there to some.


                          YOUR THROBBING MULTIFARIOUS LUSTFUL DESIRES ARE COMPLETED N YOUR HYPER-ORANGE SELF, YOU MAKE ME LOVE AGAIN, YOU'VE CHANGED MY HEART, MY MELANCHOLIA DISAPPEARS WHEN YOU ARE INSIDE OF ME, MY HUMAN RAGE IS TEMPERED WHEN I AM INSIDE YOU, THE SECRET IS COMMUNICATION, LONGEVITY, STAMINA, REPETITION, FURY, SOULFUL KISSING, EARPLUGS. YOU FUCKING CORPORATE COCKS AND CUNTS.

                          MY ANXIETY COMPLETE, MY DESIRE REPLETE, THE TASTE OF ORANGE BLOOD AND CUM AND GREENBACKS RUNNING DOWN MY FACE. THE STREETS WILL RUN ORANGE WITH YOUR MIXTURE OF CHEETOS AND HUNDRED DOLLAR BILLS REGURGITATED AND EATEN AND SHIT OUT AGAIN AND EATEN AGAIN.

                          YOU ARE MY SCULPTURE, MY SCULPTRA, MY SELF-DEFINITION. MY DEFINITION OF HUMANITY, MY HARMONY. MY HEART AND MY MIND.

                          YOU ARE SO ORANGE. SO CRUNCHY. SO CONSUMABLE.

                          THE NEW ORANGE UNDERGROUND IS THE ORANGE UP MY ASS. AND YOUR ASS.

                          I LOVE YOU CHEETOS.

                          Comment

                          • #5923
                            Spun a twirly fruitcake,
                            FFR Simfile Author
                            SKG_Scintill
                            • Feb 2009
                            • 3877

                            Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2 (Batch #1 complete)

                            you so old, I stepped vah-jay-jay years ago for the DF engine

                            also, you gotta draw a line somewhere, otherwise people gonna step and send in Ionisation by Varèse.





                            Originally posted by bluguerilla
                            So Sexy Robotnik (SKG_Scintill) {.0001/10} [--]
                            ___
                            . RHYTHMS PR LAYERING
                            . ZOMG I HAD TO QUIT OUT TERRIBLE
                            .

                            Comment

                            • #5924
                              good hot
                              FFR Simfile Author
                              AlexDest
                              • Sep 2007
                              • 5309

                              Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2 (Batch #1 complete)

                              Originally posted by Coolboyrulez0
                              damn this thread is mad gay

                              Comment

                              • #5925
                                caveman pornstar
                                FFR Simfile Author
                                FFR Music Producer
                                dore
                                • Feb 2006
                                • 6317

                                Re: Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2 (Batch #1 complete)

                                Originally posted by FissionMailed1

                                While it might not be everybody's cup of tea, it certainly isn't a troll submission. There is musical merits to it, even if it is a bit out there to some.
                                ok yeah that's pretty bad but not instareject bad
                                http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IREnpHco9mw

                                Comment

                                Working...