you indexers can probably beat this but

[Reach]

Re: RE: Re: RE: Re: RE: Re: RE: you indexers can probably be

You people suck Toph's dick too much.

The a La Menthe Challenge may be perfectly synched to every note possible but LO AND BEHOLD IT ISN'T FUN AT ALL

Except for maybe indexers and what do I care about indexers because I'm not one

When a simfile is no fun at all for all but one playing style it's not a great stepfile no matter how technically sound it is sorry.

yea exactly my feelings

and wtf. whatever im not getting into this.

and why are we talking about my quasar.

LOL ARCHS FOTBB SUCKS THATS MAKES HIM A TERRIBLE SIMFILE MAKER. Oh and he made revo too. And tons of bullshit that was offsync, wrong bpm's and yellow arrow syndrome.

He also said club was a GOOD SIMFILE back in the day.

So that right there goes to show how opinions have changed over the days so talk about old sims shouldn't even exist XD

[SMGod]

RE: Re: RE: Re: RE: you indexers can probably beat this but

I've only played one of his sims: girl boy... Are they really good? And where can I get them? BMS? I don't

[Anuj]

RE: Re: RE: Re: RE: you indexers can probably beat this but

morning everyone =\

[banditcom]

Re: RE: Re: RE: Re: RE: Re: RE: you indexers can probably be

You people suck Toph's dick too much.

The a La Menthe Challenge may be perfectly synched to every note possible but LO AND BEHOLD IT ISN'T FUN AT ALL

Except for maybe indexers and what do I care about indexers because I'm not one

When a simfile is no fun at all for all but one playing style it's not a great stepfile no matter how technically sound it is sorry.

EXACTLY... Those are my thoughts. Finally someone who understands other than Reach, Peer, and myself...

Toph: Note how hayden posted an INDEX score... So that "he plays 4-finger and still likes this file" argument is invalid.

Arch: I'm still 21.

and why are we talking about my quasar.

LOL ARCHS FOTBB SUCKS THATS MAKES HIM A TERRIBLE SIMFILE MAKER. Oh and he made revo too. And tons of bullshit that was offsync, wrong bpm's and yellow arrow syndrome.

He also said club was a GOOD SIMFILE back in the day.

You must realize that most of the younger people (14-17) are very hypocritical and fail to see that they are.


PS: Kilga is my favorite simfile maker. <3

[eVILPeeR]

RE: Re: RE: Re: RE: Re: RE: Re: RE: you indexers can probabl

To go indepth.. well, technically sound is probably most referred to due to the fact Beatmania, Guitarfreaks and such all use keysounds so they HAVE to be technically sound. Although if they weren't you could probably come up with some pretty cool rhythms anyways. Anyways, if you look at simfiles such as Eggmans Quasar, my Colors is definitley a good example.. unforunately not most of Toph's but I found The Cube to be like this.. you'll find that most simfiles are actually not super-technical.. and when they are, most of the time they're not fun. Life In Strate for example.. it's kind of fun the first few times, but after that it becomes very repetitive. Reach makes simfiles that totally deter off of the "technical" course and his simfiles are still viewed as fun to play. Unfortunately I guess that means that technical != the only fun type of simfile.

I honestly don't think people should judge simfiles until they make a decent one of their own and understand what a good simfile actually is.

[DukAmok]

RE: Re: RE: Re: RE: Re: RE: Re: RE: you indexers can probabl

lol toph said he liked the guitar part in least 100 sec. wtf? first of all, most of the technical parts of the guitar solo are actually just mush. theyre not well defined notes, theyre more like slides and stuff. frankly, the solo shouldntve been stepped, espescially not as poorly as he did it i.e a bunch of triplets at the end where its not even comprehensible what the guitarist is playing.

btw technically sound =/= fun. hello my brace yourself challenge. hell, i even put in the swung 16ths with 24ths and stuff. so? its still not fun at all. same with girl boy song. whatever. to each his own.

p.s. does arch just routinely search for his name in the forums or something? cause he seriously just came out of nowhere and started posting here =/

p.p.s. lol im anuj look at the =/

[eVILPeeR]

RE: Re: RE: Re: RE: Re: RE: Re: RE: you indexers can probabl

Actually.. the guitar solo is ONSYNC. It's not really mashed together - even though I didn't spend the most time on it. If you slowed it down you could probably find quite a few flaws, but it plays with it well anyways. The guitarist actually does play that fast however..

Anyways =/

[DukAmok]

RE: Re: RE: Re: RE: Re: RE: Re: RE: you indexers can probabl

i played the file once, and i remember being like, what the hell was that. so i went back before i posted and opened it in editor to check it out completely. i slowed it down to .7 music, and i couldnt really tell what was going on with the solo. i tried .5 music, and it seemed decent, but not exact. .3 music, it was horribly off. no, im not talking about the synching itself, i mean the rhythms. there were several spots with triplets that you had eigths at, and the part with triplets was actually like, 16ths/weird stuff. even without getting into much detail, it wasnt really fun. whatever =/

[eVILPeeR]

RE: Re: RE: Re: RE: Re: RE: Re: RE: you indexers can probabl

Well maybe I'll put it on .3 and redo it. Who knows >_>
Uh.. yea. =/

[banditcom]

Re: RE: Re: RE: Re: RE: Re: RE: Re: RE: you indexers can pro

p.s. does arch just routinely search for his name in the forums or something?

He does. He even said so.

i played the file once, and i remember being like, what the hell was that. so i went back before i posted and opened it in editor to check it out completely. i slowed it down to .7 music, and i couldnt really tell what was going on with the solo. i tried .5 music, and it seemed decent, but not exact. .3 music, it was horribly off. no, im not talking about the synching itself, i mean the rhythms. there were several spots with triplets that you had eigths at, and the part with triplets was actually like, 16ths/weird stuff. even without getting into much detail, it wasnt really fun. whatever =/

Yea, since we all play normally on slower music... Seriously, it doesn't have to be dead on because you can't tell. As long as it FEELS like it, then it's fine. If you can get it perfect, fine, good, whatever... "OMG when I slow it down to .3 music I can tell it's off"... So fucking what. You can't tell during 1x music so who the fuck cares. It's a game; it's not a classical masterpiece.

[DukAmok]

RE: Re: RE: Re: RE: Re: RE: Re: RE: Re: RE: you indexers can

the point was technicality. if its really technically dead on, then its ok if its not fun. but if its not fun OR technically correct, what the hells the point.

[Kilgamayan]

RE: Re: RE: Re: RE: Re: RE: Re: RE: Re: RE: you indexers can

It's "okay" for something to be not fun?

What the hell is the point of a simfile if it's not fun?

[banditcom]

Re: RE: Re: RE: Re: RE: Re: RE: Re: RE: Re: RE: you indexers

the point was technicality. if its really technically dead on, then its ok if its not fun. but if its not fun OR technically correct, what the hells the point.

It's still not okay. If it's not fun but technically sound, I still don't get the point..?

This is a game. It's all ABOUT fun.

EDIT: Kilga beat me to it...

[DukAmok]

RE: Re: RE: Re: RE: Re: RE: Re: RE: Re: RE: Re: RE: you inde

damnit, i dont even know what the hell im arguing about. i agree with you guys. simfiles should be fun.

[eVILPeeR]

RE: Re: RE: Re: RE: Re: RE: Re: RE: Re: RE: Re: RE: you inde

Duk is a DDR god..