35
28
21
14
7
Jade Star :: FFR Batch Submission
Mipha -
Jade Star -
SHIKI [6.75 / 10]
OT17 Bounty Batch
PublicEvents
Released
SHIKI blanket perms.
Collab with jh05013. Should be around mid-upper bounds of 50s. (56-58)
- The sim folder name isn't as expected: "Jade Star (Mipha & jh05013)" vs "Jade Star (Mipha)"
✔️ This chart has been marked as final and shouldn't receive any more changes.
- This file is a collaboration between multiple authors / stepauthors.
Simfile Folder Name
Jade Star (Mipha & jh05013)Note Count
882Chart Length
1:57Average NPS
7.7573Estimated Difficulty
56.13
First Note
0:03Ending Note Delay
0:01Hand Bias
x -18
Framers
0 - 0 1 - 0 2 - 0 3 - 0 4 - 0Jumps
x 205
Hands
x 2
Quads
x 0
Color Jumps
x 0
Color Hands
x 0
Color Quads
x 0
Most notes in:
1/3 of a Second7 - 21.00 nps 0.5 Seconds
10 - 20.00 nps 1 Second
17 - 17.00 nps 2 Seconds
27 - 13.50 nps 5 Seconds
58 - 11.60 nps 10 Seconds
108 - 10.80 nps 30 Seconds
298 - 9.93 nps 1 Minute
484 - 8.07 nps
Color Count
x 407 (46.15%)
x 194 (22%)
x 4 (0.45%)
x 269 (30.5%)
x 6 (0.68%)
x 0 (0%)
x 2 (0.23%)
x 0 (0%)
x 0 (0%)
Posted at 3:05pm on January 22nd, 2024
Approved for upper-mid 50s bounty, cleared for judging.
Posted at 5:34pm on January 25th, 2024
Jade Star (Mipha & jh05013) [6.5/10]
- Perms, metadata are good
- *Sync is off, it should be roughly -0.357
0:07.047-0:12.672 - PR? Why is this repeating the same as the intro?
*0:13.363-0:16.323 - Why does this section only has the single notes on two columns? Compare with the next sections
0:27.573-0:27.968 - 12ths, not 16ths. Double check. Check for other iterations like this.
0:36.356 - Ghost?
0:37.343 - Or msising note?
0:51.278-0:52.857 - Column consistency? Compare to the rest of the sections next
1:06.278-1:06.574 - PR, this is trills. In general this whole stream feels weird in terms of PR
1:12.199 - PR, note on 4
^ PR in this section is also pretty iffy. Some more notes below v
1:12.593-1:12.692 - Swap for better PR
1:13.185 - Should be on 1 technically
Anything forward faces the same PR concerns above, double check
This chart is quite neat and captures an old school charting vibe. However PR is greatly loose in a lot of places and needs fixing in the most prominent ones, like the break.
Posted at 7:10pm on February 18th, 2024
Jade Star (Mipha & jh05013) [7/10] -FR-
PERMS OK
SYNC NOT OK (Offset off by a 64th/25ms)
7.343: PR, shouldnt be 24 again like the first ones. Same issue for 10.501 etc.
12.080: Also PR, move to col 2 for example as these are the lowest notes in the intro so 12 "trills" are more appropriate.
12.968: Move to col 3.
12.771: Missing note.
14.152 & 15.731 & 17.310 & 18.889 & etc: Missing notes. The kick is layered at 26.784 anyway so these timestamps should probably have singles.
25.304: PR, shouldnt also be (13).
25.797: PR, same note as the 4th before it.
26.093: What does this go to?
27.869 & 40.501: Missing 16ths. Also in these iterations, the 8th should probably be omitted (like 27.772 & 40.402).
42.080: If this is layered, why isn't 42.672 too? This isn't the first instance of such a sudden layering change and at this point it becomes a bit offputting/difficult to follow.
48.889: There's a jump at 36.258, why not here? Also the PR of the 16ths around it dont match the first iteration either.
49.975: Missing note.
1:30.731: These flams are a bit excessive. At most a 32nd would probably be fine, but this speedup is way too subtle to warrant this much of a spike. Same for other iterations.
Cute chart, simple rhythms for the most part. The PR doesn't seem to make much sense for a big portion of the first half which can feel a bit random/incoherent even at this difficulty. There is also a fair amount of inconsistencies and technical issues here and there. Some motifs are pretty cool like the runningmen and the (12) anchor kicks. With a solid cleanup this could be fun. Would FR on the sync and a thorough PR and consistency pass.
Posted at 11:16pm on February 20th, 2024
Rating appealed. Conditions to release this out of Fixes Required are the PR notes/comments me & Oppie provided. As well as the sync.
Also please look to address the consistency of the anchor motif at first half (32.310-34.679 being left & right anchors, while 44.942-47.310 being down & right, even though it should be down & up variations, this is easily fixable by swapping the 3 & 4 columns of the down anchor)
And also ghost notes at 1:30.238, 1:30.402, 1:42.869, 1:43.034.
Posted at 6:11am on February 21st, 2024
Thank you for the second wind, appreciate it.
Offset's changed to reflect the changes here.
Deamerai:
7.047-12.672 - PR should now be fixed to not repeat as before.
13.363-16.323 - I initially omitted these just so that it opens up with a brief 3/16th intro, but maybe it's too empty anyway, so I added some singles.
27.573 - Now this is an interesting point - these are very subtle 12ths, but on a LR2/BMS chart it layers as 16th since it's going for the main violins. jh did concur but we committed to use 16ths instead.
36.356 - Not really a ghost, seems more of another violin hit.
37.343 - But this one is indeed missing, so added.
Anchor motif is also properly fixed to alternate the start of each anchors.
The PR until the end is also mostly fixed, but some of them are mostly moved around (it's still a little bit varied) so the patterning is also properly comfortable as well, so I might need a recheck for these.
>And also ghost notes at 1:30.238, 1:30.402, 1:42.869, 1:43.034.
- I think it's fine to add them as a continuity flow, more to reflect on the LR2/BMS 16th patterning of them.
Op:
7.343 - Fixed.
12.080 - Done.
12.771 - Added.
12.968 - Done.
14.152 etc. - Added these missing notes.
25.324 - Made it [14].
25.797 - Done.
26.093 - It goes to the main violin sound.
27.869, 40.501 - Hmm, can't hear it. The motif is based around the violin hit for the triplet before.
42.080 - I actually think this one was a mistake. Removed.
48.889 - Added.
49.975 - Added.
1:30.731 - I toned the flams into 48ths instead of 64ths. These are still 3 hits, but they do have a slight breather now.
Thank you for the notes.
Posted at 6:16am on February 21st, 2024
A new chart file was uploaded with the following changes:
----------
Offset changed: -0.337 => -0.357
----------
Note Count changed: 873 => 882
AVG NPS changed: 7.6781 => 7.75726
Hand Bias changed: -25 => -18
Posted at 10:11am on February 21st, 2024
Should be the final fix, changed additional PR based on Deamerai's recheck.
A new chart file was uploaded.
Posted at 10:36am on February 21st, 2024
PR is looking much better now. This can go out of Fixes Required.