Fastest Crash (Wiosna) [7/10] -FR-

PERMS OK
SYNC OK

10.671: Missing drum note.

10.956: Missing drum note.

11.599: Might as well integrate this hihat.

1:23.885-1:24.528: One example of a particularly awkward hand bias. Not tooo bad given the difficulty of the chart, but not the most fun patterning.

1:27.171: Fine as is, but such calmer sections probably have the leeway for using 48ths here since it's the actual timing.

1:39.647-1:40.635: Another example of bias (right hand) with unintuitive rhythms.

1:45.956 & 1:50.528 & etc: Not all wub sections with the 48ths are the same. The ones mentioned are not straight 8ths. See other iterations.

2:38.885-3:13.171 [FR]: Can't figure out the 32nds at all here. They seem to be abstractions of the melody (as opposed to the 24ths on the wubs), but it feels so difficult for what it abstracts. For example, 2:48.028 has a minijack in it, so maybe the 32nds just very much exaggerate those, but then right after at 2:48.318 there's a minijack but the song doesn't have it, and then 2:52.882 is suddenly triplet minitrills? The three sets of 32nds starting at 3:04.028 shouldn't have a single such minijack.

3:13.456: Maybe purposefully omitted but could probably be added.

This chart has pretty good execution on a per section basis, although the difficulty curve is a bit messy for tournament viability. The dubstep midsection is super fun on its own, but it feels pretty underwhelming relative to the rest of the chart, especially considering the other mentioned abstractions like the 32nds in a big part of the second half. Then there's the ending's difficulty spike of the dense 8th jumps and hands which is fine but for OT in a song that's 4 minutes long is not ideal. Some of the difficulty also comes from a few awkward patterns/transitions which could be avoided.

Ultimately, if the 32nds are made more relevant in the second half, And if they're actually just abstractions to the melody, then fixing those to not all be minijacks could maybe do it. Check the midsection wubs too, and if they can be buffed a bit that'd be neat but it's less major of a concern.

Checking in on the status of this submission, as it's past the 1 month probationary period with a "Fixes Required" flag.

Files/Songs with the "Fixes Required" tag require at a minimum a fix submitted based on the above notes from judges, or a response appealing the notes involved in the reason for it being labeled as Fixes Required.

Since you've responded on this, willing to give extra time on fixes. Just, y'know, keep it in the loop. Would rather it not be on-hold indefinitely in-batch.