Note that I'm allowing this for tourney use now, as it fits more there than a random release. Can't change how I marked it so I'm making sure it's marked here for when this gets judged.

The Dreaming Tree (XtraFestive) [ACCEPT] CR

PERMS OK
SYNC OK

41.919: Fine I suppose, although 24ths (with maybe some 48ths) would be more accurate. This felt a bit odd.

47.369 & 47.419: Ghost notes (the latter could be argued). There's a 16th at 47.394 though.

1:16.769: Would suggest removing the 24ths before this one, as the song feels more like a pause there despite the subtle high pitched notes.

1:28.044: Missing note.

1:31.344: Missing note (same synth as 1:31.494).

1:35.919: PR.

1:45.069: I'd argue this is too harsh for a fade in sound. There's a lot more buzz noise stuff in the song and this is pretty spiky for what it goes to.

2:05.169-2:37.569: The abstraction of the "laser gun" sounds is so varied in this section that it feels quite abitrary at times; there's 24ths, 24ths with polys, 32nds, 32nds flams, abstract 192nds and some 64ths. The consistency is fine, as in the various sounds are charted similarly, but it's the sheer amount of quantizations changes that's a bit offputting. Given that this is somewhat subjective, I'll just make it a strong recommendation to consider simplifying that section.

4:05.994: Missing note.

4:17.469: 24ths are slightly underwhelming here.

4:31.719: Would expect something here, even if just a single note. There's still some stuff going on aside from the flams.

This chart is pretty well executed. There's a good attention to consistency, and the playability is pretty good throughout. Will CR based on the bigger concern being relatively subjective, but a cleanup wouldn't hurt either. Good stuff overall.

Kind of agree with both Deam's and Op's larger notes, but also agree that they're relatively minor overall.

Moving this to CR status.

Checking in on the status of this submission, as it's past the 1 month probationary period with a "Change Recommended" flag, but there's been no acknowledgment of judge notes or fixes submitted.

Files/Songs with the "Change Recommended" tag require at a minimum a response from the Stepauthor in order to continue through the submission system.

I will check back on this at a later date. If it does not receive a response or fix by then, it could risk rejection.

[41.919] Replaced 24ths split roll with 48ths (this actually matches the real rhythm a lot better, I was relying on the waveform at the time) and adjusted a small portion afterwards to account for hand bias.

[47.169] (124) chord changed to (134) to reduce hand bias going into a dense burst.

[1:28.062] Added note (and moved the note after).

[1:31.344] Added note (and moved the note after to the same column).

[2:05.169-2:37.569] This one is more of a note -- I haven't changed anything about this section because structurally I would need to redo pretty much everything to make a reasonable change. My first attempt at charting this was incredibly arbitrary as it was simply random streams and rolls in the same quantization for half a minute. I remade it to match quantizations to specific pitches and sounds while keeping roughly the same patterns so it can play cohesively (nearly the same without much strict reading ability necessary between the sections). It's a silly section that seems like it could infinitely use more refining but I'm happy with how I represented it overall.

[4:05.994] Added note.

A new chart file was uploaded with the following changes:
----------
Hand Bias changed: -3 => 1

Looks great