35
28
21
14
7
PLEXIDRUMS :: FFR Batch Submission
basicdrummerman -
PLEXIDRUMS -
I-GOR [5 / 10]
Round-Table Special Batch
PublicTokenPurchasedSecretEvents
Rejected
blanket
Simfile Folder Name
PLEXIDRUMS (basicdrummerman)Note Count
1850Chart Length
2:31Average NPS
12.4887Estimated Difficulty
86.47
First Note
0:03Ending Note Delay
0:01Hand Bias
x -6
Framers
0 - 0 1 - 0 2 - 0 3 - 13 4 - 97Jumps
x 240
Hands
x 150
Quads
x 0
Color Jumps
x 17
Color Hands
x 17
Color Quads
x 0
Most notes in:
1/3 of a Second10 - 30.00 nps 0.5 Seconds
14 - 28.00 nps 1 Second
24 - 24.00 nps 2 Seconds
42 - 21.00 nps 5 Seconds
88 - 17.60 nps 10 Seconds
169 - 16.90 nps 30 Seconds
479 - 15.97 nps 1 Minute
897 - 14.95 nps
Color Count
x 895 (48.38%)
x 408 (22.05%)
x 70 (3.78%)
x 262 (14.16%)
x 77 (4.16%)
x 98 (5.3%)
x 0 (0%)
x 13 (0.7%)
x 27 (1.46%)
Posted at 8:45pm on November 13th, 2023
Accepted
Pretty safe pattern choices across the board but thankfully the song doesn't overstay its welcome and cause much of the patterns to become stale from repetitive play.
Part that suffers the most is 02:00.625 -> end of song, as patterns such-as 02:04.510 are notable in the background but are not held or introduced further in sections like 02:07.100, 02:08.395, 02:09.691, etc.
I actually think it would've performed better with a cut at 01:28.974 after the 32nd roll but that's just me.
Changes Recommended for ending stuff since it's a stand-out issue but it wouldn't be a total loss if it went in-game as-is. Just that it could be done better imo.
Posted at 1:34am on November 20th, 2023
19.603 - Should be [13] based on the previous repetitions
21.384 - Should be just [2] based on the previous repetitions
22.355 - Ghost note
24.460 - Shouldn't be [12]. Not percussion like 23.974
30.881/1:18.451/1:18.816/2:13.819/2:20.295 - Missing note
32.554/1:11.409 - Should be hand. Compare 29.964
33.688-34.983 - All the white notes should be on [3] (or at least on the same lane) to be consistent with the noise
42.592-42.916/44.211-44.696/49.877-50.201/1:10.438-1:10.599/1:11.247-1:11.409 - Why jack?
1:01.210 - Sounds closer to 1:01.264
1:03.638 - Maybe hand?
1:06.876-1:07.362 - Change to 232 for better PR and to avoid a jack on 1:07.524
1:09.142 - Why hand? No noise similar to 32.554
1:16.859 - Sounds closer to 1:16.832
1:19.989-1:20.151 - Not doing the usual roll pattern here? 1:03.638
1:21.284-1:26.446 - Weird layering. Compare 1:26.465-1:26.627
1:30.512 - Shouldn't be jump. Compare 1:31.808
1:32.131 - Should be jump. Compare 1:34.722
1:39.902-1:59.653 - Inconsistent JS with the random anchors
1:59.815 - Should be diff jump PR than 1:59.653
2:04.915/2:05.562/2:06.210/2:11.714/2:13.009/2:24.018 - Ghost note
File needs polishing
REJECTED
Posted at 7:39pm on December 29th, 2023
Reject
30.827 - why not finish the roll to the 4th?
32.554 - definitely want a hand here
33.364 - 34.983 - somewhat subjective, but layering here feels a bit weird/inconsistent. Probably don't want to create psuedo-hands here given other hand uses so far
37.735 - 55.867 - hand/psuedo-hand/psuedo-quad use issue continues here
1:44.921 / 1:50.101 / etc. - (subjective, can ignore) layering in the extra kick hits in this section could help reduce the somewhat monotonous feel of this section
The layering does need some consistency checks. Every hand/psuedo-hand/psuedo-quad (created through bursts/colour tricks) should be justified by an appropritate sound.
The patterning could stand to be somewhat more aggressive and varied as well, everything is just a roll. Maybe try mixing up some of the shorter rolls to keep players on their toes.
I also heavily agree with Gold's cut idea. The song doesn't do you many favours in terms of generating player interest especially with how repetitive it is at the end.
Ultimately I just think this will need a fair bit of work before it can go in.
Posted at 11:06am on January 1st, 2024
1 Accept / 2 Reject
Moved to reject.
Thanks for your submission!~