Bad Apple!! 8bit [OG Aniki Slayer Remix] :: FFR Batch Submission
Hakulyte - Bad Apple!! 8bit [OG Aniki Slayer Remix] - Kommisar [5.25 / 10]
16th Official Tournament (see thread)
PublicPurchasedSecretEvents
Rejected
Kommisar made the song / https://ffr.fandom.com/wiki/Kommisar
Collab with Hateandhatred

This chart challenges jacks with its 160bpm 16th. More importantly, it also contains multiple 32nd burst patterns that requires a significant amount of speed. We wanted to see how the chart converts before further fixes if applicable.

- The sim folder name isn't as expected: "Bad Apple!! 8bit [OG Aniki Slayer remix] (Hakulyte & Hateandhatred)" vs "Bad Apple!! 8bit [OG Aniki Slayer Remix] (Hakulyte)"

- This file is a collaboration between multiple authors / stepauthors.

Simfile Folder Name

Bad Apple!! 8bit [OG Aniki Slayer remix] (Hakulyte & Hateandhatred)

Note Count

3523

Chart Length

3:53

Average NPS

15.3977

Estimated Difficulty

101.11

First Note

0:04

Ending Note Delay

0:01

Hand Bias

x -69

Framers

0 - 0 1 - 0 2 - 59 3 - 250 4 - 159

Jumps

x 680

Hands

x 270

Quads

x 0

Color Jumps

x 15

Color Hands

x 20

Color Quads

x 0

Most notes in:

1/3 of a Second
12 - 36.00 nps 0.5 Seconds
16 - 32.00 nps 1 Second
27 - 27.00 nps 2 Seconds
45 - 22.50 nps 5 Seconds
105 - 21.00 nps 10 Seconds
206 - 20.60 nps 30 Seconds
575 - 19.17 nps 1 Minute
1026 - 17.10 nps

Color Count

x 1343 (38.12%)
x 821 (23.3%)
x 58 (1.65%)
x 838 (23.79%)
x 95 (2.7%)
x 132 (3.75%)
x 119 (3.38%)
x 69 (1.96%)
x 48 (1.36%)

Largest Note Gaps

0.4s0.4s0.4s0.4s0.4s0.4s0.37s0.37s
35
28
21
14
7

A new chart file was uploaded with the following changes:
----------
Hand Bias changed: -62 => -60

A new chart file was uploaded with the following changes:
----------
Note Count changed: 3522 => 3521
AVG NPS changed: 15.39336 => 15.38899
Hand Bias changed: -60 => -71

Added color theory and applied some fixes.

A new chart file was uploaded with the following changes:
----------
Note Count changed: 3521 => 3523
AVG NPS changed: 15.38899 => 15.39773
Hand Bias changed: -71 => -69

A new chart file was uploaded.

Bad Apple!! 8bit [OG Aniki Slayer Remix] (Hakulyte & Hateandhatred) - 5/10
- 31.435 - jack into a [34] chord seems a bit unnecessary here
- 33.494 - feels like more can be done to layer the wobble here
- 34.804 - ditto this with the pitch bend
- 35.740 - should be [24] to differentiate it from the chord before it (different pitch)
- 36.489 - jack makes sense, but I'd personally avoid using chords like [12] or [34] at the end of jacks because they're quite awkward to hit in general
- 42.667 - the colour change is welcome, though I think a change in pattern would also be nice too (e.g. 3412[134])
- 45.663 - not sure what justifies 64ths here
- 1:01.582 - you've used gluts for harsher sounds (e.g. 25.631) before compared to bass kicks, yet this is a straight [14] jumpjack, which is a harder pattern than the gluts that you've been using up to this point
- 1:13.564/1:25.545/etc - really not fond of the sudden use of [14] jumpjacks here -- the chart is already quite spiky in nature, and sandwiching these jumpjacks instead of jumpgluts with already difficult patterns makes this chart feel much more spiky than it already is
- 1:35.094 - missing burst given your layering scheme, though in general, I would probably use 32nd bursts for the main melody rather than the background noises instead
- 1:38.163/1:38.463 - not sure what the bursts are going to here
- 2:39.962 - this burst doesn't sound right at all, in that it shouldn't be there. the previous bursts make sense musically, but it also doesn't feel right since there are 2 clashing timbres here. just not sure what to feel about this section
- 2:42.583/2:42.770/2:43.613/2:47.732 - could have some bursts here
- 2:45.251 - funny burst, but I think it's way too soft to justify a burst like this
- 2:48.281 - not sure what that burst is going to
- 2:52.289 - burst shouldn't be here I think
- 2:51.289 to 2:51.664 - technically missed opportunity for a 5-note jack

I think I'll stop here, mostly because I think there are too many errors or that I have too many reservations with the chart to really accept this even if the rest of the chart is perfect. I see that there is a lot of tact put into the use of colours in the chart, but the chart suffers from a very uneven difficulty curve, lots of missed opportunities of evening out that difficulty curve by the use of more bursts, overly difficult jack patterns, and some gratuitous burst use overall. It's also a bit draggy overall, and I think it could afford a notable cut, but it might just be a song choice thing on my end.

[Posted for Mipha]

~~

Bad Apple!! 8bit [OG Aniki Slayer Remix] (Hakulyte & Hateandhatred)

- Offset's fine.

From a judge and a player's perspective, there's not much to talk about this chart but there are two issues with this: jumpjack spike transitions and the density of the patterns.

The jumpjacks like this 25.631 for example are very strenuous because of the concentrated center-bias patterns that really don't look fun, and they certainly off when the song itself doesn't really lend much into dense jacks like this. This is especially a repeated issue with other similar jumpjacks, and often times they are imbalanced with the hand biases.

The jumpstream/handstream is on the heavy side, but they're ultimately fine. I'm not fond of it because it definitely feels off when everything else (bursts and the jumpjacks mainly) gave so much emphasis on difficult transitions, but those are smaller concerns. The only solution I have with this is mainly on the reduction of burst and/or jack patterns so they don't feel as meatier as they are now.

Since the song is also rather long, the two issues I have above made this chart quite the frustraring experience, and I'm afraid I can't really let this pass through. [5.5/10]