35
28
21
14
7
UP&DOWN :: FFR Batch Submission
rushyrulz -
UP&DOWN -
nanobii [6.25 / 10]
Aug/Sept 2022
PublicTokenPurchasedSecretEvents
Rejected
https://www.flashflashrevolution.com/vbz/showpost.php?p=4781618&postcount=388
Simfile Folder Name
UP&DOWN (rushyrulz)Note Count
2188Chart Length
3:16Average NPS
11.4335Estimated Difficulty
84.22
First Note
0:05Ending Note Delay
0:01Hand Bias
x -8
Framers
0 - 0 1 - 0 2 - 9 3 - 16 4 - 9Jumps
x 577
Hands
x 109
Quads
x 1
Color Jumps
x 46
Color Hands
x 12
Color Quads
x 1
Most notes in:
1/3 of a Second9 - 27.00 nps 0.5 Seconds
13 - 26.00 nps 1 Second
25 - 25.00 nps 2 Seconds
46 - 23.00 nps 5 Seconds
102 - 20.40 nps 10 Seconds
198 - 19.80 nps 30 Seconds
468 - 15.60 nps 1 Minute
861 - 14.35 nps
Color Count
x 857 (39.17%)
x 682 (31.17%)
x 11 (0.5%)
x 493 (22.53%)
x 13 (0.59%)
x 13 (0.59%)
x 0 (0%)
x 3 (0.14%)
x 116 (5.3%)
Posted at 8:07am on August 22nd, 2022
Filename updated to reflect correct tile.
A new chart file was uploaded with the following changes:
----------
Title changed: Up & Down => UP&DOWN
----------
Posted at 1:12pm on September 8th, 2022
Made a jack in both handstreams much friendlier to hit, fixed some embarrassing mistakes on the color theory.
A new chart file was uploaded with the following changes:
----------
Note Count changed: 2187 => 2188
AVG NPS changed: 11.42832 => 11.43355
Hand Bias changed: -7 => -8
Posted at 3:37pm on July 1st, 2023
UP&DOWN (rushyrulz) [6.5/10]
>Perms, metadata, sync good
*33.798/55.381 - Ghost note
1:02.506/1:05.673-1:06.006 - Fix PR. Compare 1:02.340
1:05.840 - Is this really saying “up” ?
1:06.173-1:15.173 - Where’s the notes??
1:22.006/1:26.090/1:32.506/1:32.673 - Missing jump
1:38.784-1:42.951 - All these 24ths are technically 16ths
1:44.840 - Why jump?
1:45.173/1:45.840 - Missing jump
1:45.340-1:47.173 - What layering is going on here?
1:53.340/1:53.840 - Should be hand. Compare 1:50.673
1:55.506-1:55.756/1:56.173-1:56.340 - Fix PR
1:57.506 - Should be single. No piano
1:58.256 - Ghost note
1:58.395 - Missing note
1:58.506-1:59.340 - What is going on here?
2:10.006-2:10.173 - Should be singles. Compare 23.340-23.423
2:10.784-2:16.284 - All these 24ths are technically 16ths
2:31.173 - Is this really saying “up” ?
2:31.506-2:40.506 - Where’s the notes??
2:40.617 - What is this note going to?
2:42.048 - Ghost note
2:47.340/2:51.423/2:57.840/2:58.006 - Missing jump
>>Needs much polish
Posted at 3:39pm on July 1st, 2023
UP&DOWN (rushyrulz) [6/10]
>Permission good (Blanket)
>Folder contents, metadata good
>Sync good
Playtest Impression, 1.0x Rate - Would be good if the dense js/hs was nerfed
The difficulty curve of this file is very poorly balanced. It all comes down to the two sections of dense jumpstream/handstream (1:16.840 - ~1:32.840 and 2:42.173 - ~2:58.173). The rest of the chart plays in the low-70s but these two sections we wouldn’t expect to see until the high-80s to 90s.
The rest of the chart outside these spikes is pretty solid. I think you could definitely make something mid-70s here.
Addressing the difficulty curve issue will represent fairly large structure changes that I feel will be too much for an FR flag.
Posted at 8:41pm on September 19th, 2023
Thanks for the feedback - I'll be submitting this again with fixes to next batch.
*33.798/55.381 - Ghost note || Fixed
1:02.506/1:05.673-1:06.006 - Fix PR. Compare 1:02.340 || Fixed I think, or at least better.
1:05.840 - Is this really saying “up” ? || Yes - "Three counts up"
1:06.173-1:15.173 - Where’s the notes?? || This part is fine IMO.
1:22.006/1:26.090/1:32.506/1:32.673 - Missing jump || 1:22.006 omitted intentionally as it spikes too hard following the minijack, 1:26.090 I don't see this as a jump. 132.506/1:32.673 I don't see this as jumps either since there are in a stripped section musically, continuing the jumpstream there feels wrong.
1:38.784-1:42.951 - All these 24ths are technically 16ths || Fixed
1:44.840 - Why jump? || Originally stepped as hand since there was a vocal, drum, and piano on this beat. Nerfed from hand to jump, since the hand does seem a bit much.
1:45.173/1:45.840 - Missing jump || fixed these + another missing one
1:45.340-1:47.173 - What layering is going on here? || should be fine now
1:53.340/1:53.840 - Should be hand. Compare 1:50.673 || yup, fixed
1:55.506-1:55.756/1:56.173-1:56.340 - Fix PR || Huh? Seems fine to me. First vocalization is higher in pitch and stepped as 4, second vocalization is slightly lower in pitch and stepped as 3.
1:57.506 - Should be single. No piano || added layering which makes this a valid jump now.
1:58.256 - Ghost note
1:58.395 - Missing note || fixed this part^
1:58.506-1:59.340 - What is going on here? || dunno what I was smoking, should be fine now.
2:10.006-2:10.173 - Should be singles. Compare 23.340-23.423 || Fixed
2:10.784-2:16.284 - All these 24ths are technically 16ths || Fixed
2:31.173 - Is this really saying “up” ? || Yes, same lyric as earlier.
2:31.506-2:40.506 - Where’s the notes?? || Not sure what else I'm supposed to step, this plays fine, doesn't feel barren.
2:40.617 - What is this note going to? || grace note in the synth. It's subtle I guess, but I'm fine leaving it in.
2:42.048 - Ghost note || Fixed
2:47.340/2:51.423/2:57.840/2:58.006 - Missing jump || Disagree for same reasons above.
---
Comment on the difficulty spike - I do sort of agree, however this handstream was not too aggressive. Nerfing it anyway because the minijack part (which I think is necessary) feels too hard amidst a handstream.