Terror From Beyond v2 (Xtreme2252) [7.5/10]
>Perms, metadata, sync good

12.004-12.491 - I suggest changing this section from [24]1[24]1 to [12]4[12]4 for better PR, since there is another [24] at 11.356 that represents a different noise.
17.356/17.680 - Kinda surprised that these singles weren’t on [3] as part of this long trill.
22.545/22.869/27.734/28.058/28.545 - Missing jump
27.247 - Should be [24] for consistent layering.
30.166/30.491 - Should be [34] for better PR. The noise before this spot already occupied the [23] pattern.
30.815-32.761 - Why was this ascending noise alternating trills of “1313-2424”, but 15.247-17.193 wasn’t?
38.031/38.356/43.220/43.545 - Missing note
43.788-56.437 - Maybe step the swishy-swoosh background noise here to make this entire section feel less empty.
46.950/47.193 - Should be on [1].
1:00.166-1:00.491 - Should be [34] for consistent layering of “ABA”. The next few repetitions follow that same pattern of “ABA” with the jumps.
1:00.653-1:01.139/1:05.842-1:06.329/1:11.031-1:11.518/1:16.220-1:16.707 - PR needs work here. Out of these 4-jump sections, the second jump should have a jump pattern that’s different from the first jump and the third/fourth jump.
1:17.599-/1:17.923 - If the yellow 16ths are going to the ascending melody, then these two singles should be removed since the ascending melody starts at 1:18.166. And also, 1:18.166-1:19.139 should have its 16ths filled out.
1:30.491-1:33.896 - Fix the 4-jump repetitions here. Make it consistently “AABC”, like the ones afterwards.
1:50.275 - Turn this to a [24] like 1:50.761.
1:59.031-1:59.518 - Maybe lessen up the [3] anchor by using [12]’s instead.
2:11.518 - Missing jump. Snare
2:16.707-2:16.869 - Should at least be a minijack here since there’s a 2-jump snare repetition.
2:22.842/2:26.437/2:29.031/2:31.626/2:34.220/2:36.815/2:39.410/2:42.004 - Not part of the synth jack. Please change the respective jumps to a jump pattern that’s different from the synth jack.

>>File’s got acceptable layering. Just be more mindful about PR and unnecessary anchors.

I think I'm finally getting a grasp on the issue with anchors. This tweak overhauls a few problematic sections of the song, and I hope you'll agree it's a vast improvement over the original, and maybe even over the legendary v1

A new chart file was uploaded with the following changes:
----------
Note Count changed: 1894 => 1957
AVG NPS changed: 11.06739 => 11.43553
Hand Bias changed: 48 => 49

Off the top of my head several of the changes I made were...

During the weird wobbly synth segments, I fixed the PA by correcting my error in determining the pitches [ABBAABABCDDCEFEF] where E is charted as B and F is charted as A respectively, in all cases.

I tried ending each roll section in a similar fashion, with emphasis on the two crashes at the end, with three [BCB] notes following each. The exception is one roll in the middle in which a change in synth chords is emphasized over the crash.

I corrected several instances of the squawky synth notes being charted as [A...A] when they should be [A...B] or [A...B] when they should be [A...A]

Bass kicks are now consistently charted as single notes throughout the bridge of the song.

The final post-chorus of the song now follows a number of guidelines;
1. During the end of each measure where the two alternating jumps lead into a hand, the anchor that follows must now always be the note not charted in the hand
2. Back-to-back measures cannot have the same two-note jump as their most common two notes.

Update completely reworking that section of the song that was riddled with hands. I changed the layering and nerfed the kicks.

A new chart file was uploaded with the following changes:
----------
Note Count changed: 1957 => 1916
AVG NPS changed: 11.43553 => 11.19595
Hand Bias changed: 49 => 44

Also, I'm sorry for the inconvenience with additional "fixes" but some of the rolls in particular were really nasty. I nerfed I think two really poorly layered rolls in the middle and changed some of the rolls to minimize anchors. I think these are all rather minor changes and they, at least in my opinion, act to make the chart more consistent and less frustrating/chokeable during the admittedly inconsistent rolls

Posting in place of Op-

Assuming that there's no additional surprise changes in the next version, I'm ok w/ taking the FR off if you did two things - (1.) put non-minijack jumps on 1:55.707 & 2:00.896 (2.) add the missing swishy-swoosh notes: 48.207, 49.180, 50.153, 50.802, and 51.450.

A new chart file was uploaded with the following changes:
----------
Note Count changed: 1916 => 1918
AVG NPS changed: 11.19595 => 11.20764
Hand Bias changed: 44 => 40

I did add the swoosh sounds in. Instead of a quad, they are now split as mini-rolls. As 32nd notes (abc-d-)

This update turned the notes you mentioned into non-jack jumps rather than single notes

K, almost there. Now finish the file by adding the missing swishy-swoosh notes located at: 48.207, 49.180, 50.153, 50.802, and 51.450.

I don't think there's any missing notes at those parts. I think what I charted it as now is repesentative of what they are in the song, at least to my ear o~o

Nope, there definitely are some swishy-swoosh noises at 48.207, 49.180, 50.153, 50.802, and 51.491 (changed from 51.450, which I had to listen a bunch more times to get a more accurate spot).

I hear what you're talking about now. I was only hearing and charting the underwater bubble gloop sounds and not those weird scratchy sounds

A new chart file was uploaded with the following changes:
----------
Note Count changed: 1918 => 1938
AVG NPS changed: 11.20764 => 11.3245
Hand Bias changed: 40 => 36