Phoenix (WirryWoo) [7.0/10]
> Permission check good.
> Sync is slightly off (Currently is -0.035, should be -0.041). Notes for this judgement will be based on this sync.
> No issues found within simfile properties.
> No issues found within submission folder contents.

-[01:04.586] Why is this not portrayed similarly to something like what’s done at 00:29.677 ?

-[01:10.768] Feels like you’re missing an 8th here.

-[01:16.131] Spicy 16th here that was left out.

-[01:41.859] Dropped the hand here?

-Hand usage feels like it’s all over the place. Starting at 00:21.859, you have hands presumably following to drum snare on 4ths, but drop it at 00:23.313, and is not re-visited until transition snaps at 00:29.677. Happens again at 00:33.495, but continues to drop 4ths it should be landing on. So a question for a lot of the stuff happening in the file is, what are the hands going to? Why is stuff like 01:22.586 or 01:31.677 not a hand?

-After discussing the above with another judge, appears to be the mixture of voice + snare. Seems fine with that perspective in mind, just not particularly a fan of that layering method.

-it’s fine. Maybe a sync fix?

[7.5/10]

Permission: good
Metadata: good
Offset: good

- The intro is kinda long, I feel you could fill it up with at least the bass sound at 1.126, 4.035, 6.944 etc. I find a 12 second intro of nothing a bit much.
- 17.489: Missing arrow to the melody.
- 62.489: Vocal is on the 32nd instead of the 8th.
- 62.899: Vocal is closer to this 64th than the 4th.
- 90.035: Why is this hi-hat included and not the earlier hi-hats at 88.580 and 88.944?
- 91.671: Layering aside, I think this is intense enough to be a hand.
- 104.762: A bit spiky.
- 117.308 - 117.489: Missing notes to the percussion, you are following the toms at 116.944 and 117.126.

Good chart, layering is easy to follow. Not a personal fan of the song, I don't think it lends itself well to charting.