Dump Batch Discussion Thread

[Psychotik]

Dumps are good, and there is no reason it shouldn't count toward ranks unless it's zero diff due to an unreasonable spike.

I do agree it should get it's own genre or some way to be labelled. I'm not too crazy about just adding another label in the title (like duplicate authors for same song title or Standard/Heavy as we have too many of those already). There should be a more elegant way of doing it.

[XelNya]

Originally Posted by Psychotik

Dumps are good, and there is no reason it shouldn't count toward ranks unless it's zero diff due to an unreasonable spike.

I do agree it should get it's own genre or some way to be labelled. I'm not too crazy about just adding another label in the title (like duplicate authors for same song title or Standard/Heavy as we have too many of those already). There should be a more elegant way of doing it.

Well crafted dumps, such as files that merge a base structure, with say emphasized vocal dumping, are great and have a lot of cool value to be added. Absolutely should count.

But just shitting notes like it's an osumania file, or an icyworld js file with ghost notes everywhere (think say Nature of Dying before he posted the open collab opportunity, I dunno how many folks have played that file tbh) absolutely shouldn't count. (Not trying to shit on Icy here btw, it's just an example.)

Is pretty much my take.

Originally Posted by Lights

ratio.

"Be nice" I think is what applies here.

[Lights]

Originally Posted by XelNya

"Be nice" I think is what applies here.

I'm merely giving the level of response warranted for what was said. That was the nice version.

[XelNya]

Originally Posted by Lights

I'm merely giving the level of response warranted for what was said. That was the nice version.

In an effort to not derail, I know you understand what I was getting at.