Queue/Batch Discussion Thread

[buizel8888]

I always knew carlos was easy

*wink* *wink*

[bmah]

Done.

[TC_Halogen]

Some of the code on my judging notes are broken, would it be alright for me to ask you to fix them?

[buizel8888]

My art wasn't appreciated. Oh well.

[qqwref]

I found this funny: 3 of the 4 judges who reviewed my C&E file said it was a bad cut.

Except I didn't cut it at all D: Maybe I'll have AsphyxZero make a longer version, and step that.

[krunkykai22]

Well, damn I'm glad I didn't submit anything XDDDDDD jk jk

Actually .... I will be soon(ish) Hopefully I get better reviews than some >.<

[megamon88]

I guess nobody likes 64th gallops even though you can hit them as jumps. :P

[TC_Halogen]

Wow, I totally didn't call out to a whole bunch of people both in DF and in FFR's profile chat that two judges would [++] SamS.

And it was the same two who I thought it would be too. Damn, I'm good.

[bmah]

Added resubmissions at the end of the batch post. Note that not all resubmissions were reviewed (e.g. I didn't re-look at White Walls yet).

[buizel8888]

I am really butthurt

[buizel8888]

Can you all call me izzy now?

[TC_Halogen]

Ok, I happened to look at the judge's notes for The Final Hour, and I'm going to separate everyone's notes bit by bit so I can ask people questions since I'm trying to help get Kayla her first file in FFR. I'm not attacking anyone, but merely stating points/disagreements.

i love you
m2: Quad note? Pretty sure a double would be just fine.

Loudest sound in the entire song? Since the quad rule was lifted, I don't see why it's an issue.

m7: Missing a 16th note on Beat 24.25.
Added.

m11-m14: Beat 40.00 should be a double. Also, this whole section is underlayered. I would suggest adding layer to that obvious background noise that you can clearly hear.

If it's so obvious, why was it mentioned as a "background" noise? Why is it not a synth, or a bass, or something? It is a bit empty, but it's also introducing a riff/melody that only happens in the song a single time.

m15-m23: I don't even know what you're layering here. This section is just too inconsistent. I suggest that you layer the most prominent sound in that section.

Layering in the bass drum/snares/or other stuff, so that you have a melody which is perfectly prominent have jumps that will more than likely seem random to those who are actually play it - direct layering works like garbage in this section. Accent layering works loads better and looks cleaner. (P.S. I changed this section myself.)

m28-m31: You can hear that base kicking in so you might wanna layer that part to keep the file flowing.

The focus of this entire section was just the synthesized lead runs, even I noticed that and I didn't touch this section of the file. <_<

m32: Beat 124.00, you're missing a double

There's a cymbal crash hitting that beat, only one fading out on it.

m39: (subjectivemanias alert) the doubles could have been more expressive with the song rather than just PRing everything and making it look awkward.

Explain, because I rather like this section and it was another one that I didn't touch.

m40-m43: Missing some 4th doubles here and there. Listen carefully.

Bass + synth = exactly how it is. However, she is missing a single note at the end of m40.

m48: Beat 188.00 doesn't need a double; remove it.
Agreed, fixed.

Also, *remove the 4th note on Beat 189.00 and the **8th note on Beat 189.50 since those sounds are barely audible to the music. You might want to check on your layering as well.

Yet another part that I did. I will admit to the fact that I actually ghost stepped the section, but only ** is correct. * is not.

m49-END: Basically the same mistakes over and over again as mentioned above.

Considering these are the same largely subjective issues that happen over and over again, not really.

wc
missing 16th at 8.99.
missing 16th at 20.62.
missing 16th at 23.53.
missing 16th at 26.44.
pretty much you have missing 16th in every section like this were you're putting jumps to the lead synth so go back and make sure you get everything.

Added all of these. Thanks for picking up on that, because I did not catch those at all.

at 56.89 you step the clap and bass kick then you stop stepping the bass kick and then you start stepping the basskick for no real reason. try to stay consistent with your layering. i suggest just putting jumps to the clap and stepping the drums as single notes.

This section, I didn't touch whatsoever. I saw Kayla use separate charts for layering this entire section - what it looks like to me is a bass/clap/synth layering, avoiding triples where all three coincide. I may be wrong but I can figure it out later down the line.

68.172 i kinda get that the 16ths go to the vocals only thing is that the vocals are 3 syllables that land on 8ths so the rest of the notes go to?

Not too sure about this - can you explain in a little bit more detail?

you should continue stepping the closed hihat after the 16th run that goes to the the closed hihat at 117.99.

I agree with this as well - went through and changed it to lone 8th notes without adding layering at any point when they coincide with another instrument, for accenting consistency. Thanks again.

Kory
In the beginning you overuse the jumps. Don't really need them to every single sound.
Same goes for the section around m50 that you do the same thing in.

Is there any other way to step this without making awkward looking layering while still accenting the relevant sounds? Layering in really dull/quiet sounds where there's really not an extended percussion line makes it look strange.

qqwref
Instead of stepping something quiet in m11-12, maybe you could keep doing the background, but add in the quiet notes with layering. Add some 16ths at the end of m57.

Fixed m57. m11/m12 is an issue because if you layer in anything outside of those, you'll get random jumps everywhere.

The point that I'm trying to make is, people are judging way too harshly on extremely subjective errors and not enough on objective errors like missed sounds, progression errors, etc.

Thanks for finding the important mistakes, though.

[kjwkjw]

For one of my files, I got [+], [+.], [?], and [-] from the four judges.

lol

[jimerax]

ok good work judges, I'm calculating the overall ratings now.

ps. meh

[TC_Halogen]

Originally Posted by kjwkjw

For one of my files, I got [+], [+.], [?], and [-] from the four judges.

lol

Sorry kjwkjw.

[kjwkjw]

Originally Posted by TC_Halogen

Sorry kjwkjw.

It wasn't the file that was in your group, haha.

Though the one that *was*, you were the only one to give me something other than a [+] or a [+.]

I'll try what you suggested in your notes

[AsphyxZero]

Originally Posted by TC_Halogen

I'm going to separate everyone's notes bit by bit.... I'm not attacking anyone, but merely stating points/disagreements.

I see.

[bmah]

Originally Posted by jimerax

ok good work judges, I'm calcurating the overall ratings now.

lol

if this was a spelling error, then it sure made sense ANYHOW

[TC_Halogen]

Originally Posted by kjwkjw

It wasn't the file that was in your group, haha.

Though the one that *was*, you were the only one to give me something other than a [+] or a [+.]

I'll try what you suggested in your notes

D: I happen to be very pattern/accent-oriented, sorry!

Originally Posted by AsphyxZero

I see.

WHAT, I may be Rican but I don't argue with everyone. I actually asked questions and made a few fixes.

calcurating

engrish :3

[jimerax]

Group 1

2008 (Kommisar) - 20 (5/5/5/5)
Field of Snow (Patashu) - 19+ (4/5/5+/5)
Champion Freeverse (wc) - 19 (5/4/5/5)
Can Can (woker-X) - 18 (4/5/4/5)
Cinnamon Roll (Kommisar) - 17 (5/5/4/3)
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
Destination Unknown (Dark_Chrysalis) - 16 (3/4/5/4)
=======================================================================
Everything Went Numb (wc) - 16 (4/5/4/3) [Hold - NG]
Famicom Selecta (Dark_Chrysalis) - (16) (</4/4/5) [Close]
Feux d'artifice (Xandertrax) - 15 (4/1/5/5)
Capriccio No.24 (woker-X) - 15 (2/4/4/5)
Chik Habit (AlexDest) - 15 (3/4/5/3)
Fighting of the Spirit (Kory) - 15 (4/4/3/4)
{Lazy Summer Days} (Silvuh) - 14 (3/4/4/3)
Black Apple (Kory) - 14 (4/4/3/3)
Famicom Selecta (MrPopadopalis25) - (14) (4/</</4)
Canon In WHEE V2 (qqwref) - 13 (4/3/2/4)
Connect (wc) - 13 (4/3/2/4)
Beautiful Arrhythmia (iironiic) - 12 (4/2/3/3)
Creature (AsphyxZero) - 12 (3/4/3/2)
CAMELLIA! ~Dangerous Camellia Vacation~ (daro-) - 11 (2/2/4/3)
C&E (qqwref) - 11 (3/2/3/3)
Dance Weekend (ichliebekase) - 10 (1/3/4/2)
Amputee (Dossar) - 10 (2/3/2/3)
Bedtime Story (Dark_Chrysalis) - 6 (2/2/1/1)
Dizzy (bobbob) - 5 (1/1/2/1)


Group 2

Puzzle (bmah & leonid) - 19 (4/5/5/5)
Ice Disk (ElectricWerewolf) - 18 (3/5/5/5)
Guitar Sounds (who_cares973) - 18 (4/5/4/5)
Miraiya (bmah) - 18 (4/5/5/4)
Waltz In The Rain (who_cares973) - 18 (4/4/5/5)
No Purpose Flour (iiconiic + wc) - 17+ (4/5+/3/5)
Lune Noir (Kory) - 17 (5/4/3/5)
---------------------------------------------------------------------
Fly away -mix del matador- (bmah) - 16 (3/4/4/5)
The Club (Dark_Chrysalis) - 16 (4/5/3/4)
He's a Pirate - F-777 ReMiX (megamon88) - 16 (4/5/3/4)
=====================================================================
Mysterious Desert (cry4eternity) - 15 (5/5/3/2)
Machine Dance [Light] (Khenra) - 15 (5/3/3/4)
Lawn Wake II (0) - 14 (2/4/3/5)
Nocturne (Dark_Chrysalis) - 14 (3/3/4/4)
Phalanx (FFR Cut) (customstuff) - 14 (3/5/3/3)
Nitro Manta (Dark_Chrysalis) - 13 (3/3/4/3)
Minagiru Kirby (kjwkjw) - 12 (5/2/4/1)
Metro (DossarLX ODI) - 11 (5/2/3/1)
Four Blocks Madness (woker-X) - 11 (3/4/3/1)
Radiant Flux (Exias) - 10 (3/1/3/3)
The Club (Kory) - 10 (3/1/3/3)
-Glorious Morning- (Waterflame) - 10 (2/3/3/2)
Hyper Highspeed Star (Izzy) - 9 (3/2/2/2)
One More Cutie (0) - 8 (2/2/2/2)
Rainbow Tylenol (bob bob) - 7 (1/1/4/1)


Group 3

Variations 2 (jimerax) - 20+ (5+/5/5/5)
Staring at my Spaceship (Kommisar) - 19++ (4/5+/5/5+)
Infinity Hyperspace (Kommisar) - 19 (5/5/4/5)
REVERSE SQUIGGLY (Silvuh) - 19 (4/5/5/5)
Grist (Patashu) - 18 (4/4/5/5)
The Battle With The Betrayed (Patashu) - 17 (4/3/5/5)
Tamashii (Dark_Chrysalis) - 17 (4/5/4/4)
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Sing for Absolution (Patashu) - 16 (4/2/5/5)
Sexplosion (woker-X) - 16 (3/5/5/3)
Through the Martian Hell (woker-X) - 16 (3/3/5/5)
Spacedust (Silvuh) - 16 (4/3/4/5)
=============================================================================
When Petals Fall (Silvuh) - 16 (1/5/5/5) [Multi Chart- NG]
To the Heaven (kjwkjw) - 15 (2/4/4/5)
Scavenger (Plan_Bsk81127) - 14 (3/4/4/3)
Elements of a Party (dore) - 13 (2/3/4/4)
You Should Drink Cucumber Flavored Beer! (Patashu) - 12 (3/5/2/2)
The Final Hour (psychoangel691) - 12 (4/3/3/2)
Rockhill (bob bob) - 10 (1/4/3/2)
Shy Guy Toybox Twisted Remix (ichliebekase) - 10 (3/2/4/1)
Where Ya Been Lars? (MrPopadolis25) - 8 (1/4/2/1)
Trisection v2 (trumaestro) - 8 (2/1/2/3)
Worse (Xandertrax) - 7 (2/2/1/2)
you're dumb (nois-or-e) - 7- (1-/1/2/3)
Thrash The Plank (T-Force) - 6 (2/2/1/1)
Trip to the Moon v2 (bob bob) - 6 (2/2/1/1)
Toho Mathetmatics (SacredInsanity) - 5 (1/1/1/2)

Need to determine the final acceptance, for borderline files.