TWG 192: Sunfan's Cool Game Game Thread

[mellon_collie]

Originally Posted by mellon_collie

I like that shadowgod immediately ISO'd me after I said I had thoughts in my other posts. It seems just like a human-y thing to do, like he actually has to investigate me and doesn't have any extra information

and just in general I think Shadow is looking pretty towny. I thought the posts he was making last night seemed to follow a natural way of thinking

I just ISO'd myself though and he missed a few things, mainly my thoughts on Haku and Xiz. Not sure if he just missed these or if he intentionally made it seem like I had done less than I did :thonk:

[MixMasterLar]

Originally Posted by mellon_collie

I just ISO'd myself though and he missed a few things, mainly my thoughts on Haku and Xiz. Not sure if he just missed these or if he intentionally made it seem like I had done less than I did :thonk:

Do you uh...normally have to ISO yourself to remember who all you've commented on?

[Bolth mannn]

Originally Posted by Hakulyte

That's like a big ouch.

????

freeze was taunting me for some reads on players after 3 and a half hours of gameplay, so I obliged.

Originally Posted by Shadow_God_10

Why would he feel like he's in danger like less than 12 hours into the game?

Ever since shooting shit back at freezing, I feel like I've had to play defensively. This might just be because I'm not used to the game. Can you blame me? I was attacked very early on for non-serious posts.

Anyway, I've observed enough, gonna do some reads.

MML, roundbox, Shadow and Fat Fuck are all town reads from me. They are asking good questions to others and to themselves, and I feel like they are making an overall impact on the game in a positive way. I wouldn't feel comfortable voting for any of these guys on d0.

I am extremely against poptarts playstyle in this game. No reads either way because he hasn't given us a chance to. Regardless of what happens from here until EOD, I'm pretty unhappy playing with someone like this.

I'll go through my thoughts on the rest:

DaBackPack: There hasn't been anything new from him since I last mentioned it but again, I really don't like his wham bam vote. It was right in the middle of everyone reading into my initial longpost and no one thought twice of him throwing that vote out there, and nobody asked him for an explanation. He didn't give an explanation on that OR on any of the other vague reads he made. He has offered nothing to the game thus far and I'm suspicious of his motives.

mellon_collie: I still feel like youre floating through this too easily. Your take on Xiz was simply that you weren't a fan of him wanting to lynch AFKers. Your take on Haku is not really a take either, just you asking him why our interaction on the first couple pages is such a hot topic for him. Again, you've given no real independant thoughts on anyone in this game and no one is really demanding them from you either. I don't like this.

Originally Posted by MixMasterLar

Bolth, Raeko is always kind of just like this d0. Not clearing her, but I don't think for her meta she's particularly UTR.

Maybe, maybe not. I think it would be unwise for me to try and judge anyones actions in this game based on their actions in previous games. Her actions in this one make me suspicious, and I'm not a fan of most people just giving her a free pass.

storn42: storny is very similar to mellon for me, not giving any independant thoughts on anyone in the game until recently just now. Responding to things in a very de-escalating manner, avoiding conflict. His reasoning for freeze is based on a very very early interaction, and he hasn't commented on anything since.

Hakulyte: Firstly,

Originally Posted by Hakulyte

If you're Roundbox or Plop you can ignore what I said in the last few pages.

What is this??? Secondly, Haku is someone I'm having the most trouble reading. My gut tells me there's something off about the way he interacts with everyone, I don't like that he went into a whole pity thing earlier, and he seems to have a very high opinion of himself and his gameplay, which, regardless of alignment, I don't really like playing with people like that. His style seems to be very self aware, and he seems to ask questions looking for reactions rather than answers. He seems to be commenting on everyone fairly equally even though he spent a lot of time tunnelling me. Still unsure how to read.

Xiz: Another one I don't really know how to read. He has been tunneling me hard. While ISOing him I swear to god 95% of his posts have my name in them. Problem is, all his other reads are based on his assumption of me being wolf, so there's nothing there I'm finding inherently helpful.

Freeze: You said you would come back with an analysis on my response to you after work. You did not do that. You made a single response to MML regarding his accusation on you posting a lot. You have not posted since. Was your strategy to hardpush me and then sit back and observe the fallout? Your posting has been extremely inconsistent. Very high volume at the start, nothing since. I hope to hear more from you before EoD because you've dropped off the face of the earth.

Gradiant: I can't tell if I just don't like your playstyle or if I am suspicious of you. You have a very low post count. Your posts do seem to be thought out but you also got strangely defensive of my call for you to post more, considering you had only made 2 actual reads which were both light town reads, nothing that really sparks conversation or gives anyone anything to go off. Your most recent post is more what I'm after, however, you're really only going after one person (haku), which is not unwarranted, however, I really want to know what you think of more people.

At this point, I'm torn on who to vote for. I am hoping something happens in the next few hours that clear things up for me.

[XelNya]

Originally Posted by MixMasterLar

Do you uh...normally have to ISO yourself to remember who all you've commented on?

Speaking of Lar, this post is... Unhealthy.

If I was alive at this point I'd have voted him for it.

[Xiz]

Originally Posted by mellon_collie

I just ISO'd myself though and he missed a few things, mainly my thoughts on Haku and Xiz. Not sure if he just missed these or if he intentionally made it seem like I had done less than I did :thonk:

He as in haku or me

[Shadow_God_10]

Originally Posted by mellon_collie

I just ISO'd myself though and he missed a few things, mainly my thoughts on Haku and Xiz. Not sure if he just missed these or if he intentionally made it seem like I had done less than I did :thonk:

Can confirm I missed these entirely.

Iirc the Xiz interaction was based on the stance of lynching inactives?

I don't remember the Haku thing though