TWG CXLVI - Remembering Storn42

[Jtehanonymous]

does the parity rule apply to independents. if it does then that's impossible since it'd be 2:0:2 best case.

[Charu]

Yes.

None one first night

dAnceguy 2nd night

Boss Bitch 3rd night

Roundbox 4th night

[Charu]

Originally Posted by roundbox

What if Charu was also purple
I'm going crazy this game but I don't care

Isn't that what all you idiots are trying to say anyways?

If you all were saying you believe V because you thought I'm a wolf.

Then my word

[Charu]

[Jtehanonymous]

The biggest problem I have with letting Charu live is this:

He claimed a nerfed medic role. The numbers for indp/wolves or whatever couldn't have been all that astounding during that phase. I would've thought they'd be a bit desperate even at that point since we had knocked town quite a few reds at that point. I would think killing charu at that moment in time would be priority. If they didn't, they risk falling even FURTHER behind at that point.

they didn't even try to kill you roundbox, since two kills happened (bb and fg). You and charu were the most obvious targets since you both claimed. for you both to still be here and telling the truth is just not sitting well with me.

Even aside from all of this, I think killing the purple here at least gives us a shot. There's at least reasoning behind that choice instead of trying to come up with some twisted way Charu is either manipulating things, is a sixth wolf, is another purple etc...

[Charu]

Oh boy, I feel like this entire phase is going to be exactly like this right until EoD... that is if we get there.

Hee hee hee

[Vendetta21]

One thing I also find suspicious here is how Charu chose to reveal who he was "guarding" last night effectively nullifying his chance at protecting someone from the night kill and bringing this phase to what seems to be LyLo. To me that falls inline with the general aroma of distrust I have towards him generally.

[Vendetta21]

Also I just want to say most of my read on Charu feels like it's based on motivation and tone. The fact that there were two kills yesterday and one of them was a wolf suggests if Xiz is following Natural Order/Action Resolution (which is one of our site standards) funnygirl didn't make the second kill, and I'm not going to try to surmise what random roles are left in the game in this context, I'm just going to find the person who I believe to be acting as a confederate, which to me appears to be Charu.

[Charu]

Confederate THIS, you butt!

*Sticks up middle finger OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO*

[roundbox]

Hey wolves and evil people confess please I'm still not home and I'm tired

[Vendetta21]

i just got home, i'm insanely tired. i thought the phase ended tomorrow but i guess it ends todayu

another thing i've noticed here is how charu keeps making assumptions about the game set-up and assuming them as true as a part of his presence of mind right now, for instance questioning jteh's extremely towny effort to determine if there was ever 6/6 [parity

[Vendetta21]

like the only scenario i understand making those assumptions in is one in where you are trying to shill an agenda

[Vendetta21]

jteh trying to determine 6/6 parity and going to that length clears him, to me, at this point

[Vendetta21]

boss bitch illuminating roundbox as cop i feel clears him well enough. which makes her an interesting kill last night. iirc funnygirl could track who targeted who? the combination of the two kills just gives me the impression charu neither wanted to be tracked nor revealed.

[Vendetta21]

if charu didn't kill two people and only one, to me that leaves a kill from jteh, which says that this isn't a game that town could ever win and it's a battle between two independents to catch each other. this logic, to some degree, has support, but given the motivation and tone of jteh i see as less likely.

[Vendetta21]

on the off chance that that is true and i had to chose between two independents to win tho, i would chose jteh because he probably deserves it more, and would still kill charu.

[Vendetta21]

there is no scenario i see where roundbox is not town, i just don't believe that at this point

[Vendetta21]

Originally Posted by Vendetta21

if charu didn't kill two people and only one, to me that leaves a kill from jteh, which says that this isn't a game that town could ever win and it's a battle between two independents to catch each other. this logic, to some degree, has support, but given the motivation and tone of jteh i see as less likely.

actually lol in this scenario there is also the scenario where i am lynched and they shoot each other rendering a town victory hahahaha that would be clutch as shit

[Vendetta21]

i mean that's a possibility but with every permutation i still see charu as anti-town, and even if he doesn't die today i'm keeping that vote there for I-Told-You-So-ism

[Vendetta21]

to be clear, why i eliminate the possibility of jteh killing two people while still hold it in the bank for charu is "why would jeth care/try-hard so much this phase if I was already an easy target and he would win by lynching me?" and there is no fathomable answer to that question.