TWG CLXVII Game Thread How Was Awakening Reviewed

[Celirra]

Also @MML, sorry for coming off as white noise; it's an issue of mine putting my thoughts in words for arguments at times, as cited by a prof I had last semester. I'll try to put more diligence in explaining.

[tiloco217]

I took character guessing into consideration and I don't think it's guessable with the info I gave. I've played through about half of awakening by the way. The roles seems to have very little to do with their characters in general.

[Soundwave-]

Originally Posted by MixMasterLar

Fair 'nuff

You have a reads list you'd like to share?

Uh yeah I guess. I'd like to iso some more people and stuff. Are we on a 48 hour day or do I need to rush this out?

[Soundwave-]

We are on a 48 hour day, so yeah unless you got some questions I'll put a list together.

[tiloco217]

I agree with a lot of points that MML made in his reads list but I don't see very much commitment in the reads. Most give a general idea of how MML is reading them and then gives them some sort of out.

[MixMasterLar]

Originally Posted by Soundwave-

We are on a 48 hour day, so yeah unless you got some questions I'll put a list together.

Well, a quick list to show where you are would be nice, and you can ISO some peeps and amend it with new info. That would show me your progression which is always helpful in reading people. If you plan to do a full hands on read list later after some work, a simple tier list will do for now

[MixMasterLar]

Originally Posted by tiloco217

I agree with a lot of points that MML made in his reads list but I don't see very much commitment in the reads. Most give a general idea of how MML is reading them and then gives them some sort of out.

You take issue with my reads list?

The only person I gave an out to was Blind, and that's more the formality of it since others seemed to think he was town last phase. Make no mistake if I had to cast a vote right now it would be Blind.

Looking back, I guess you can make the argument that I give Manti an out but I think that was a legit point that needed to be made personally.

[MixMasterLar]

Actually, where the fuck are your reads Til? Other then that half of reads list you made EoD0 you don't even do the courtesy of arranging your thoughts for us it seems unless I keep missing it (which I fucking doubt)

[Soundwave-]

Originally Posted by MixMasterLar

Well, a quick list to show where you are would be nice, and you can ISO some peeps and amend it with new info. That would show me your progression which is always helpful in reading people. If you plan to do a full hands on read list later after some work, a simple tier list will do for now

Aight, I'll throw out some tiers, but like going to be 100% honest takin' the L here I haven't paid near enough attention to this game as I should have

Town Lean:
InD
Lar
Xiz
Til

Null:
Cel
WV
Tokzic
blind
DBP

Scum Lean:
Manti

Super interesting I know it's almost like I can't even summarize what most of the people on this list have said this game.

First day I kinda just was on the look out for weird EoD stuff and didn't see anything concerning, hence why no serious vote. Second I actually bothered to iso the lynch candidates, which is how I decided to place my vote.

[Soundwave-]

Most of that is just by like, tone and stuff, btw. Hence why if I'm going to put out a reads list I actually like, want some good reasoning and shit.

[MixMasterLar]

Eh, at least your honest with your shortcomings.

Please make that ISO-backed reads list before EoD to avoid people feeling the need to rush through it, tho.

[MixMasterLar]

Originally Posted by Soundwave-

Town Lean:
InD
Lar
Xiz
Til

Null:
Cel
WV
Tokzic
blind
DBP

Scum Lean:
Manti

That null section concerns me as those are some polarizing players IMHO

[MixMasterLar]

Like, I'm super interested to see who moves where

[MixMasterLar]

Really ticked off by lack of reads from Til, tbh.
Don't be one of those PRs who think it's cool to slack off because of your role because that shit doesn't help town.

[the sun fan]

Votecount:
Xiz (1)- Manti

[MixMasterLar]

Manti you been there for awhile but haven't said that much. You got any thoughts?

[Soundwave-]

Originally Posted by MixMasterLar

Eh, at least your honest with your shortcomings.

Please make that ISO-backed reads list before EoD to avoid people feeling the need to rush through it, tho.

I'll try to get it tonight or at the latest, first possible opportunity tomorrow, to give some time to go through it before EoD

[tiloco217]

@MML
You tell tokzic to make more detailed posts
Read on me was a reverse out. Read me town with the conditions for you to switch
Blind was the most obvious out
WV needs more content
DBP needs to bring the fire

There is very little in the way of reads that you seem to actually feel strongly about with the only notable exception being Indheart

As for my reads list, you're right. I haven't made a full reads list and collected my thoughts into one place but my reads are all out there. I might get to posting one tonight but I'm not currently working on one. Real quick reads from scum to town are:

Xiz //Everything he does just feels off to me. Nothing super scummy on it's own but it adds up
Cel //Intro that I think was too good and flip on me that I think was unjustified
Sound //scummy individual play but unlikely to be with xel
MML //more of a null read
WV //again mostly null
Tokzic //would be higher but Xiz and Cel were on him
Blind //I really like his tone but don't remember much content I cared about
Manti //I think his posts matter a lot more than his eods. Like his posts a lot
Ind //no reason for him to lead a lynch on xel if they were partners
DBP //Can't think of a single thing he's done that I didn't like

Xiz and Cel could switch pretty easily. I'm pretty confident on both of them.

Ind and DBP are off the table

[tiloco217]

I had those //'s lined up all nice but I guess ffr doesn't like a lot of spaces

[Celirra]

Originally Posted by tiloco217

Cel //Intro that I think was too good and flip on me that I think was unjustified

I'm starting to come around on you a bit... most of that is taking Freezin's stance on you to heart a little bit perhaps.

I've been considering it, and given the context of the wolves trying to set up Tiloco:

D0/N1, roundbox and/or haku kill, both of which make Tiloco look fairly bad.
D1 claim blue, N2 not killed by wolves.
It could very well be a case of trying to make you seem scummy by the wolves. That or you're just playing the "too wolfy to be considered a wolf" game, but... well, I have doubts that you're doing that.

I don't know whether or not you being blue is true, but I hope you report back with something tomorrow; if what your claim is truly is true, go for the guaranteed tonight.


Also I'm curious about why my intro was "too good", but I'll take it as a compliment.



ps. quoting you did in fact prove you took effort to line up the //'s, so props to you. I find using bold or colours, followed by a fresh line, as a good strategy though for the goal you were going for.