TWG CLXXIV - Sounds Like You've got a Problem. - Game Thread

[TWGma]

suckit.dx

[roundbox]

Originally Posted by roundbox

your post doesn't really answer this voting reason, as I can tell

you assert here that the kitb missed, therefore wnb is a wolf
you say in your other post that you felt "something wasn't rubbing right" about wnb

do you actually believe that the kitb missing makes wnb a wolf here, or is it your "not rubbing right"? or both?

hey blind I see you
can you answer this last question?

[TWGma]

Is it a bad play? Bad idea? Oh probably.
But it'll make me rest that much easier if I have to reset and refresh if I'm wrong.
If I'm right on one to start? Well... I hope you don't mind inflated egos.

[inDheart]

i didn't really think the second thing was a question but wolf sunfan has written long responses to posts that don't even pressure him before

[reuben_tate]

Originally Posted by star-crossed

I am wondering, if you have this intensive of notes about who everybody voted, talked to, and had leans on. Or is it that you were more focused on Gradiant, because of your theory about it being a good time to kill him if he is on the right track?

I feel kind of weird saying this, since I do not really want to encourage people to be quiet and say it is because they are reading, but I am liking reuben somewhat for seeming to be thorough, with his reading (because I think mafias may not need to read as closely, because they do not really have to figure things out). It is the main thing from him that I have a lean on besides that he is funny, though, so I still feel that I should.

Unfortunately, I don't have as notes like that for each person. Most of notes consists of randomly scattered ideas and paraphrasings of the "meatier" posts that happen in the thread so I can easily skim through it and try to see a "big picture".

I mostly looked at gradiant since I was trying to analyze the night actions so his actions were tantamount to my ideas and helped to solidfy reads that I had on people.

[star-crossed]

Originally Posted by reuben_tate

Unfortunately, I don't have as notes like that for each person. Most of notes consists of randomly scattered ideas and paraphrasings of the "meatier" posts that happen in the thread so I can easily skim through it and try to see a "big picture".

I mostly looked at gradiant since I was trying to analyze the night actions so his actions were tantamount to my ideas and helped to solidfy reads that I had on people.

OK. Well I would be interested, if you would like to be more specific about those notes.

[roundbox]

Originally Posted by reuben_tate

I disagree that it gets us "nowhere". It's not like the night kills are determined by wolf's rolling some dice, there is usually motivation behind the actions of the wolves. Usually this leaves us with finitely many options, some much more plausible than others. The reason I think it is helpful is because when I make a read, I want to make sure it holds some level of consistency with plausible set of wolf night actions.

As for "being a stretch", I only meant that for WnB. I do feel strongly that MML is likely town because of it and I feel strongly that the analysis is inconclusive for both myself and star-cross.

I guess I should rephrase the word "nowhere", but I'm going to be a turbo fucking nerd and invoke a video game character and their views on lies and truth:

"There's only one truth, but endless possibilities for lies, y'know?"

all of these people weaving narratives for what could have happened just feel like they're having a hard influence on who to vote. I would wager one of the people speculating might actually have a devious purpose to it. among those are t-force, reuben, and MML. yours sounds the fishiest, t-forces sounds like a natural reaction, and MMLs seems a bit dumbfounded so if I really wanted to drive this point home, I'd say it's one of you or MML

I feel really different this game about my analytical style and I think it has to do with me recently playing DRV3 and watching a bunch of logic and argument videos on youtube

[inDheart]

Originally Posted by TWGma

Is it a bad play? Bad idea? Oh probably.
But it'll make me rest that much easier if I have to reset and refresh if I'm wrong.
If I'm right on one to start? Well... I hope you don't mind inflated egos.

holy shit

i want to lynch this post

[the sun fan]

Originally Posted by inDheart

holy shit

i want to lynch this post

somewhere, alette shudders

[roundbox]

Originally Posted by TWGma

Is it a bad play? Bad idea? Oh probably.
But it'll make me rest that much easier if I have to reset and refresh if I'm wrong.
If I'm right on one to start? Well... I hope you don't mind inflated egos.

yeah but the way you're going about this is wagering your entire game and investigative strength on something you called a HOT TAKE
it doesn't inspire confidence

[the sun fan]

I might switch over to blind tbh

[the sun fan]

when blind gets like this, I think he's a lot more likely to be a wolf
he's not really trying to be solvey imo and I think his progression on wabby specifically is ???????

also inD is doing things and while I am still slightly pinged doing things is a pretty good thing

[inDheart]

Originally Posted by the sun fan

somewhere, alette shudders

man you posted this knowing only i would get it too

[star-crossed]

Originally Posted by blindreper1179

That hurts sun. I don't see that being out of town play being I'm town, but you don't know that yet.

Can somebody tell me, if it seems normal for blind to post this as a town, to somebody he does not strongly townread?

[the sun fan]

Originally Posted by inDheart

man you posted this knowing only i would get it too

don't tell no mandy, its just a lanmower turned bankways

[star-crossed]

I am tempted to table inD for now and reinvestigate later, because I do like his overall engagement more now (including the reads post, especially about blind and raeko, but that he is kind of trying to work through T-Force/reuben; it reminds me of his attitude at the end of the days in our hydra game, basically, more than in the turbo).

I am considering voting for raeko, because I felt that her analysis of my long post was more likely to be motivated by trying to sound like she was critically thinking, than somebody who actually was (from her disagreement on the interpretation of the words, as I have discussed before). But I feel weird about it because I do not know what roundbox thinks of her. He only really mentioned mindmelding with her on something kind of boring?

I am also considering voting for blind, basically just because of that message.

I would like to go to bed, so please talk to me.

[the sun fan]

Originally Posted by star-crossed

Can somebody tell me, if it seems normal for blind to post this as a town, to somebody he does not strongly townread?

Its not super abnormal, and honestly I'm stretching a bit for the read here and its not something I care a lot about and don't really factor it into my read but the wording itself seems fine... just not sure that he actually felt hurt there. When he reacts to something like that... its a bit different imo. There's more emotion and there hasn't really been any of that this game.

[inDheart]

Originally Posted by star-crossed

Can somebody tell me, if it seems normal for blind to post this as a town, to somebody he does not strongly townread?

i kinda already weighed in on this but there was one wolf game where he played up fear and suspicion that the stronger players were going to hoodwink everyone (he included sunfan in this to bus him)

iirc he can have confidence that people are town and i don't really get it but i don't think he had that for sunfan in his reads

peculiar

[the sun fan]

Originally Posted by star-crossed

I am tempted to table inD for now and reinvestigate later, because I do like his overall engagement more now (including the reads post, especially about blind and raeko, but that he is kind of trying to work through T-Force/reuben; it reminds me of his attitude at the end of the days in our hydra game, basically, more than in the turbo).

I am considering voting for raeko, because I felt that her analysis of my long post was more likely to be motivated by trying to sound like she was critically thinking, than somebody who actually was (from her disagreement on the interpretation of the words, as I have discussed before). But I feel weird about it because I do not know what roundbox thinks of her. He only really mentioned mindmelding with her on something kind of boring?

I am also considering voting for blind, basically just because of that message.

I would like to go to bed, so please talk to me.

I think this is a really good post and I think that all three of these candidates are good to great lynches

can you talk to me about your stronger townreads?

why are you more comfortable with me as opposed to inD now that you're shelving inD (apparently)

on a scale of 1-10 how high was Trevor when he made that reads list

which is the best Final Fantasy game

[the sun fan]

hey, its lar
welcome back lar