The 200th & 201st Skill Token Ideas

[Gradiant]

Originally Posted by Tru

No permission rules, just be on sync

If files need perms through the submission rules, then there should be perms for the token as well

[Klarion]

Originally Posted by Gradiant

If files need perms through the submission rules, then there should be perms for the token as well

Can't help but agree with this, I don't see why special token shouldn't follow perm guidelines, we have enough good songs anyways.

[Lights]

Knowing the tenuous state of permissions (and the presence of a not-insignificant number of songs ingame that don't actually have them) I'm not against a non-permission yolo token. Depending on the song it wouldn't be any more likely to be DMCA'd than several files currently ingame and so few people would have it that it'd be even less likely to be discovered.

On principle alone, though, it probably should be a song that we have permission for.

[rushyrulz]

whatever you do, no Token Whore v2 thxu

Originally Posted by emulord

I think it should be "Get every non-event Achievement token", simply because that token goal doesn't exist yet. Yes it would be far easier than Token Whore, but the two of them give a good 100% goal for completionists.

I kinda like this one ngl.
Problems with it are:
1. PianoCore is a big blocker and goalpost mover.
2. New achievement tokens being added will also move the goalposts.
3. Does it make sense to award a "skill token" for earning all achievement tokens? I suppose it's not too much of a stretch of the imagination to get there.

-----

I wonder how feasible "Pass / FC / AAA a song from every year in order from 2002 to <insert year token 200 is added here> in order" would be. No goalpost moving, celebrates the history of FFR perfectly IMO and fits well as a milestone token.

[XelNya]

Originally Posted by rushyrulz

whatever you do, no Token Whore v2 thxu



I kinda like this one ngl.
Problems with it are:
1. PianoCore is a big blocker and goalpost mover.
2. New achievement tokens being added will also move the goalposts.
3. Does it make sense to award a "skill token" for earning all achievement tokens? I suppose it's not too much of a stretch of the imagination to get there.

-----

I wonder how feasible "Pass / FC / AAA a song from every year in order from 2002 to <insert year token 200 is added here> in order" would be. No goalpost moving, celebrates the history of FFR perfectly IMO and fits well as a milestone token.

it makes more sense than forcing antipas and as far as a moving goal post, I think the original one even with the migrated goal posts is a nonargument because of how hard it would be naturally

I don't got a thing for that achievement token point tho

[hi19hi19]

Originally Posted by rushyrulz

I wonder how feasible "Pass / FC / AAA a song from every year in order from 2002 to <insert year token 200 is added here> in order" would be. No goalpost moving, celebrates the history of FFR perfectly IMO and fits well as a milestone token.

All tokens that are based on % of the game should be indexed to something static like a particular year in this way.

Tokens with goalposts that move are bad design and always have been.