TWG 203 Werewolves in Avalon GAME THREAD

[DarkManticoreX2]

Originally Posted by MixMasterLar

I dove into this in an unpublished post in a not cool way, but I still want to address this

Manti, you know your reason for voting me was that I was pushing the No Lynch too hard, right? But when you explain how I was pushing the no Lynch too hard your reason ends up being "well he was for it but isn't anymore. He 180'd on it. Wolf"

So in your world, if I liked the idea and stuck with it I'm a wolf, but if I liked the idea and then through conversation admitted it had drawbacks I'm still a wolf?

You can not explain your way out of this contradiction. You have given two different, opposing reasons for the vote that in the end you abandoned for really shady reasons.



That's a lot of focus on Juber for being indifferent

I don't like responding to important posts like this on mobile but here we go

My reason for voting you wasn't because you were pushing the No Lynch too hard. This is semantical maybe but Bugkid was the one who said you were pushing it too hard in post 270. I expect you to go back and confirm this.

I voted you because your stance flip was quick and in response to light pressure as I've said before. On D1, active wolves want to interact with the thread and get in good standing with it but don't want to draw too much attention. When I read your No lynch posts, they bothered me because they struck very close to this. You interacted with the idea of a No Lynch and kept it in conversation for quite a while and then backed off with the exact reasons it is a bad idea when Roudbox and mellon came out against it and bugkid also decided it was a bad idea. If you had reasons for liking it then I expected you to at least defend the option a little bit before switching off of it. I probably still wouldn't have liked your stance but at least you would have had a base you were working off of.

If you're mad about the first sentence of 267 (the post where I vote you but mess up my tag). That wasn't directed at you but just general frustration. No Lynch is a bad option unless it mechanically buys us another day or gets us more information and several people were flirting with the idea at the time.