Queue/Batch Discussion Thread v2

[bob bob]

2 ++ and a pass (speaking of the pass, who did it get passed to, i couldn't find it)

wat

[Ziergdsx18]

i noticed a lot of ++ on this batch.


wow so many pr0's up in here o.o

[justin_ator]

'cept me >.>

[hi19hi19]

Slightly confused as to where to go now.
I'm assuming my [++][+][+.] and [+.][+][+] are in the game. Of course I'll send minor fixes based on the notes I got but yeah, these two seem fine.

Caprice for Violin in B Minor Theme and Variations got a [+.][?][++]. Clearly two judges thought the file had merit, but wc didn't even really comment on the file, just said he thought the song should be different (okay..?)
I don't really know what to do with this. Submit it again and hope for different judges? Give up on the file? Wat do

And my [-][+.][PASS] file... exactly what happens with a [PASS] rating? I couldn't find any other notes about the file, was it actually passed to someone else?
Obviously it's not going to be accepted, but can I resubmit it next batch without it counting to my total, or do I have to submit it again with it taking up one of my maximum slots?

[jimerax]

I'll give ratings on [PASS] files.

[bmah]

Originally Posted by justin_ator

Can we work on recommended fixes and send it over as a fixed file, or is that submission set in stone until it gets accepted/rejected by jimerax or another judge?

If the file was conditionally accepted/borderline, you can send a fix anytime and it'll get placed in the queue.
If the file was rejected, you'll have to send the fix for the next batch (except you can't do that for the upcoming hard batch) and it'll be judged again. In other words, this will cause quite a bit of delay to a file you wanted to get in.

Originally Posted by bob bob

2 ++ and a pass (speaking of the pass, who did it get passed to, i couldn't find it)

It got passed to no one yet.

I'm currently requesting jimerax to test it however. (edit: ninja'd - see above)

[00Razor00]

Mfw the only vocal part I stepped in my chart was the "break it down" part which lasts like what? Not even 2 seconds? So I really have no idea what you're on about, AJ, lol.

Appreciate the notes, almost had borderline x) 10/20.

[megamon88]

15+, 15, 13 and 13? I think that means 4/4 I'll take a more detailed look at the notes later today and fix up the small stuff.

[iironiic]

14 and 13 here. I will definitely fix minor problems in those files later today.

EDIT: JX, did you get my resubmission for No Purpose Flour? I sent it about two weeks ago with my other two files. If not, I can resend an email.

[jimerax]

Originally Posted by iironiic

EDIT: JX, did you get my resubmission for No Purpose Flour? I sent it about two weeks ago with my other two files. If not, I can resend an email.

queue'd it with the fix.

[Elite Ninja]

oh cool so I guess 13/15 means accepted with fixes? I just might get my first file on FFR

When I get home from school today I will take your suggestions and fix the chart. Thanks for the notes!

[who_cares973]

Originally Posted by hi19hi19

Caprice for Violin in B Minor Theme and Variations [+.][?][++]
Not sure I agree with wc on this one... it's a Theme and Variations, that's how it's supposed to sound >_>
Well either way I was kinda expecting this, I had a feeling this would be controversial!

i dont see how this file is controversial ?_? the steps themselves are fine and fun its the song that dragged on and how broken it felt that was my problem. all the pauses in between ruined it for me and id personally rather see it as seperate files than 1 who cares if its a theme and variations.


ALSO

warren - + + +.
velocity - + +. +
stay crunchy - + + +.
throwing fire - + + +
stately, wrong - + +. ++

5/5

[bob bob]

Originally Posted by jimerax

I'll give ratings on [PASS] files.

o0o0o0o0o0o0o0o0o0o0o0
doubt ill get another ++ on earth blew up but we will see

[JSH]

Darling +, -, ?
lol

Tasteless +., +, +?
I still have a chance for this one!

[justin_ator]

I'm still a little confused as to whether my file is capable of getting in or not. It got an 11, so with fixes can it make it? Or will it have to be a resubmission later after the hard songs batch? I'll gladly fix it now if it means I could finally get a song in FFR.

[bob bob]

11 would mean resubmission unless it got +,+,-

[justin_ator]

Urgh, expect it next batch (obv after hard songs batch).

[One Winged Angel]

I was scouring this thread for like half an hour to find the batch notes before realizing they're posted in a separate thread, oops

But I saw AJ's post and shed a tear :')
lol I can't believe that dump is going to end up in-game

[TC_Halogen]

Originally Posted by 00Razor00

Mfw the only vocal part I stepped in my chart was the "break it down" part which lasts like what? Not even 2 seconds? So I really have no idea what you're on about, AJ, lol.

Appreciate the notes, almost had borderline x) 10/20.

Not too many points were taken off on all of those minor layering mentions because I wasn't sure about them. The biggest point choppers were the incorrect offset for the first half, and the misrhythms/missing notes for drums that you had (because looking at your layering scheme, I was fairly certain you were following drums). It looked like you were following vocals at some points of the song, so I decided to list those too, just to be safe.

[leonid]

offset can be readjusted after the chart goes in-game. It shouldn't be a huge point chopper







<-- Chopping points off