FFR Community Pack

[Relyks]

Originally Posted by dood gone krazee

Gonna submit some, maybe have the deadline somewhere in end of June or July? Just to get more people into it, make an epic pack, etc. etc.

Probably would be niceto have some graphic artists in this too. I won't be able to get any graphics.

Maybe have some more specific stepfile restrictions.
Like no 16th jacks that go for a minute long.
Or those stupid freeze-rolls things.

Ehh, if you want I can judge a bit.

By the way, do you happen to know a good BPM finder? I have MixMeister but it sucks. Do you have a program where I woild be like "BPM at 2:04 minute mark?" And it would tell me right at that moment when the BPM is.

Uhm, I'll do graphics.


I use BPM Detector PRO - the trial version.
I think it sucks, but I haven't really figured it out all the way. You might like it.

[blindreper1179]

thanks for your commentary. i'm just going to wait to fix anything until i hear what the others have to say as well.

[kommisar[os]]

white and nerdy 3/5 : i could just copy paste what i said for red fraction, still rejected


heaven 3.5/5 : technically it's correct. I actually liked this a bit, but blame this on song selection. also the 32nds were sorta weird and mines at the beginning weren't really necessary.


love cheat 3/5 : i think you stole my exact pattern for the end hehe. this was quite fun, mines imo were pretty awesomely placed. however, there are many inconsistencies (mini-freezes weren't necessary, the middle part with the jacks pr is off they should all be jacks and some long freezes are questionable). also pr in the beginning if off and some jacks could've been avoided to make it flow better. a few fixes would make this splendid


sandopolis 2.5/5 : freezes are very very inconsistent, some 16ths you placed were 24ths, forgot some key melodies in the song and mini-freezes were abused.



also sent a file play it

[WTFBrandon]

I have my song finally complete...
I feel something very important is missing but I can't figure it out...
I might just be confused but oh well, you be the judge.
I will send it in in a bit.
CoD4 Gun Sounds.

[blindreper1179]

Originally Posted by kommisar[os]

white and nerdy 3/5 : i could just copy paste what i said for red fraction, still rejected

well, what did you say about it? no one posted anything about it on rf.

[kommisar[os]]

song was boring and steps didn't make up for that

[moches]

did more reviews

Scar in the Earth- 4/5 Okay, first of all, who made the graphics, cause I need to go personally thank them. Secondly, maybe you should have followed the melody with freezes at the end like you did at the beginning/middle.

First Helping- 1.5/5 Heaven was a lot better than this. There’s not much you can do with the song + pitch relevancy issues + inconsistencies with freezes + incredibly generic steps = not very fun.

ps Kommi that was the only way to do the ending correctly hehe

[Professor Raine]

I hope you got my fix for Sandopolis

[kommisar[os]]

btw moches i had a version with mini-freezes following the melody. had freeze syndrome and was insanely annoying to play so i took them all out


ps dragoonhead made the gfx. he probably doesnt approve of me using them though

[moches]

Originally Posted by kommisar[os]

btw moches i had a version with mini-freezes following the melody. had freeze syndrome and was insanely annoying to play so i took them all out


ps dragoonhead made the gfx. he probably doesnt approve of me using them though

gah dragoonhead makes good graphics but he acts like he's better than me for some reason.

"i love how moches cant make good graphics but he think he can criticize other peoples simfiles"


edit: this is what i can tell for what's wrong with love cheat:

the minifreezes on the down arrow at the beginning go to the whoosh sound. every other freeze in measures 1-8 unneccesary, you were right. fixing pr also. the 48th minifreezes go to the trumpet. is it annoying to play? fixed jacks. oh, and i forgot the ! at the end of Love Cheat! i'll fix it.

[omgitznpv]

im getting lazy with judging someone help motivate me to judge the stuff

[/Itachi-san/]

um, I am not sure what you mean by motivate. /noob/

[blindreper1179]

npv, by judging these songs, you are lowering the population of off sync, crappy simfiles. you are helping lowering the number. without your help, this number grows drastically day by day. so, npv, help while you can before it's too late.

[jimerax]

why don't you set deadline/release date for the motivation?

[omgitznpv]

ok brb touhou then judging




Sandopolis Zone Act 2 - furryman

2/5

Poor jump/hand placement; annoying to play. Too much hold abuse and some parts aren't good with the music




White and Nerdy - blindreper1179 (need cdtitle? i dont see one)

1/5

quit out; poor layering in general (much with jumps/hands), poor hold usage, technical errors (and if they're not then its just awkward as fuc)





Love Cheat! - mooches

1/5

quit out wow mooches this is not a good file. really annoying to play; mines get annoying, poor pattern choices, pitch relevancy, layering etc





Scar in the Earth - Kommisar
nekomata master lookin forward to dis
2/5

disappointment not really fun, gets kind of repetitive for me. inconsistencies. did not really like the sound choices especially in the beginning.




First Helping - MrPoopaliss123524758643r

3/5

file is best it could be for this song, but the song is a terrible choice and doesn't exactly allow for a good file

[moches]

set deadline to July 4th (American pride). people keep sending those files!

edit: Love Cheat! wasn't that bad, holy ****ing crap. I'll fix it just for you npv >.<

[dragoonhead]

Originally Posted by kommisar[os]

ps dragoonhead made the gfx. he probably doesnt approve of me using them though

No i approve

[omgitznpv]

Originally Posted by moches

set deadline to July 4th (American pride). people keep sending those files!

I'll fix it just for you npv >.<

deadline is kind of really sudden/soon if i must say so myself.

also don't bother with love cheat i can't see a good file coming from it at all that people would like to play + mosaic.wav song lol

[moches]

Originally Posted by dragoonhead

No i approve

awesome thanks dude

[Legacyzero]

Originally Posted by omgitznpv

Scar in the Earth - Kommisar
nekomata master lookin forward to dis
2/5

disappointment not really fun, gets kind of repetitive for me. inconsistencies. did not really like the sound choices especially in the beginning.

lmao what I thought that file was accepted for the RFpack 2?

10% done on cemetary of (>_>) Onbashira