FFR Community Pack

[Legacyzero]

Originally Posted by omgitznpv

Black Rain - Legacy? (for the next four)

3/5

cool file, easily accepted with a few minor fixes. PR is off on a lot of the places lol. mines in the beginning are like wtf take them out rofl. missed a couple of 16ths here and there. recheck like 2 or 3 spots on the technical accuracies during the solo, i found a few when i slowed down the music to check the PiTcH rEleVaNCy of this one part

gap is off like fuc


Deep Striker - Legacy

2.5/5

file was kinda boring rofl. missed a lot of jump and hand opportunities. the first 48ths (the 28(46) pattern) is wrong (or sounds like it). m58 and wherever it repeats 24th trill? no


Hana Ranmin - Legacy

1.5/5

quit out lol the way you stepped it is lame as fuc pretty much. gap is off like fuc


Rokuju Nen Me No Touhou Saiban - Legacy

2.5/5

pr is off, gap is off by like what the hell 100ms or something lmao. mini-freezes were a bad choice mostly, you missed a lot of sounds, i dunno, this file was kinda meh

@Black rain: I tried to make files flow as well as possible. There were parts that could've been pitch relevant, but it felt like a mess when I tried it out in the editor, so pitch relevancy might be off at some points.

@Hana Ranmin: I'll make an another chart for it. Obviously one chart wasn't enough for this simfile.

Plus, you're the one that gave me bad ratings so far on my simfiles. Get on MSN, I added you.

[omgitznpv]

Most of the PR problems were in the solos and etc. where there wouldn't be much conflict with flow. I'm aware of stuff like flow; I often encounter problems myself. The PR problems weren't major or anything, anyways, so yeah.

With Hana Ranmin, I personally think the chart is better off not present, even if you were to add a second. It's pretty bad and not worth playing, IMO.

And I'm rarely on MSN because it's really buggy. If you want to catch me whenever, use AIM

[EnR]

moches, can I fix Hit you like thunder myself? send it in again, then if you still wanna fix it, you can?

[-Barista-]

Originally Posted by omgitznpv

Saruin - Barista

0/5

ok quit out lol wtf were you doing lmfao true dump

what?

[omgitznpv]

basically it was bad

very bad

[operationstrawbarry]

Originally Posted by omgitznpv

Hot-Headed v2 - Operationstrawbarry

1/5

quit out lol boring and dumpy file; really repetitive, no regards for the other sounds, and PR isn't existant lol
also can you not include stepped by operationstrawbarry as teh subtitle rofl

Original SES (Police In Helicopter) v2 - Operationstrawbarry

1/5

beginning wtf? technical accuracy throughout the file (24ths), and pretty much just bad- sounds incorporated, etc.

Going to wait for Kommi and Torrent to review. I knew I was going to get 1/5's from you.

[Legacyzero]

Originally Posted by operationstrawbarry

Going to wait for Kommi and Torrent to review. I knew I was going to get 1/5's from you.

If Omgnitz is that bad, kommisar and torrent are 10x worse on their ratings.

my black rain barely got away with a 3 rofl.

[omgitznpv]

lmao, refer to me as npv or something >_>

I generally judge somewhat strictly. I don't take ~fun~ too much into account when I judge, since I generally have a skewed image of an enjoyable file. I go more with technicalities and such.

*edit*

nvm I think I clicked you and eventualyl it showed up rofl

[Alioth]

Originally Posted by omgitznpv

lmao, refer to me as npv or something >_>

I generally judge somewhat strictly. I don't take ~fun~ too much into account when I judge, since I generally have a skewed image of an enjoyable file. I go more with technicalities and such.

*edit*

nvm I think I clicked you and eventualyl it showed up rofl

you're not quite the best structured judge, but yea, nobody is quite there yet from what i've seen with the past packs. i'm going to create a thread soon on how to judge in a pack.

edit: http://www.flashflashrevolution.com/...ad.php?t=93068

[moches]

Alioth good job lol

Oh and accepted Black Rain since Legacy fixed it.

more judging notes.

Saruin- 2/5 The whole file is more or less meh. Sorry, but if you want to step a marathon, you need to do a hell of a lot more with it.

1989- 3/5 Sometimes you used freezes for cymbals, and then at other times you used triples. Also, there was a 16th note that shouldn’t have been there where the music stopped. Lastly, you didn’t finish following the sound at the end. Fun, but needs some fixes.

Icarus- 4/5 Nice handling of speed-ups and jacks. I didn’t get some of the pitch relevancy at points, though.

Radio Heads- 3.5/5 It was pretty decent, but there are some errors. First of all, the entire song is half bpm, it just seems weird to me. Also, when you used freezes for guitars, there are parts where you got the rhythms wrong.

Last Battle- 4.5/5 What can I say, considering the other Last Battle, this one blew my mind. It’s fun and manages to be technical. Some of those streams seem to be freeform, but then you get back in control. Also, where you used freezes for the notes that are one dotted eight note apart from each other, followed by two 8th tap notes, the pitch relevancy was really off. Still, very good job.

Deep Striker v2- 4/5 Alright, much better.

[Legacyzero]

Originally Posted by moches

1989- 3/5 Sometimes you used freezes for cymbals, and then at other times you used triples. Also, there was a 16th note that shouldn’t have been there where the music stopped. Lastly, you didn’t finish following the sound at the end. Fun, but needs some fixes.

Icarus- 4/5 Nice handling of speed-ups and jacks. I didn’t get some of the pitch relevancy at points, though.

Last Battle- 4.5/5 What can I say, considering the other Last Battle, this one blew my mind. It’s fun and manages to be technical. Some of those streams seem to be freeform, but then you get back in control. Also, where you used freezes for the notes that are one dotted eight note apart from each other, followed by two 8th tap notes, the pitch relevancy was really off. Still, very good job.

Deep Striker v2- 4/5 Alright, much better.

For Icarus, Some of the pitch relevacy was changed because I thought the file would get really repetitive if it was left alone. What measure on Icarus exactly?

Also, don't bother considering Radio heads. One SSH file is enough.

On the last battle simfile, what measure was I wrong?

[operationstrawbarry]

Hey alioth is you're hotmail Ali0th92@hotmail.com? If so i accepted and whatsup and whats the occasion?. If not, someone added me and I dont know who it is LOL.

Edit: nvm... saw you're email on the judging thread a cople of post back. LOL

Edit: I do have a serious insane Jungle DNB song that I would like to have in either this pack or if its awsome (the song sure is) the RFpack. I have only a minute left of the song to step and it has a lot of stops. Need some advice before I continue. I will send the entire file over....

Edit3: Concerning my last post, I do take NPV's comments seriously, but since we have not heard from either Kommi nor Torrent, I only predicted what NPV would give me. And I was right. And Moches, I sent in the fixed up version of Original SES. its the v2. Im guessing you played it?

[moches]

icarus: 40-41, at the 8th freeze jumps. the third set should be the same jump.

last battle: 99-107 is one freeform stream, though probably no one will notice. 137-145 has the clusterfunk of dotted eighth notes.

[Legacyzero]

Originally Posted by moches

icarus: 40-41, at the 8th freeze jumps. the third set should be the same jump.

last battle: 99-107 is one freeform stream, though probably no one will notice. 137-145 has the clusterfunk of dotted eighth notes.

That part's the correct way to step that section. It does get annoying at some points though, but the pitch relevancy there's correct, for the most part.

Fixed the freeform stream.

For Icarus. On the measure at 40-41, the pitch relevancy of that jump sounded differently, if you listen to it closer.

[omgitznpv]

hey this is on-topic lmao

ruined

[Legacyzero]

Originally Posted by omgitznpv

hey this is on-topic lmao

ruined

lmfao.

Plus I should add the jumps on the beginning part of my deep strikers when the sound increase in pitch. It just feels weird as hell without it.

[kommisar[os]]

legacy said plus


=o

[Legacyzero]

Originally Posted by kommisar[os]

legacy said plus


=o

haven't said that in a while hehe.

[omgitznpv]

hey who wants to make gfx for my prism file

which is coming here anyways rofl probably going to get rejected anyways because i got lazy and made the chorus a dumpstream rofl

[Legacyzero]

Originally Posted by omgitznpv

hey who wants to make gfx for my prism file

which is coming here anyways rofl probably going to get rejected anyways because i got lazy and made the chorus a dumpstream rofl

Sometimes dumpstreams can be fun.

Plus, I'll make gfx for your prism file since I finished making gfx for final battle already.