jTWG LXXI: Harry Potter and the Rise of the Wolves - Game Thread

[tiloco217]

that offers us absolutely nothing Melissa. Like I have said time and time again I want to know your opinions as well as what you think about possible worlds. You haven't even indicated a direction you think is correct you have just spouted info.

[Red Blaster]

I'm not trying to be rude, but do you speak a language other than English as your primary language?
What I just read seems like a bablefish translation to english.

[Red Blaster]

But I do like that you're posting something.

[Jtehanonymous]

Friendly reminder that she's newer and it's still a good effort even if it didn't provide enough personal opinion.

Chill guys.

[Red Blaster]

Jteh what if I said I'm starting to get an unexplainable gut feeling that you're going to end up being a wolf

[Jtehanonymous]

Your pattern you've indicated is slightly interesting. So you're saying by default, you would be the last quiet person to be lynched since Riot and Dfr were both quiet? Reuben and myself have had our own quiet spells throughout the game as well, so why not us?

Although, I will definitely agree you have been the most quiet.

[Jtehanonymous]

Originally Posted by Red Blaster

Jteh what if I said I'm starting to get an unexplainable gut feeling that you're going to end up being a wolf

I would tell you that you are paranoid and welcome to the wonderful world of TWG. I have a spare tin foil hat for you if you want.

but more importantly, I would urge you to go back into the thread and draw connections that could support that.

[lynn34melissa]

Isn't the answer obvious: you both make "worthy" posts that can't be seen as totally useless to the game and you both have answered why you have dry spells.

[lynn34melissa]

Originally Posted by Jtehanonymous

Also T-force dying can't be taken to mean anything.

Doesn't everything have a meaning?

[Red Blaster]

Yeah jteh elaborate on why T-Force's killing has no meaning

[Red Blaster]

Because it obviously points put that someone wanted him dead.

[Red Blaster]

Out*

[Jtehanonymous]

Originally Posted by lynn34melissa

Doesn't everything have a meaning?

Sure, fair point.

However, you stated that T-force's death would be a dumb move for Tiloco, so Tiloco wouldn't have killed T-force.

However, how would Tiloco know to kill T-force in the first place? (Seer wasn't revealed at that time) So in the midst of your argument, I don't think you can use T-force's death to draw any powerful conclusions.

[lynn34melissa]

Originally Posted by Jtehanonymous

it's still a good effort even if it didn't provide enough personal opinion.

Originally Posted by lynn34melissa

Is it not possible that a wolf lynched their partner in order to win the game?
Is it not possible that we have a very aggressive wolf that appears human?
But what if we have a quiet wolf?
Is it not possible that both wolves are still in play?
In any event does anyone else see a different pattern?

The whole thing is personal opinion, everyone would answer the question differently.

[Jtehanonymous]

Originally Posted by lynn34melissa

If tiloco was wolf it would explain the desire to kill t-fore who asked for a seeding, however killing t-force would be a stupid move to make that night. In this case I believe t-force was killed in order to cast suspicion on tiloco.

Tiloco asked for that seering as well. T-force only ever pushed someone to seer Tiloco.

The conclusion doesn't follow because the power to seer Tiloco wasn't evidently in T-force's hands at that time.

[Red Blaster]

Seer was claimed 2-3 minutes before end of phase. I've never wolfed before, but I assume they can change their kill target at will any time before night is over.

[Jtehanonymous]

I saw you make that point earlier and I don't see it as being very likely.

Someone would need to be camping here roughly 2 minutes before T-force's post, not even knowing that T-force would pull something like that.

Next, the person would need to quickly read it over, realize it's deleterious to them, then already have a window open and ready to change the kill, making the correct actions.

For that to all occur in under two minutes seems very unlikely to me. It'd be so peremptory.

[lynn34melissa]

Originally Posted by Jtehanonymous

Sure, fair point.

However, you stated that T-force's death would be a dumb move for Tiloco, so Tiloco wouldn't have killed T-force.

However, how would Tiloco know to kill T-force in the first place? (Seer wasn't revealed at that time) So in the midst of your argument, I don't think you can use T-force's death to draw any powerful conclusions.

If tiloco were wolf it would it not be a good idea to kill any opposition or anyone that could try to get him killed? He wouldn't need to know if T-force were seer in order to get rid of him, and besides didn't T-force admit that Tiloco did a nice job at drawing the attention away from himself. This I can even conclude because the seer himself "T-force" didn't seer Tiloco in the end.

[Jtehanonymous]

Yes, on those grounds, I can agree with you that Tiloco could have killed T-force simply to quiet the idea that he needed to be looked at for future phases.

However, that is a very obvious kill reason to make for Tiloco though, so I question the strength there.

[lynn34melissa]

Originally Posted by Jtehanonymous

For that to all occur in under two minutes seems very unlikely to me. It'd be so peremptory.

That is exactly my point. T-force was not killed because he outed himself as seer. Since this is the case who would want him dead? Does anyone have a theory?