TOP Players / Tier Requirements Thread - Updated 7/8/09

[arelik]

Skill tokens shouldn't be counted because of requirements like less than 50 perfects on a song.

[Razorflame]

Anyways, I am proud to announce that I have 13 tier points now :P

[hoochan]

Originally Posted by arelik

Skill tokens shouldn't be counted because of requirements like less than 50 perfects on a song.

That's how you get them, which has nothing to do with how you do on them.

[arelik]

What if someone is able to AAA the skill token song but can't meet the requirement because it forces him to get a bad score. He won't be able to play the skill token song and won't get points. Getting a bad score on a song can't be a requirement to earn points for this list.

[hoochan]

If you can do well then you can do not well if you tried.

[arelik]

This list shows how well you do on songs and not how bad you can play. Your ability to get bad scores shouldn't be evaluated. I know many people on the list can get the skill tokens, but forcing someone to get them just to keep up with others isn't fair.

[hoochan]

You only have to get the bad score once then you can unlock the song. I don't understand what's so hard about that. :/

[Doug31]

The ones about doing bad are easy enough that you'd have to be not good enough to make this list to not be able to do them, IMO.

[arelik]

I'm not saying it's hard to get the skill tokens. This list is about getting good scores and only that. Nothing else should affect your ranking. If there's at least one person on the list who can't get a skill token requirement like less than 50 perfects, it's not fair. Every person on the list must have every skill token if you want to give points for them.

[Doug31]

Not every skill token song needs to be worth points. A lot of the regular songs aren't even worth tier points.

[arelik]

You're right, but we still can't count them because of the reason stated in my previous post.

[Razorflame]

Dazzling Destiny should be counted because of it's difficulty. 'Nuff said.

[hoochan]

I want my Ride Out AAA to count

[The5thMoon]

Once they add the new songs in I'll be around 155+ in tier points so I guess I should be secure in tier 4

[HammyMcSquirrel]

Originally Posted by Razorflame

Dazzling Destiny should be counted because of it's difficulty. 'Nuff said.

Token songs do not show up on people's level rank stats. Therefore, they will not be included on this list.

Edit: Yeah, I know this has been said a few times before, but sometimes it just needs to be repeated.

[brothaice]

Is P4U not on there because of the slowdown?

[Doug31]

Songs with bugs in them like Party 4 u and Chrono definitely shouldn't be on there, IMO.

[brothaice]

Originally Posted by Doug31

Songs with bugs in them like Party 4 u and Chrono definitely shouldn't be on there, IMO.

Yeah but even with the slowdown its still really hard, and it be even harder to get a good enough PA to meet a req =/

Its iffy...

[Tayfun]

if there is way to remove the background then i dont mind.

[Doug31]

Yea, well, I just don't think it's a very accurate measure of skill when people can easily use slowdown on it.