TWG CLXIV: Classics Man - Game Thread

[Hakulyte]

If you take into account the abnormal accuracy of all his calls in the game, it makes little sense.

I feel like he should have been more lost D0 and less lost now.

[Hakulyte]

@Shado

You seriously need to consider the world where both Xel and you are town.

[ShadoWolfe]

Originally Posted by Hakulyte

I have Proph has potential wolf because he claimed "VT" D0 and I see that as very anti-town and I don't understand how someone like him would do that as town.

I don't like how he seemed to want to be killed to have more time this week, I feel like a protown player would try anything else to avoid a mislynch. His walls have been solid, though so idk.

[Hakulyte]

..and that's a pretty small world if me and MML are also town.

[Hakulyte]

Something like Proph/wineandbread/Jade for instance.

[ShadoWolfe]

Originally Posted by Hakulyte

@Shado

You seriously need to consider the world where both Xel and you are town.

I am. Don't you see me doing exactly that?
One more post in that vein coming up

[thesunfan]

I kinda like Shado deciding not to worry too terribly much about pairs/teams because that's probably what I'm going to end up doing this phase as well

[Hakulyte]

Originally Posted by ShadoWolfe

The quoted post, for instance, is pretty towny because I think wolfXel would take advantage of people (Haku in this case) saying that me and AA are always W/T. Instead, he said "bad" a hundred times at Haku's logic that me/AA are always different factions.

..but do you think he said that [because he knew both of your flips] or because it's bad (?)

[ShadoWolfe]

Originally Posted by Hakulyte

Something like Proph/wineandbread/Jade for instance.

I don't think wineandbread is a wolf here.
Like, props to him if he fooled me, but I don't really see it at all.
You're assuming MML/Xel are town here. If I knew MML and Xel were town, then that only leaves Jade/Sunfan/Proph after taking Haku and Wabby out.

I don't think that's the case though, and it's a pretty big stretch (and extremely easy) to take out 5 players out of 8 total, clear them, and then say the rest are wolves.

[Hakulyte]

Well, you don't need to solve the team, you just need to find the wolfiest wolf.

[ShadoWolfe]

Originally Posted by Hakulyte

..but do you think he said that [because he knew both of your flips] or because it's bad (?)

Well, that's what I'm saying.
If he knew both of our flips, he'd want people to think that AA/Shado are always W/T.
He'd want that because it nets him a free mislynch after either me or AA flips.

Instead, he went out of his way to post a wall of BAD.

That doesn't align with a wolf intention. See where I'm coming from?
Obviously, he could've just done it to appear as though he's against bad logic or whatever, but idk if wolfXel chooses to correct a possible freebie like that.

[ShadoWolfe]

Originally Posted by Hakulyte

Well, you don't need to solve the team, you just need to find the wolfiest wolf.

aorn, this is between Jade and Xel imo

[Hakulyte]

I think Xel (both alignment) won't bother correcting me ever unless it's something more serious.

He's just going to wait until I either "dig my own grave" or "put him at risk of something".

[ShadoWolfe]

Originally Posted by XelNya

I dunno if I agree with this. I don't think defending someone has any direct implications of being partners. Sure it makes 'em worth looking into but like if you dislike witch I think you're just not paying attention now.

Same wording he used for the vigi!
That proves to me that Xel isn't lying about knowing who the vigi was.

I was giving him townpoints for this when I was just talking about "one more post in this vein", but now that I'm actually writing this I see that it also raises the question of
why didn't you defend witch at all at EoD? Something like "lynch me before witch" or "GET OFF WITCH THIS IS BAD" or any other subtle or not-so-subtle hint is what I'd expect from a town worried about losing their vigi.

[Hakulyte]

Originally Posted by ShadoWolfe

Same wording he used for the vigi!
That proves to me that Xel isn't lying about knowing who the vigi was.

I was giving him townpoints for this when I was just talking about "one more post in this vein", but now that I'm actually writing this I see that it also raises the question of
why didn't you defend witch at all at EoD? Something like "lynch me before witch" or "GET OFF WITCH THIS IS BAD" or any other subtle or not-so-subtle hint is what I'd expect from a town worried about losing their vigi.

Originally Posted by XelNya

Admittedly I failed to do the thing I ought to have done which was advocate witch not die

and I should get lynched and mauled in postgame for it

^^

[ShadoWolfe]

Originally Posted by Hakulyte

^^

Yeah but I didn't really believe him knowing it was witch. I thought he was referring to me when he said it was "subtly confirmed" by him not dying, which is another reason I was confused when he reversed his read so suddenly.

[thesunfan]

I didn't think it was you but I did think you softed at one point
you said something like "keep this in mind for later" and it felt like you were preparing for a claim, which is why I had the reaction it that I did

[Hakulyte]

Originally Posted by Wineandbread

Actually this is something I wasn't considering. Although it would mean that I've basically been reading the entire game wrong

I don't think they would kill you though. Makes more sense for you, but not for me, as you are a harbinger or all that is chaos

I have no problem voting this guy.

:v

[ShadoWolfe]

Originally Posted by thesunfan

I didn't think it was you but I did think you softed at one point
you said something like "keep this in mind for later" and it felt like you were preparing for a claim, which is why I had the reaction it that I did

Ohhh, when you said "I won't forget this, friend?"
I was talking about in the case of my lynch or vigkill IIRC, so your post at the time was a tad ominous from my perspective

[ShadoWolfe]

Originally Posted by ShadoWolfe

Ohhh, when you said "I won't forget this, friend?"
I was talking about in the case of my lynch or vigkill IIRC, so your post at the time was a tad ominous from my perspective

The "friend" was italicized and everything lol super ominous to the point of me remembering it off the bat