Easy Song Special Batch - Submission Closed

[TC_Halogen]

[++]: 1
[+]: 21 (4)
[+.]: 13
[+?]: 7
[?]: 3 (1)
[-]: 5 (1)
[<]: 3

Italics indicate files that were too hard for the batch.

Raw acceptance rate: 35/53
Adjusted acceptance rate: 31/53

[Reshiram]

Near 60%.

That's still a failing grade. D:

[bmah]

I will be posting the notes up shortly.

[00Razor00]

Moment of truth :333

[jimerax]

20/20 - 4
19/20 - 10
18/20 - 8
(and 1 14/15).

These ones will be accepted, if they don't have critical issues.

We have like 10 16-17s/20 and files that contain <, those files will go to the 2nd stage.
I'll review the accepted files and do final check.

[00Razor00]

Originally Posted by jimerax

20/20 - 4
19/20 - 10
18/20 - 8
(and 1 14/15).

These ones will be accepted, if they don't have critical issues.

We have like 10 16-17s/20 and files that contain <, those files will go to the 2nd stage.
I'll review the accepted files and do final check.

So this means 8 files that scored 18/20 will be picked? o:

[T-Force]

Originally Posted by 00Razor00

So this means 8 files that scored 18/20 will be picked? o:

It means 8 of the songs in the batch scored 18/20.

[Plan_Bsk81127]

Made a list real quick of the files accepted and whatnot based on the cutoffs jimerax said (18+ auto accept, 16-17 2nd stage, etc). Anyone who wishes to make an edit to the list or fix something feel free.

Edit: Added the scores for the 2nd judge files

Leaves in the Wind (iironiic) - 20+
Until Tomorrow [Light] (bmah) - 20+
Louder than Thunder (qqwref) - 20
Morning Grory (bmah) - 20
Another Day (bmah) - 19
botu1 (MarioNintendo) - 19
Counting Snow (0) - 19
Hana Yuduki (jimerax) - 19
Love, The Elephant (MarioNintendo) - 19
Sea Breeze (Silvuh) - 19
Shu Kurimu no Uta (jimerax) - 19
Space Entropy (cry4eternity) - 19
Steel for Pappa (OneHandNow) - 19
Town Theme 1 (Reshiram) - 19
Above the Clouds (cry4eternity) - 18
bitmapstar (Ziergdsx18) - 18
Ding Dong Song (Dossar) - 18
Finding A Way (00Razor00) - 18
Maintenance Bot (woker-X) - 18
Minuet In G (Reshiram) - 18
Passage D (qqwref) - 18
Subconsciousness (leonid) - 18
-----------------------------------------------------
Endless Handbag In Asia (MaxGhost) - 17 (5/3/5/4)
Fall into Night (0) - 17 (5/2/5/5)
Rill Rill (Dr.Ozi Remix) (Coolboyrulez0) - 17 (4/5/3/5)
Shadows of my Lost Memories (Plan_Bsk81127) - 17 (5/4/4/4)
Sonnenuntergang (Xayphon) - 17 (5/3/5/4)
Happy Happy Shining Star!! V2 (MrPopadopalis25) - 16 (5/5/3/3)
Purity (T-Force) - 16 (4/3/4/5)
The Degredation of the Soul (Silvuh) - 16 (5/2/5/4)
Tutti Frutti Summer Love (Dossar) - 16 (5/4/4/3)
-----------------------------------------------------------
45 (nois-or-e) - 15
Deadly Daydream (leonid) - 15
Darling(JSH) - 14
Playing With Yourself (MaxGhost) - 14
Your Thoughts Disgust Me (nois-or-e) - 14
Eulogy For Nick Galvez (Emulord) - 13
Yukitsukiyashou (leonid) - 13
Link's Awakening (Childhood Memories Remix) (MaxGhost) - 12
Hoax (Midnghtraver) - 11
Dance Trigger (XCV) - 10
Pastel Candy (JSH) - 9
Oliver (OneHandNow) - 8
Break Fast (OneHandNow) - 6
Carrots (Yo Man I'm Awesome) - 6
Chimes (Thatskier) - 4
Minimal Effort (Thatskier) - 4
Op 71 IV Rondo Allegro (Thatskier)- 4


Other:

Sunless Daybreak (psychoangel691) - 14 (need one more judge)

Skate or Die 2 (Reshiram) - 12, <
Skate or Die 2 [Beginner] (Emulord) - 10, <, <
Skate or Die 2 [Light] (Emulord) - 9, <, <

Above the Clouds (nois-or-e) - 8, <, <

[psychoangel691]

Originally Posted by Plan_Bsk81127

Other:

Sunless Daybreak (psychoangel691) - 14 (need one more judge)

Skate or Die 2 (Reshiram) - 12, <
Skate or Die 2 [Beginner] (Emulord) - 10, <, <
Skate or Die 2 [Light] (Emulord) - 9, <, <

Above the Clouds (nois-or-e) - 8, <, <

Originally Posted by jimerax

20/20 - 4
19/20 - 10
18/20 - 8
(and 1 14/15).

These ones will be accepted, if they don't have critical issues.

We have like 10 16-17s/20 and files that contain <, those files will go to the 2nd stage.
I'll review the accepted files and do final check.

^^

[bmah]

Notes are now posted!

[bmah]

p.s. personal opinion Niala, but I think you're missing the point on some songs when you say "undersaturated" or "underlayered"

[Niala]

I look at it like this: Simfiling should be about making arrows to music, if something has a lot of sounds to it and just a single arrow every quarter note you're not representing the music very well. idc if this is an easy batch if something's missing, then something's missing.

P.s. bed time night

[TC_Halogen]

Originally Posted by Niala

I look at it like this: Simfiling should be about making arrows to music, if something has a lot of sounds to it and just a single arrow every quarter note you're not representing the music very well. idc if this is an easy batch if something's missing, then something's missing.

P.s. bed time night

I tend to look at it similarly to this, but not entirely at density. Basically, I want variation when the song calls for it. If the song doesn't make for much variation, then I look for subtle changes in patterns, or notable differences in pattern structure, etc.

[Reshiram]

Make sure we add a full list of the approved files if you could, please, once Jimerax makes the narrowing.

And AJ, permission granted to fix the syncs on my songs wherever necessary. :3

[cry4eternity]

Awww yeah 19 and 18 . The only non-pluses came from Gundam-Dude >_<.

[00Razor00]

Ooh nice. 18/20. Tbh, I thought Gundam-Dude was gonna wreck me rofl

Thanks for the notes judges.

[MaxGhost]

17/20, 14/20, 12/20

:/

[bmah]

Originally Posted by MaxGhost

17/20, 14/20, 12/20

:/

http://www.flashflashrevolution.com/...d.php?t=119202

good time to check this out!

[championanwar]

Another file queued for me! Wooo yeaaaah!

[Plan_Bsk81127]

lol got 17/20, not bad I guess for a song I just found sitting on my SM stepped from who knows how long ago. XD


At least the other two songs I had people step got in, mainly all I cared about.