Difficulty 1-9 Special Batch

[PrawnSkunk]

Re: Difficulty 1-9 Special Batch

judges can't handle my lv1 file. too intense for them.

[MarioNintendo]

Re: Difficulty 1-9 Special Batch

Holy shit @ Lunar Landing, this must've been really good.

[DarkZtar]

Re: Difficulty 1-9 Special Batch

Set 1: (Judge order: Bmah, Samurai, MN, Gnr)
Calling Mars / DarkZtar: 8,7,9,5 (29)
Countdown / DarkZtar: 8,8,8,8 (32)
glaciate / DarkZtar: 8,7,7,8 (30)


Glad to see Countdown and glaciate do well, honestly surprised at how well Calling Mars did(was expecting more reviews like Gnr's tbh). Probably gonna send minor fixes for Mars based on judge reviews.

[MarioNintendo]

Re: Difficulty 1-9 Special Batch

Idk if this could work, but I had an idea for a system to calculate if a file passes or not. It's pretty primitive compared to Wilson's, but I wanted to find a way to keep the "disregard most severe and lenient judge" system since it didn't seem you guys already decided for an actual 4 judge per group system.

Instead of just not taking into account the most severe and lenient ratings, you could simply half their value to make them weight less in the final equation. Roughly, it would look like this:



A: averaged grade
L: lenient grade
M1, M2: middle grades
S: severe grade

All that's left to decide is which value of A is the limit for passing. If I try it out with my own submissions, here are the results I would get:

FF7 - Theme of Aeris: 6.5
Redirected Moonlight: 7
ULTRAnumb: 8.3

Just a suggestion~

[yo man im awesome]

Re: Difficulty 1-9 Special Batch

that puts me at 7.1

I don't think that's passing lol, what would you need for the conditional cue?

edit: if we just take out top and low I get 7.5

[MarioNintendo]

Re: Difficulty 1-9 Special Batch

that puts me at 7.2 (fixd)

I don't think that's passing lol, what would you need for the conditional cue?

edit: if we just take out top and low I get 7.5

In no way would I be qualified to decide which number passes and which does not, but I felt it made the overall number seem fair, don't you?

[yo man im awesome]

Re: Difficulty 1-9 Special Batch

In no way would I be qualified to decide which number passes and which does not, but I felt it made the overall number seem fair, don't you?

Well yea, of course. But what do you think would be passing/conditional?

[iironiic]

Re: Difficulty 1-9 Special Batch

I second this idea Mario (:

Also, I am assuming that usually, files with an 8+ average are passing. Would it be logical to let those files which scored 8+ be in queue? (8+ may be a little too lenient but definitely 9+ deserves to be in queue.)

If we hypothetically, have a batch of files that are all of good quality, I think it's unfair to discard some of those files because the average rating is high. I think there should be rating that defines a line of automatic acceptance to the queue.

[00Razor00]

Re: Difficulty 1-9 Special Batch

Holy shit @ Lunar Landing, this must've been really good.

Lunar Landing was indeed a good chart.

Really surprised someone gave Pork and Beans a 5, haha. Scintill's charts were also good.

Overall, this half of the batch was really diverse, with both the best and worst overall files being in this half of the batch.

Agreed.

Also, I think I know the exact reason Jesse passed on my file :P

So you think :P

[bob bob]

Re: Difficulty 1-9 Special Batch

using the algorithm
Galaxy9:7.1333333333333333333333
Can't work out the tunnel accurately but it would be somewhere in the 6.5-6.8 mark (depending on what the pass value would be)

While on the subject, since The tunnel did get 1 !, does that mean it will be excluded from getting the pass rating?

[bmah]

Re: Difficulty 1-9 Special Batch

A [!] rating is given if the file is definitely too hard for the batch. I've noticed that the other judges who did review the file did not seem to give a [!] so I played it myself just now to see how hard it is. Seems to me like a high 9, and that's only because of two measures which contain short 32nd bursts. Without those measures, I wouldn't even say the file would contest a borderline difficulty. I would personally accept the file for review. I'll see what the supportive judge who'll review the [PASS] files have to say.

[Reshiram]

Re: Difficulty 1-9 Special Batch

So you think :P

Well logic might dictate you slapping a pass due to the preview music, or the fact that you've hated p.much every single one of my files since I started stepping and didn't wanna bother because you knew you'd be super-biased and likely throw a 1 or 2 on it.

[00Razor00]

Re: Difficulty 1-9 Special Batch

Well logic might dictate you slapping a pass due to the preview music, or the fact that you've hated p.much every single one of my files since I started stepping and didn't wanna bother because you knew you'd be super-biased and likely throw a 1 or 2 on it.

cause I totally throw 1 and 2's out like they're nothing :eyeroll:

[MarioNintendo]

Re: Difficulty 1-9 Special Batch

Hope my reviews weren't too biased!

[jimerax]

Re: Difficulty 1-9 Special Batch

That works.

ps you guys forgot about various adjustments.