Criticism

[DossarLX ODI]

Criticism can provide insight on how something can be improved. However, there seems to be a very big problem in terms of how this kind of feedback can be expressed.

One of the big questions I pose is: What criticism should matter? Of course one would need to consider the context of the situation, so I'll illustrate a few examples.

Scenario I: Car Music
Bad criticism: Good music doesn't sound like garbage.
Good criticism: The songs are too complex, unpredictable, and distracting for a car ride. They might be interesting and make good rhythm game songs, but for most people the changes are jarring.

Scenario II: Wallet Problem
Bad criticism: You lost the wallet you moron. Be careful, pay attention, and don't be a dumbass.
Good criticism: Next time what you should do is inform people that you have the wallet so someone else could offer to put it in their bag or whatnot and it has less of a chance of being lost.

I would like some more thoughts on this subject matter because I have seen plenty of insults trashing other people that are completely tasteless, disgusting, and thoughtless which don't add helpful information. Along with that, "Be Careful" is used way too often and fits into the "don't add helpful information" category.