TWG V: Red Alert! (Human Day 4 Victory?)

[QreepyBORIS]

I personally do think he is a wolf.

If he turns out not to be, he is certainly a hindrance. And we know what just one hindrance can do in a game of TWG. Tny in last game illustrates this beautifully.

Given, that was his first game, but this is Snapps's second, which is no better at all, in my eyes.


So, if he is a wolf, and we kill him, wonderful. If he is not, and we kill him, it's really not as bad as you would think--indeed, it could be beneficial, though one might argue that there is no sense in targetting a human at all. But since the evidence points to him being a wolf, well, it would be the bigger win in the win-win situation of voting him off.


Review all of the evidence against him. You'll see.


EDIT: Moogy said what I meant in like a quarter of the words, with 4 times more coherency. Read his post as a synopsis of mine (except the part where he is suspicious of me :P).

Man, it's only 9:15, and I'm dead on my feet.

[blahblah18]

4 AM early saturday morning

My interpretation of what Snapps said was that he isn't a total idiot.. no one coudl be that stupid, and he meant he has a role to play.. such as in the first game he was killed night 1? I can only assume he meant that, and not that his IQ is under 70..

[QreepyBORIS]

If you say straight out that you have a role, you are fucking stupid, and that's the end of the story. Well, at least 90% of the time.

And why are you going so far out of your way to defend him? THAT doesn't make sense to me....

[User6773]

Changing vote to Chardish. His last post pretty much announced it, and he is infinitely more dangerous than anyone else on the wolf team could be.

Explain to me how I'm more dangerous than anyone on the wolf team?

You understand that for every human you lynch, you actually lose 2 because a) you lynched a human and b) that's one extra night that stands between you and victory.

And if too many humans die, you lose.

If I'm really that dangerous, then simply don't listen to me.

If you say straight out that you have a role, you are fucking stupid, and that's the end of the story.

QFT.

[Moogy]

Changing vote back to Snapps in favor of eliminating him.

[sleeplessdragn]

im going with Snapps because his words caused me to raise an eyebrow very quickly. of all the games ive played in ive never heard anyone simply announce that they have a role. if that doesnt sound an alarm, iunno wat will.

[blahblah18]

sleepless look at my post, I"m neither defending nor condemning him, but I refuse to believe he's that moronic... so odds are he meant a roel i nplaying the game, as opposed to being killed on night 1 like the only othert game he was in

[evilbutterfly]

When I read Snapps say something about a "role" my first thought was "you moron, people will all think you're special now." But then I realized that he wouldn't want to come out and say that, and it was either a mistake, a bad way of wording things, or he's just a moron. Regardless of which, it seems dangerous to keep him around. I still wanna hear his side of things before I change any votings.

Although, I might not change my vote. There are some people I'm looking at suspiciously, so I think I'll keep my random vote before I go pointing fingers. I'll let suspects post more before I try and say they've done anything, because I wanna make sure I'm doing the right thing (like, last game I thought Qreepy was a wolf the whole time and would have said something if I was playing, but I was wrong). Wouldn't wanna vote off any humans by accident.

[GuidoHunter]

Okay, six pages of stuff to digest...

My first thought was about why Tass or chardish didn't die. I know I expected Tass to be guarded, by a newb who thought, "ZOMG Tassel's awesome, let's keep him around" if not a regular who knows how valuable he really is. So, why not chardish for a first pick? Well, there's the obvious reason that one or both of them are wolves, but I think it's still too early to go off of that.

Regarding Snapps, I agree that he's just dumb, and not being wolfish. I also agree that getting rid of him may help us in the long run (as getting rid of tny would have been last game), but I'd REALLY rather not lose any humans. I move to back off of Snapps.

Regarding evil, while his actions are slightly suspicious, that can be explained by his newbness. However, I still think there's something slightly strange about his defense. It's not that he's trying too hard like alain said, but something I can't really tell. I'm sure he'll give himself away soon if he's a wolf, though.

One person who really caught my eye was Moogy. That's a pretty bold move to come out against chardish that early on. Once chardish made a really meaningful post, Moogy jumped on him hoping that chardish's logic would be enough to swing support against him. Once he sees that he can't garner support, he moves on to the bandwagon. This is why my vote goes to Moogy.

I had a little more, but I got distracted. Perhaps after this movie I'll come back...

--Guido

http://andy.mikee385.com

[Snapps]

When I read Snapps say something about a "role" my first thought was "you moron, people will all think you're special now." But then I realized that he wouldn't want to come out and say that, and it was either a mistake, a bad way of wording things, or he's just a moron. Regardless of which, it seems dangerous to keep him around. I still wanna hear his side of things before I change any votings.

Although, I might not change my vote. There are some people I'm looking at suspiciously, so I think I'll keep my random vote before I go pointing fingers. I'll let suspects post more before I try and say they've done anything, because I wanna make sure I'm doing the right thing (like, last game I thought Qreepy was a wolf the whole time and would have said something if I was playing, but I was wrong). Wouldn't wanna vote off any humans by accident.

What I meant about role as in actually getting to play the game with a role, like a wolf or a human. I had bad choice in words. Remember the time when I was killed before the game actually started? Thats when I didn't get a role.

And also about me not changing my votes, I guess that is a stupid choice. But the reasoning behind it was that I would have gotten very much detail on who is a wolf that then I can pick without any regrets.

I didn't mean to have any of you guys think differently :/

[blahblah18]

finally logic begins to appear in some posts... God bless

[evilbutterfly]

Just a suggestion for Kilga: please post what time day and night end (as LD did) and maybe have little vote count updates (as in previous TWGs). I, for one, have no idea when this "day" ends, so I don't know when voting closes. I would use your original post's time as a reference, but we all know that it's all wrong. The voting is just laziness on my part, because I don't feel like searching through the pages for all the votes :P. But yeah, just some suggestions.

And I have nothing to add to the voting scene. I don't know if Snapps is dumb or what, and the rest of you all either seem too quiet or too loud. I don't know anything right now, so I'm just gonna go to bed and try not to worry about this game, because all my worrying can make me say stupid stuff, and as we can see with Snapps, saying stupid stuff = you're screwed. G'night all

[Kilgamayan]

Uh.

15 people, so 8 votes is an instalynch. Note that an insta-lynch can happen at any time - there is no 24-hour waiting period in this game. You get 60 hours to vote. Vote wisely.

And I would update but I have a DiffEQ test in 8 1/2 hours so I want to go to bed.

[blahblah18]

oh DiffEQ's... i'm glad I don't have to deal with those anymore... as I"ve already said.. the day ends 4 AM saturday morning or when one person gets 8 votes

[GuidoHunter]

Man, DiffEQ was such a great class...

But anyway, is someone keeping a record of votes? I'm always up for seeing a current tally.

--Guido

http://andy.mikee385.com