TWG CLXIV: Classics Man - Game Thread

[ShadoWolfe]

Re: TWG CLXIV: Classics Man - Game Thread

I'll be back later today. Will phonepost as opportunities arise. I'd like to see a lot more from.. Well, basically everyone, but especially Xel, Proph, and Jade

[ShadoWolfe]

Re: TWG CLXIV: Classics Man - Game Thread

tbh I don't believe this, I think you voted mellon expecting a wagon, but when you backed off when you saw what people were saying, you said something like you didn't actually have a scumread on her, but you wanted her to post more

that's not the feeling I got from that vote by you

How? In what world does this make sense?? People (I think Charu or DBP, not really sure) were already disagreeing with my reasoning before I even voted. Why would I vote if what you're sayomg wrr true or made any sense? I put it pretty simply. I wanted her to vote more. I've said this from the very, very beginning. I don't understand how you could possibly think otherwise.

[thesunfan]

Re: TWG CLXIV: Classics Man - Game Thread

"Aggressive" in generating content? Check
Sometimes tinfoils? Check
Sometimes tunnels to China? Check
Sometimes undecisive in reads? Check
Meta analysis and vote analysis? Check
Argues irrelevancies at times? Check
Posts excessively much and causes the game to negatively impact his commitments IRL? Lol CHECK

I don't usually reread previous games I think its usually a waste of time

I agree that you've generated a lot of content, I am not disputing you on this point. I agree that it /is/ a more townie trait in general, but you def are someone who I know can post a lot as a wolf because as much as I've been shitting on you for the past 20 posts, you're a good wolf, so I don't think this is a point in your favor or against you, but yes. You have generated a lot of content this game.

You had a stupid unexplained tinfoil on me last game that you tried to write off as a joke that I don't think you meant as a joke. I don't really have an opinion whether you or townies in general tinfoil more than wolves, but I've seen you do it as both alignments so idc.

I don't think you ever tunnel to China as either alignment. You did focus on raeko a lot but eh, I wouldn't say it was like, excessive. I somewhat disagree with AA in that I remember you doing/talking about a lot of other people, so I don't think that your persistence on raeko is anywhere near as damning as you not interacting very much with her/responding to her longer posts.

Don't really care about being indecisive, wolves have to do it because townies do it.

Look man all of these are attributes of both your town game and wolf game. They are attributes of your wolf game because they are attributes of your town game. Looking at what you've done specifically rather in general is how people need to read you, and how most people who don't have incredibly flawed unleveled gameplay should be read.

I have more respect for your game than to read you based on a checklist.

[Hakulyte]

Re: TWG CLXIV: Classics Man - Game Thread

AA/Sunfan seems coherent with game progression.

What they're saying about Shado fits with what I was getting upset about D0, but not expressing properly.

I plan to be more quiet today because I feel like I take too much space for not enough content.

[Witch of Certainty]

Re: TWG CLXIV: Classics Man - Game Thread

fwiw Lar is right in that I /should/ be getting more flak than I am for killing DBP than say, AA is, and I'm not really sure what that means.

I think people are trying to latch onto the fact that AA's vote looks /kind of/ bad because of the timing, but not taking into account the fact that roundbox/me pushed the lynch, mostly me.

The point of the suspicion, at least for me, is not that the DBP vote looks bad itself, since it's fairly reasonable that he could doubt his stance in the face of wanting a lynch and seeing townreads pushing that one, it's that at that time, he had me as null at best, yet didn't want to vote me? Silencing your doubts and voting with people you trust makes some sense if there's not a wagon that fits your stance more.

[thesunfan]

Re: TWG CLXIV: Classics Man - Game Thread

How? In what world does this make sense?? People (I think Charu or DBP, not really sure) were already disagreeing with my reasoning before I even voted. Why would I vote if what you're sayomg wrr true or made any sense? I put it pretty simply. I wanted her to vote more. I've said this from the very, very beginning. I don't understand how you could possibly think otherwise.

I get the feeling that you wanted to push her, not because you wanted her to post more, and I mean that regardless of your alignment, but I do think its almost a universally wolfy move

[Hakulyte]

Re: TWG CLXIV: Classics Man - Game Thread

The point of the suspicion, at least for me, is not that the DBP vote looks bad itself, since it's fairly reasonable that he could doubt his stance in the face of wanting a lynch and seeing townreads pushing that one, it's that at that time, he had me as null at best, yet didn't want to vote me? Silencing your doubts and voting with people you trust makes some sense if there's not a wagon that fits your stance more.

He said it was to avoid KitB.

[thesunfan]

Re: TWG CLXIV: Classics Man - Game Thread

The point of the suspicion, at least for me, is not that the DBP vote looks bad itself, since it's fairly reasonable that he could doubt his stance in the face of wanting a lynch and seeing townreads pushing that one, it's that at that time, he had me as null at best, yet didn't want to vote me? Silencing your doubts and voting with people you trust makes some sense if there's not a wagon that fits your stance more.

yeahhhhhhhhhhhhhh you're not wrong man
I get that this looks not great for AA, but I'm looking at a lot of other shit he's done

the thunderdome post sequence with Shado makes me (like roundbox said) probably willing to never vote AA this game

[ShadoWolfe]

Re: TWG CLXIV: Classics Man - Game Thread

I get the feeling that you wanted to push her, not because you wanted her to post more, and I mean that regardless of your alignment, but I do think its almost a universally wolfy move

Regardless of my alignment?
So if you knew I was town, you'd think I was lying about my intentions?
Take that shit elsewhere man I'm not lying and I made my intentions clear from the get go.

[thesunfan]

Re: TWG CLXIV: Classics Man - Game Thread

well I guess roundbox only said that AA is probably not a wolf
I have a slightly stronger opinion

[thesunfan]

Re: TWG CLXIV: Classics Man - Game Thread

Regardless of my alignment?
So if you knew I was town, you'd think I was lying about my intentions?
Take that shit elsewhere man I'm not lying and I made my intentions clear from the get go.

telling me to go elsewhere will not get me off of you
it is making me want to move my vote less

[Witch of Certainty]

Re: TWG CLXIV: Classics Man - Game Thread

yeahhhhhhhhhhhhhh you're not wrong man
I get that this looks not great for AA, but I'm looking at a lot of other shit he's done

the thunderdome post sequence with Shado makes me (like roundbox said) probably willing to never vote AA this game

So if I take AA, and presumably roundbox, out of the list of 5 I gave before, who would you say we lynch?

[ShadoWolfe]

Re: TWG CLXIV: Classics Man - Game Thread

I don't usually reread previous games I think its usually a waste of time

I agree that you've generated a lot of content, I am not disputing you on this point. I agree that it /is/ a more townie trait in general, but you def are someone who I know can post a lot as a wolf because as much as I've been shitting on you for the past 20 posts, you're a good wolf, so I don't think this is a point in your favor or against you, but yes. You have generated a lot of content this game.

You had a stupid unexplained tinfoil on me last game that you tried to write off as a joke that I don't think you meant as a joke. I don't really have an opinion whether you or townies in general tinfoil more than wolves, but I've seen you do it as both alignments so idc.

I don't think you ever tunnel to China as either alignment. You did focus on raeko a lot but eh, I wouldn't say it was like, excessive. I somewhat disagree with AA in that I remember you doing/talking about a lot of other people, so I don't think that your persistence on raeko is anywhere near as damning as you not interacting very much with her/responding to her longer posts.

Don't really care about being indecisive, wolves have to do it because townies do it.

Look man all of these are attributes of both your town game and wolf game. They are attributes of your wolf game because they are attributes of your town game. Looking at what you've done specifically rather in general is how people need to read you, and how most people who don't have incredibly flawed unleveled gameplay should be read.

I have more respect for your game than to read you based on a checklist.

MFW sunfan tells me I don't tunnel to China as either alignment :

) : )
Happy that I'm not remembered for tunneling to China

( : (
Sad that sunfan thinks he knows my game better than I know myself

[thesunfan]

Re: TWG CLXIV: Classics Man - Game Thread

Add Proph to this, actually. Now there's 5 to work from.

Xel
MML
Roundbox
Jade
AA

I propose lynches and vig shots not be outside that group. Preferably lower ones first. There, any questions?

I really wish shado was in this list of names
the other 3 are all candidates that I have yet to eliminate coming into today, I guess Lar looks the best between xel lar and Jade, so it would be between the other two, but I don't know which I'd pick yet

[thesunfan]

Re: TWG CLXIV: Classics Man - Game Thread

tunnel to China is too strong language imo