TWG 194 - Game Thread

[Makilaz]

Re: TWG 194 - Game Thread

Vote Count:
4/28 @ 19:00

00:59 = GOOD
00:00 = BAD

==============

Xiz [1]
MixMasterLar

jessiebessie [1]
Hakulyte

ShadoWolfe [1]
flashflash account

Bolth mannn [1]
Xiz

flashflash account [1]
leetic

DaBackpack [1]
Bolth mannn

[flashflash account]

Re: TWG 194 - Game Thread

also y'all really did lynch psycho when she had less posts than the minimum.

I'm still confused as to how nobody raised an objection that she was below the post requirement. I mean, I'd be willing to wager someone in the scumteam figured it out but going through EoD nobody gave any indication of that so its impossible to read into

The only person who even brought up the requirement is Bolth, but that was as a question and it was like <5m to EoD

it crossed my mind, but I was too lazy to check min postcount and I don't have any problem with lynching a doomed slot from a game integrity pov

that being said, it's a lot better than the alternative wagon rn

[Duskfall]

Re: TWG 194 - Game Thread

can we leave the votes like this please

[Hakulyte]

Re: TWG 194 - Game Thread

ShadoWolfe's reads seems to align toward a Duskfall/Jessie/DBP team.

I was definitely aware of the postcount thing too. Similar conclusion as FFA.

[Bolth mannn]

Re: TWG 194 - Game Thread

but is it pronounced bolT, bolTH, boTH, or BOAT??????MML

bolTH :P

MML causing this clusterfuck and being proud of it looks bad. pushing the inactive lynch is expected from MML. Hell, I agree with it. but pushing it to the point of letting it consume thread and then being proud of that is not good.
#579 yessss GO MML way to focus on the right shit. call Xiz on that BS "big brain" move
#602 first player to move on past Xiz and take the mechanically correct step of accepting the claim and moving on, despite how easy it might have been to push Xiz further and call the claim fake. Follows up with #611 which puts MML at a high town read for making what he knew was the correct move mechanically but then being unable to move on past Xiz' weirdness and so asked to explain the reversal on dusk.
MML defending Ulle when there's some pressure on her from FG and then FFA/Xiz looks good on him in retrospect. Beyond that, #709 goes farther in analyzing *why* FG is pushing Ulle and attributes it to defending leetic. really liking MML at this point

Isn't MML still trying to lynch Xiz though?

Still analysing everything else you've said but that stood out to me in particular

[Bolth mannn]

Re: TWG 194 - Game Thread

oops didnt mean to leave the bolded mml in

[Duskfall]

Re: TWG 194 - Game Thread

haha 'ight ima sign up let's do this for real duskfall

I was gonna but I dont really like vote for town game

[Funnygurl555]

Re: TWG 194 - Game Thread

I was gonna but I dont really like vote for town game

hm? what do ya mean :O

[Bolth mannn]

Re: TWG 194 - Game Thread

I feel like I could see a Shadow, Dusk and MML team, shadow did go hard on Dusk in that big post though so perhaps swap one of them, probably dusk, with DBP or Jessie

[Funnygurl555]

Re: TWG 194 - Game Thread

maaaaaaaaaaan ulli why'd you have to leave. you were hard to read but shado's even tougher x.x

[Bolth mannn]

Re: TWG 194 - Game Thread

ShadoWolfe's reads seems to align toward a Duskfall/Jessie/DBP team.

I was definitely aware of the postcount thing too. Similar conclusion as FFA.

What specifically got you those three names from Shadow's post?

[Hakulyte]

Re: TWG 194 - Game Thread

I guess I projected what I thought would make sense for me in these reads rather than what Shadow really thinks.

[ShadoWolfe]

Re: TWG 194 - Game Thread

Isn't MML still trying to lynch Xiz though?

Still analysing everything else you've said but that stood out to me in particular

What does MML trying to lynch Xiz this phase have to do with his actions last phase?

Last phase, he pushed to move off Xiz from a mechanical standpoint of letting unCC'd claims stay until the claims resolve themselves or the PRs die. Xiz has since shot his shot. His utility is the same as a villager now, so lynching him comes down to whether or not you believe his claim — as well as some strategic considerations that you're free to take into account. My own thoughts notwithstanding, I can see absolutely see MML's perspective on reasons why Xiz is viable this phase. That doesn't impact my read on MML's actions last phase.

Does that make sense?

[Bolth mannn]

Re: TWG 194 - Game Thread

Does that make sense?

Yea my bad

Some of your reads like Leetic included things in this phase so I assumed you were talking about this phases shenanigans too

[ShadoWolfe]

Re: TWG 194 - Game Thread

ShadoWolfe's reads seems to align toward a Duskfall/Jessie/DBP team.

That's pretty close, actually. I've only partially skimmed this phase, so I can't fully answer that buuuut

I think at this point I think Dusk is the scummiest barring slots that will resolve themselves.

As for the other two,
I'm really not sure about Jessie 'cause she's posted so little, but it wouldn't be the worst thing in the world. She had little real content last phase, and what there was wasn't exactly insightful. FG thinks she's scummy which may be a good sheep given the check, but I'd pursue Dusk first.

DBP this phase seems better than DBP last phase, and I didn't have much against him last phase so I don't think I'd include him here yet.

I'd put Xiz well above DBP in terms of my suspicion. I really didn't like him last phase or believe his claim too much, but it does exist un-counterclaimed by either a different claim or the setup Letters, so I think it may be wise to give him more time until a contradiction in possible worlds appears.

I was definitely aware of the postcount thing too. Similar conclusion as FFA.

You were aware of the postcount requirement or aware that psycho was below it?
but fair point, it ended up being a good thing that the lynch didn't fall on leetic.