The VideoGame MegaPack 4 (SUBMISSIONS CLOSED)!

[MarioNintendo]

Re: The VideoGame MegaPack 4 (OPEN FOR SUBMISSIONS)!

Bump. I sent a balloon fight medley. I hope the judges will like it. Please understand. Sorry for the spam. Where are you Ossa.

<3

[Dj_Ossa]

Re: The VideoGame MegaPack 4 (OPEN FOR SUBMISSIONS)!

Alright guys! I'm back for another batch of reviews! Also, sent you a PM MarioNintendo

Let's get started, shall we?

A Beautiful Day For Golf (MarioNintendo) - YES. WOW this file's a blast. Good job.

Airship Stage (cedolad) - YES. AH - MAH - ZEN file holy shit. One of my favourites so far!

Balloon Fight Medley (MarioNintendo) - YES. Again, just such a blast playing your files, man!. Awesome first submissions so far

Battle 2 (moches) - Yes. Not only is moches one of my favourite simfile artists, but this song is absolute boss. Awesome fun file, sir. Good to see Harvard is giving you some time off to make more amazing files!

Dark Demon's Song (MarioNintendo) - Yes. This is exactly how I would have stepped this song, and that's a good thing!

Deku Palace (Lofty) - No. Not a big fan of the patterns and the use of color theory on this file. Repetitive, song doesn't really help. Also, I'm fairly sure that what you tried to pull off with the emphasized not in the two sections is offsync.

Entrusted Hope (CyclopsDragon) - No. This song is amazing. That being said, I think you underutilized the song. It's a very generic streamy file, and there's nothing wrong with that. I just think this song deserves a different approach, if you're willing to resubmit; would love to see this song in the pack.

Factory Stage (cedolad) - YES. Amazing.

Gear Getaway (MarioNintendo) - Yes. Swing's always a good choice. Good job.

Gopher Grove (Jose_Varela) - MAYBE. Ok, here's the thing. LOVE the effects, I think it's fresh; I think people don't use those amazing SM features nearly as much as they should. THAT BEING SAID, the file's pretty simple. Again, nothing wrong with that, this just feels like a somewhat challenging pad file. If you could make an extra difficulty targeted more towards KB players and resubmit, I'll consider it for sure, it has a LOT of potential.

Hope & Joy Peace & Love (MarioNintendo) - YES. This, Sir, is your opus magnum. My favourite you've submitted so far. Amazing.

Neko Atsume no Theme (Gundam-Dude) - No. Some interesting things you did but the song is boring and the file is extremely repetitive, not much going on. I just didn't enjoy it :/

Rhythm and Balance (bmah) - Yes. Great song, solid file.

The Mystic Caves (Lofty) - Maybe. Song's amazing. This file is definitely better than you other submission. However, same issues apply (with me). Patterns feel off, some of the stuff you stepped doesn't even follow anything (there's a couple of notes at the end that seem to be ghost notes?). Again, with the color theory, it's really cool if it's used properly, and you did use it well towards the end, but all the other parts were colored notes showed up made not sense to me, maybe I'm missing a sound? Please take a look at it and send a resubmission, I would love to have this song in the pack.

Alright, folks, that's all! Until next time

[jose656]

Re: The VideoGame MegaPack 4 (OPEN FOR SUBMISSIONS)!

Gopher Grove (Jose_Varela) - MAYBE. Ok, here's the thing. LOVE the effects, I think it's fresh; I think .people don't use those amazing SM features nearly as much as they should. THAT BEING SAID, the file's pretty simple. Again, nothing wrong with that, this just feels like a somewhat challenging pad file. If you could make an extra difficulty targeted more towards KB players and resubmit, I'll consider it for sure, it has a LOT of potential.

Alright, I'll keep that in mind. I maybe create two levels, although, since I'm not good at KB chart mapping, this might go bad.

[MarioNintendo]

Re: The VideoGame MegaPack 4 (OPEN FOR SUBMISSIONS)!

Wow thanks for the reviews mate!

Just a suggestion (I suck at graphics), but I think using these for inspiration would be nice for Hope & Joy Peace & Love. Especially the background. They're actual acrade marquees and posters for Gradius.

[lofty rhino]

Re: The VideoGame MegaPack 4 (OPEN FOR SUBMISSIONS)!

I sent my fixes for The Mystic Caves. Please judge this new version for those who did not judge it yet.

Thanks for the reviews Ossa.

[macgravel]

Re: The VideoGame MegaPack 4 (OPEN FOR SUBMISSIONS)!

Balloon Fight Medley (MarioNintendo) - Extremely fun file! Your files are just so much fun dude. You get me hype in my pants. YUP.

Battle 2 (moches) - Yo, Mystic Quest! I love the soundtrack to that game. Very fun file! No complaints! Yes.

Deku Palace (Lofty) - Okay, I need to ask you a question. When trying to step this file did it keep feeling randomly offsync? Trying to view it in the editor is a nightmare. Because of the encoding on the MP3, stepmania is having a seizure. What's with all of the 192nds sprinkled throughout the file? Is that because of the poorly encoded MP3 and Stepmania or what? Also thet entire 192nd section is off. Unless you make changes again and resubmit or something it's a no

Gopher Grover (Jose_Varela) - I love the gimmicks! Only downside is the song/chart repeat and nothing changes. It's really easy, but that's alright, because I want this pack to have all kinds of difficulties! Yes!

Rhythm and Balance (bmah) - SONIC ADVENTURE 2! You stepped my favorite song, too! Hard, but solid chart! No complaints! Yup!

The Mystic Caves (Lofty) - Definitely gonna need some changes. There's some really cool ideas in here. Half the time it's hard to really hear what the notes are going to, it just feels dumped in. There's times where you step a certain sound and then 2 seconds later you completely avoid it. It's feels really hectic and all over the place. Love the jacks, but even those stretch on for a little too long (pitch changes but you stay on the same arrow). As of now, it's a no. I would love to see some changes and a resubmit though! You're close!

[NeonSM]

Re: The VideoGame MegaPack 4 (OPEN FOR SUBMISSIONS)!

You judged the fix, right?

Lofty btw

[macgravel]

Re: The VideoGame MegaPack 4 (OPEN FOR SUBMISSIONS)!

You judged the fix, right?

Lofty btw

Yup

[MarioNintendo]

Re: The VideoGame MegaPack 4 (OPEN FOR SUBMISSIONS)!

neonsm is lofty rhino, confirmed?

haiyyyype. Thanks for the review mac.

[lofty rhino]

Re: The VideoGame MegaPack 4 (OPEN FOR SUBMISSIONS)!

Close enough.

[MarioNintendo]

Re: The VideoGame MegaPack 4 (OPEN FOR SUBMISSIONS)!

Sent a file. Check out this cool-ass banner.

[MarioNintendo]

Re: The VideoGame MegaPack 4 (OPEN FOR SUBMISSIONS)!

Sent a fix for that file with the cool-ass banner.

[macgravel]

Re: The VideoGame MegaPack 4 (OPEN FOR SUBMISSIONS)!

u kilt the pak

[hi19hi19]

Re: The VideoGame MegaPack 4 (OPEN FOR SUBMISSIONS)!

[MarioNintendo]

Re: The VideoGame MegaPack 4 (OPEN FOR SUBMISSIONS)!

Now i truly kilt the pack.