Yolomania Vol. 4 Submissions CLOSED

[BilliumMoto]

Re: Yolomania Vol. 4 Submissions Open

The biggest problem with this file is that the hold count makes it kind of an easy AA, while the file itself has a lot of tricky parts to it, so it's not really good for scoring at all as a result. Really super interesting chart otherwise and we’re glad to have it. (Is there anywhere that the hold layering could be reduced a bit that wouldn’t affect how the chart plays?)

Play
for
fun

[GammaBlaster]

Re: Yolomania Vol. 4 Submissions Open

sCK! My files got in!

Definitely gonna try to squeeze in a couple more stuff that's been rotting in my hard drive for a while now.

[choof]

Re: Yolomania Vol. 4 Submissions Open

glad you liked GBYE! I mostly made it for myself, but figured that it would be a solid file for rates
would you like me to finish the solo chart/make the chart I mentioned in the email?

also, I'm gonna pull ragga bomb. as happy as I am that you liked it as well, I think it's pretty boring after playing it again.

[_Zenith_]

Re: Yolomania Vol. 4 Submissions Open

Play
for
fun

lmfao

[Wafles]

Re: Yolomania Vol. 4 Submissions Open

glad you liked GBYE! I mostly made it for myself, but figured that it would be a solid file for rates
would you like me to finish the solo chart/make the chart I mentioned in the email?

also, I'm gonna pull ragga bomb. as happy as I am that you liked it as well, I think it's pretty boring after playing it again.

Okay, fair enough.

Totally up to you on whether you want to include a solo chart or not. None of us really play solo so we wouldn't be able to give much feedback on it really. Basically if you send a completed solo chart for it we'll include it, but that's totally up to you.

[Krolxp]

Re: Yolomania Vol. 4 Submissions Open

Okay, fair enough.

Totally up to you on whether you want to include a solo chart or not. None of us really play solo so we wouldn't be able to give much feedback on it really. Basically if you send a completed solo chart for it we'll include it, but that's totally up to you.

Lol. Licca has solo chart. It wasn't worked well because it's not complete in spite of I finished 4k. I didn't pay attention of making what keymod I made.

[.Gazelle.]

Re: Yolomania Vol. 4 Submissions Open

fixing up HAVOX for this

[Leo137]

Re: Yolomania Vol. 4 Submissions Open

Sent two more files!

[Wafles]

Re: Yolomania Vol. 4 Submissions Open

Review Batch 5
REVIEWS HERE --> https://docs.google.com/document/d/1...SNndJofOh4iCxA

If for some reason your submission is missing from this document and you sent your submission before 12:00am EST Wednesday, Oct 28th, let me know. If your file was sent after this time it will be reviewed with the rest of batch 6.

Review batch 6 deadline is Tuesday night at midnight (12:00am Sunday, Nov. 1st).


As a note, there are 8 review batches total before submissions close.

[AZVW_2]

Re: Yolomania Vol. 4 Submissions Open

' w'! How many files accepted for now

[AutotelicBrown]

Re: Yolomania Vol. 4 Submissions Open

If possible I would like to know which bursts on wizdomiot were considered offensive by the reviewers.

Because of repetition there are basically only 4 different bursts in that section and commeting how I see it in order of appearance:
- 24th minijack 24th: Takes momentarily a bit more control from the hand doing the minijack than the general dense jumpstream so I'm assuming this is ok
- short 3 64ths: Reading difficulty only, plays close to a hand so assuming ok too
- offsetted 32nds: I'm guessing this is the main reason for complaint. I'd argue this is mostly reading difficulty (it's effectively [23]41[234] 24ths without any gross minijack in/out of the pattern) but still more than understandable complaint especially considering it also precedes the 24th streams section. I will change even though I feel it is very justified (^:
- 48ths: Actually in doubt if this is being considered a problem. Effectively pretty close to a 4 note 24th jumptrill with the patterns around making it extremely comfortable to hit.

I actually think as it currently is, the burst section is easier and stacks slower with rates than the 24th streams and the ending dense js, albeit more control oriented. Guess I'm just your average biased player.

I'll probably only be able to submit an updated version with that and some other minor fixes for batch 7.

[Wafles]

Re: Yolomania Vol. 4 Submissions Open

If possible I would like to know which bursts on wizdomiot were considered offensive by the reviewers.

Because of repetition there are basically only 4 different bursts in that section and commeting how I see it in order of appearance:
- 24th minijack 24th: Takes momentarily a bit more control from the hand doing the minijack than the general dense jumpstream so I'm assuming this is ok
- short 3 64ths: Reading difficulty only, plays close to a hand so assuming ok too
- offsetted 32nds: I'm guessing this is the main reason for complaint. I'd argue this is mostly reading difficulty (it's effectively [23]41[234] 24ths without any gross minijack in/out of the pattern) but still more than understandable complaint especially considering it also precedes the 24th streams section. I will change even though I feel it is very justified (^:
- 48ths: Actually in doubt if this is being considered a problem. Effectively pretty close to a 4 note 24th jumptrill with the patterns around making it extremely comfortable to hit.

I actually think as it currently is, the burst section is easier and stacks slower with rates than the 24th streams and the ending dense js, albeit more control oriented. Guess I'm just your average biased player.

I'll probably only be able to submit an updated version with that and some other minor fixes for batch 7.

I personally think that the 48ths are the biggest offenders, and while yeah they're just rolls, they're quite fast and regaining control after them to nail some jumptrilly parts can be quite rough. (e.g. http://puu.sh/l2D7k/97b01692bc.png). Its particularly rough especially since due to the density it leads into a pretty long 4 anchor.

And yeah, the 24ths after are probably more difficult, but not in as much of a BS-sort of way like those 48ths.


Skwid and/or caliber might want to weigh in too, but that's my opinion. You could also add me on skype if you want and we could chat about it there.

[Skwid1]

Re: Yolomania Vol. 4 Submissions Open

If possible I would like to know which bursts on wizdomiot were considered offensive by the reviewers.

Because of repetition there are basically only 4 different bursts in that section and commeting how I see it in order of appearance:
- 24th minijack 24th: Takes momentarily a bit more control from the hand doing the minijack than the general dense jumpstream so I'm assuming this is ok
- short 3 64ths: Reading difficulty only, plays close to a hand so assuming ok too
- offsetted 32nds: I'm guessing this is the main reason for complaint. I'd argue this is mostly reading difficulty (it's effectively [23]41[234] 24ths without any gross minijack in/out of the pattern) but still more than understandable complaint especially considering it also precedes the 24th streams section. I will change even though I feel it is very justified (^:
- 48ths: Actually in doubt if this is being considered a problem. Effectively pretty close to a 4 note 24th jumptrill with the patterns around making it extremely comfortable to hit.

I actually think as it currently is, the burst section is easier and stacks slower with rates than the 24th streams and the ending dense js, albeit more control oriented. Guess I'm just your average biased player.

I'll probably only be able to submit an updated version with that and some other minor fixes for batch 7.

forgive my stupid noteskin and use of the sm3.95 editor, but i'll point out a couple of the more specific problems i had because i am gay.

in general, i'm just personally not a huge fan of the offset 32nd bursts due to the patterning, but that's because i hate rolls. imo they're made gayer because of the hand right before them and because they don't start on 1 or 4.

however, stuff like this (http://puu.sh/l2DZq/909930ea0e.png) is super homo on the right hand. it's a really awkward transition into that burst. i would suggest adjusting the patterns to not include one-hand trills transitioning into it.

http://puu.sh/l2EfR/2acdd7035e.png this is also a gay transition into the longest 24th section of the file.

http://puu.sh/l2ER0/13a64a1c82.png not related to the bursts, but this jack leading into a one-hand trill is really mean and felt kind of unnecessary.

overall, i guess my problem with most of the bursty stuff in the second half has to do with how aggressively you layered the jumps/hands in that section because it forces you to make awkward transitions into bursts. just look over the hand balance right before bursts and try to cut down on unnecessary one-hand stuff right before/after them.

you can take the criticism regarding the offset 32nd patterns however you want, and i'm not personally going to demand you change them because i recognize that i just hate rolly bursts.

[AutotelicBrown]

Re: Yolomania Vol. 4 Submissions Open

Fair enough, probably going to change the 48ths to something else altogether.

http://puu.sh/l2EfR/2acdd7035e.png this is also a gay transition into the longest 24th section of the file.

Yeah, was definitely intending to change that. About the other instances of the offset 32nds, I'll need to have a better look but I'm likely to leave as is.

http://puu.sh/l2ER0/13a64a1c82.png not related to the bursts, but this jack leading into a one-hand trill is really mean and felt kind of unnecessary.

It was a mix of the 4 hits before warranting a jack (in fact one option I had was putting an aiae [12][12][34][34][124]), that first hand being a stronger hit than what is layered as hands right after and that I actually find trilling out of minijacks pretty comfortable. Either way I don't feel strongly about keeping it so seems fine to change.

You could also add me on skype if you want and we could chat about it there.

Will probably do once I have time to work on that.

In any case, thanks for the feedback.

[Krolxp]

Re: Yolomania Vol. 4 Submissions Open

Where should I improve my Heavy difficulty in Catch your eyes? All 32ths? I Understand my bursts are not fun here. I'm gonna improve that ptoblem but where I should improve it.
Some files in progress. 2 more files are waiting for a review .