TWG XCV: Nobody messes with the frog, see

[j-rodd123]

Re: TWG XCV: Nobody messes with the frog, see

have you read the thread?

[Viccica]

Re: TWG XCV: Nobody messes with the frog, see

Have you?

[Viccica]

Re: TWG XCV: Nobody messes with the frog, see

Most of it is nonsense and recycled information.

[j-rodd123]

Re: TWG XCV: Nobody messes with the frog, see

Most of it is nonsense and recycled information.

ok this is your signature day 1 quote. interrogating and pressing for information is not nonsense. does yoman's persistent and strong defense so early in the game not strike you as wolfy? it did for me, oh look there's an opinion.

what about crazyjayde's loooong posts, does that seem like pro-village to you? it did for me, but to an extent. of course it is too early to clear people but why not prod for suspicion sake. people have said jayde seems to be trying hard to fit in, and i agree with that (not a recycled opinion, it is good to hear the majority's opinion on stuff), however i'd rather have someone weighing in on the same ideas rather than always complaining "bla bla bla stop following V and manti, bla bla bla day 1 is useless, bla bla bla that opinion has been said".

[Viccica]

Re: TWG XCV: Nobody messes with the frog, see

TPS seems to have come a long way since I played with him last. I strongly agree with his initial post, where he votes for yoman. A lot of his post seemed like fluff but the point was really that only wolves have to be afraid of posting something that contributes. I always enjoy hearing his insight. It’s nice that he’s been poking at people and getting responses from various people.

Dance is clearly just making joke posts. This could just be a means of staying neutral to avert attention from him, where it also could just be him trying to be a safe human. He’s responding to things that have pretty much already been decided or moved past.

Yoman seems overly emotional, but that could be a kneejerk response to gathering votes on him in quick succession.

Freaky is stuck on his multiple voting pools idea. This is a bad idea for a number of reasons, but the primary one being that results are unreliable and it requires complete compliancy from everyone in the thread. Nevermind the fact it relies on there even BEING a vigi.

Cedo has a chronic case of talking bit and not backing it up. Seriously, where the analysis you promised on page like. 3. You’ve had plenty of time and plenty of posts to throw it out there. He also let Jayde defend him and then disappeared.

Jayde seems to be making informed, well-thought responses but I think her jumping on V was a bit premature. Further, after maybe three posts with V, she ended up voting for Cedo anyway?


Those are the notable things that I have seen thus far. I think the votes on Cedo are reasonable, but perhaps a little rushed. V, Manti and Jrodd are all playing as they typically would. Past James, my vote would probably be on Freaky because he’s incessantly useless and contributes little while maintaining a lockjaw on what he and only he deems to be a good idea.

[Viccica]

Re: TWG XCV: Nobody messes with the frog, see

And I'd just like to say that post was for V and Manti.


Jrodd, to you directly my gripe, as I'm saying for the third time now, is that there are a good five people in this thread that are just cantering along with the more active people, not saying much at all. Freaky and dance come immediately to mind.

Further we have people that virtually do not exist in this game right now like Zoshi and Ac1.

And that is permitted to happen because of laziness and on-the-spot decisions.

[Viccica]

Re: TWG XCV: Nobody messes with the frog, see

That is to say, I respect V and Manti and am sorry I've been playing like butt lately so that was my initial attempt to remedy.

[Tps222]

Re: TWG XCV: Nobody messes with the frog, see

wolves legit can't communicate during the day time? what is this horseshit

This is such an obvious "Hey guys look I'm totally not a wolf" play that I can't decide if you'd actually do it if you were a wolf.

@Vicc: I certainly don't view this as recycled and pointless posting by most people. Personally, I haven't played with a good chunk of these players. Not only do I find interesting what they post, but how and why they post what they do as well; How everyone reacts to pressure. Who comes to the defense of others, and how they do it. There are definitely opinions being formed and discussed.

I'm going to switch my vote up to JRodd for now. It isn't a "definitive" vote so much as an uncomfortable feeling I've gotten reading his last 5 or 6 posts. It almost feels like an attempt at purposefully white-knighting for humanity, without actually saying anything of substance to back up his vote on Yomann(which is a piggyback vote if I've ever seen one). I'll keep this vote until he gives me a few examples of Yoman's "defensiveness". I'm not criticizing the choice as much as the reason for it.

[Viccica]

Re: TWG XCV: Nobody messes with the frog, see

I would argue that V, you and Jayde are the only ones that have posted anything noteworthy and the rest are clinging onto the sidelines.

[yo man im awesome]

Re: TWG XCV: Nobody messes with the frog, see

I would argue that V, you and Jayde are the only ones that have posted anything noteworthy and the rest are clinging onto the sidelines.

To me it sounds like you believe that every single person should have a different opinion than the next person, and that ideas should only be elaborated upon by the person who has that opinion, as opposed to hearing what other's think of that opinion.

[Viccica]

Re: TWG XCV: Nobody messes with the frog, see

It's not that I believe opinions should drastically differ, more that a substantial vote (especially the second or third on one person) should have more than one sentence accompanying it.

[j-rodd123]

Re: TWG XCV: Nobody messes with the frog, see

^ yea i agree. that was my point. i am changing to freaky. it seems like he is trying hard to mimic his erradic style from last game in order to appear consistent. does anyone else feel this way?

[j-rodd123]

Re: TWG XCV: Nobody messes with the frog, see

the agree was @yoman

[Viccica]

Re: TWG XCV: Nobody messes with the frog, see

LoL. Back shortly.

[Vendetta21]

Re: TWG XCV: Nobody messes with the frog, see

Great argument. I like how your contribution is pointing out this fact and digging your heels into the ground. I think your vote for James May is weak and your fuss about the lemminghood of others is just smoke screening a terrible vote.

What I want is a little deeper clarification on why James May is wolfy.