Hard Song Special Batch - Submission Closed

[jimerax]

Re: Hard Song Special Batch - Submission Closed

For hi19,

Adjustment Method

If a file gets rating A from Judge A, "actual" rating will be adjusted with following formula;

A = raw rating from Judge A
M(A) = Mean(Judge A) -- average rating of Judge A, indicator of strictness
SD(A) = SD(Judge A) -- SD of Judge A's rating, indicator of variation in Judge A's ratings
M(t) = Mean(total) -- average of Mean(Judge A), Mean(Judge B)...
SD(t) = SD(total) -- average of SD(Judge A), SD(Judge B)...
X(A) = actual rating from Judge A after the adjustment


X(A) = M(A) + {A - M(A)}*{SD(t) / SD(A)} + {M(t) - M(A)}

Maximum X(A) = 10, and Minimum X(A) = 1.
After we calculate X(A), .... X(F), we'll discard the highest rating and the lowest rating.

Then, the average of other ratings will be defined as the score of the file from this judgement system.

We calculated both Average(X(A), ... X(F)) and Average (without min and max) this time since we had only 6 primary judges. If one of these parameters is above 6.5, the file passes primary judgement.

[mean/SD of every primary judge]

bmah - 5.543 / 2.393
samurai7694 - 5.489 / 2.372
kommisar - 6.089 / 2.042
Gundam-Dude - 6.68 / 1.816
i love you - 6.302 / 2.029
qqwref - 6.458 / 2.010

For Zierg:
well, I'm suggesting fix for only 48ths part in the beginning now.
You still think they are the best representations of the song, I won't say anything anymore and moving it to the queue as it is.

[leonid]

Re: Hard Song Special Batch - Submission Closed

Made it simpler (canceled out two M(A)'s lol):

[hi19hi19]

Re: Hard Song Special Batch - Submission Closed

Okay, thank you for clarifying.

[jimerax]

Re: Hard Song Special Batch - Submission Closed

Made it simpler (canceled out two M(A)'s lol):

I wanted to emphasis how it's calculated probably, but yeah it's simpler and looks better.