jTWG XIV: The march ends. WOLVES WIN!!!

[Sol_Solis]

continued from last post:
vote him over someone else, who is "more suspicous"

[TheRaiRaiEatsBalloons]

I don't think Vash is a wolf really. I just think he's a prick.
But it would be a waste to vote him either way since he's useless.

I'm gonna go with TSA.
Seriously, there's a lot of stuff to go on, and he's voting based on inactivity... twice in a row.

[iggymatrixcounter]

Or psychic might be the wolf because he's trying so hard to make everyone think he isn't.

I've thought that too Sol. But for now I stand on my judgement and wait to see if something more conclusive comes out.

[TheRaiRaiEatsBalloons]

I'd rather have people who suck but post play than people who don't.

As a human that would not make any sense, asuming you're trying to win the game. You're trying to survive and win the game, not weed out the stupid people.

posting without brain > not posting anything

Wrong, especially when you're using that as a basis of voting while tryign to vote off wolves so you stay alive. Then again, if you're a wolf, you don't have to worry about that. Hmm?

[TheRaiRaiEatsBalloons]

Sol, your suggestion may have merit. I'll certainly be taking that into account.

[TSAGod]

Oh im active but noone other than mead [asked for my suspect list] has im'd me or pm'd me so I had noting to contribute [still dont] so I didn't post. Alright bye. /waste of post

EoD has had nothing to contribute, and she's still managed to post. You could have even said that you are not the psychic, and that would have been worthwhile.

Would that really have been worthwhile? Are you saying that EoD's behavior is acceptible? Wtf reasoning is this?
You are basically saying, "Don't do anything smart - its still worthwhile"
tentative confusion stirs in my mind
TSA God

And if you're right, EoD's probably a wolf too. But I'm not so sure about your logic.

I definately suspect TSA though, mostly because it seems like he's promoting useless votes even though we have a lot of evidence. Theoretically, the people who happento be inactive could be human and a few of those we are suspecting could be wolves. In that case, his votes would be super convenient: He makes a vote that is useless, with very little logic, but in a way that he very well could get away with. It's nowhere near definite, but it seems a lot more likely and a lot more justified than most of the theories that have come up.

People I'm leaning between are TSA, Vash, and ddrruler.
Voting Vash at this particular moment seems a bit useless since he's an idiot, but I'm still not sure exactly what to do right now.

I'll say it again. A vote against a person who doesn't post isn't a useless vote. It prevents us from losing somebody because they have more phantoms than there are players.

Really, I could vote for everybody because they aren't posting, aren't posting well enough, posting too much to make us believe him, or any other mundane reason.

The game doesn't really start until we have information on everybody, and we don't have enought to make a final decision on everybody. We have real weak reasons for choosing anybody now. There's no seer, there's no real stupid action that dominates. Nobody has said "the only other time I was a wolf."

Let's just cut out the people who haven't done anything. We aren't losing anything either way.

You can't win this game on the first day. So let's not try.

[TheRaiRaiEatsBalloons]

The game "really starts" when it starts.

Cutting the people who aren't doing anything IS a waste, because they aren't doing anything.
And yes we ARE losing something: a much better chance to nail a wolf. We will have more information late, but anyone who says we don't already have a lot of information is either mislead or attempting to mislead everyone else.

You can't win the game on the first day, but not trying to at least peg one wolf is ludicrous. Why wouldn't you? That's what we're trying to do, isn't it?
By your logic, we should do nothing on Day 2 either, because you can't win on Day 2.
BS.

[psychic25]

Or psychic might be the wolf because he's trying so hard to make everyone think he isn't. He is also trying to raise suspicion about a bunch of people to make sure no one votes for him because they won't have a reason to vote him over someone else who is "more suspicous"

Of course I could be a wolf. Anybody could be a wolf. But how am I trying "really hard" to prove that I'm human?

Also, who would really WANT people to vote for them? When only a few people have voted for me in the past (even a few), I usually end up getting lynched. I really don't want ANY suspicions on me because I usually die when there are suspicions on me.

posting without brain > not posting anything

Well, yes, but it's not like they should KEEP posting without a brain if it can be helped. And I think there's been enough posted here to draw up some good posts.

Everyone just be smart and post plz >.<

[Sol_Solis]

Or psychic might be the wolf because he's trying so hard to make everyone think he isn't. He is also trying to raise suspicion about a bunch of people to make sure no one votes for him because they won't have a reason to vote him over someone else who is "more suspicous"

Of course I could be a wolf. Anybody could be a wolf. But how am I trying "really hard" to prove that I'm human?

Also, who would really WANT people to vote for them? When only a few people have voted for me in the past (even a few), I usually end up getting lynched. I really don't want ANY suspicions on me because I usually die when there are suspicions on me.

posting without brain > not posting anything

Well, yes, but it's not like they should KEEP posting without a brain if it can be helped. And I think there's been enough posted here to draw up some good posts.

Everyone just be smart and post plz >.<

Well I got the impression that you're trying 'really hard' because, your posts are long and detailed like you're trying to win an award. I know that it's always good that they are, and in TWG that's nearly how everyone posts, but that was just my first impression because you stand out.

[TheRaiRaiEatsBalloons]

posting without brain > not posting anything

Well, yes, but it's not like they should KEEP posting without a brain if it can be helped.

Agreed.

I'd rather have several people inactive than several people gaying up the thread.

[iggymatrixcounter]

o and before we get too far into this. Can someone explain what a safety vote is?? Gonzo said they weren't allowed and I can't find what they are.

[Edge_of_Death]

iggy

[Edge_of_Death]

Because I don't want to get a phantom. I'll take my vote off iggy and onto someone else if he gets lots of votes.

[TheRaiRaiEatsBalloons]

That, Iggy my friend, to answer your question, would be a safety vote right there.

[psychic25]

A safety vote happens in this situation:

You have no suspicions, but you need to vote by the end of the day. Otherwise, you'll get a phantom. Therefore, you vote for somebody who has no votes on them (so you won't accidentally end up helping lynch them) and go on your merry way.

Gonzo's just trying to get us all to vote for people that we actually think are wolves and not just say "oh I'll think about this game later and stall for time now".

^ Haha, irony.