TWG 201: Game Showdown Throwdown (Excite11) - GAME THREAD

[ShadoWolfe]

Re: TWG 201: Game Showdown Throwdown (Excite11) - GAME THREAD

You still did not answer why you thought I was correct. And I get you are busy, but almost your entire post seems to be talking about things that are adjacent to what I am not liking with you, but not directly what I meant.

From a theory perspective, I agree with some of what you are saying about #2. However, even if I take your bugkid and Shadowgod leans to mean just that they are basically behaving how you expected them to, I still do not like it in context. With Shadow, you even found something that seemed odd on the surface, but softened the impact by saying you do not want to hang him overall.

I don't recall suspecting anything about Shadow God so, I doubt this is the wrong Shadow.

nah she was definitely talking about lewdy.

[Hakulyte]

Re: TWG 201: Game Showdown Throwdown (Excite11) - GAME THREAD

I don't care if she doesn't like it. I'm just saying what works for myself. I just feel like Shadow God would fail to emulate his town sense that well.

I also feel like bugkid has an identicaly mind state as every town game they ever rolled.

If you can't see that then I'm curious about what you see.

[ShadoWolfe]

Re: TWG 201: Game Showdown Throwdown (Excite11) - GAME THREAD

@host roundbox
is there a postcount minimum this game? what is the modkill vs replacement threshold here or is there one at all?
sorry for the size 7, just want clarification early on

[Hakulyte]

Re: TWG 201: Game Showdown Throwdown (Excite11) - GAME THREAD

I'll be around for eod which is what's important

This is the only foreshadowing part that could be more W than T by principles.

[ShadoWolfe]

Re: TWG 201: Game Showdown Throwdown (Excite11) - GAME THREAD

I'm bored decided to associate concerns with reads. I'll develop if there's things you guys don't understand.

I'm concerned that mellon_collie has no post that helps me read her or anyone. The only noticeable thing is the friendliness with Shadow God and that's cool and all. It's just that clock is ticking and if you flipped D0, no one would have a clue what you liked/didn't like. I'm not gonna be a bit meanie and ask for reads 10 pages in with nothing going on, but if I could have a pulse or where the vibes are at, I'd be super happy.

I'll skip being concerned about Zenith, 'cause 0 post. It's just a reminder that the slot exist.

I'm actually not concerned about Shadow God because I'm seeing the exact same posts/concerns/thought process as he does in his town games and I cannot picture him ever wolfing this at this point.

I'm concerned about FFA in relation to myself and also in relation to Star-crossed because you've been doing some hyper focus stuff that is a little early. The DBP vote is spicy tho. It looks more interesting to me than the ShadoWolfe wagon. Unfortunately, I have nothing making me lean DBP wolf specifically. I can see why DBP would vote ShadoWolfe and he could be right, but I feel more strongly about ShadoWolfe being town than where the waves are trying to push. I'm having a bad time putting myself in your shoes, but it's cool to see some takes. I think if you explained your own takes it would help me with alignment.

I'm concerned about WV because I am certainly flipping a coin over one thing. I'm town reading the guy over "investigative mentality", but I need to be careful about the "how" he does it. I think if you switch between posting short posts and making more lengthy ones to explain in depth your stance, It'd be easier to secure a town read. I do think you're primarily town, but I wasn't fan of your first post and how you had to joke about blue roles etc. I wouldn't put it past you to be the active wolf in this game, but maybe you just like bringing positive energy in the thread which is obviously very good. It's just that fun guys aren't always good guys in this game. Still town tho.

My only real concern with Star-crossed is if the entire gameplay is centered around finding one target and sticking to it rather than exploring what everyone has to say. I do think the attitude is generally pro-town, but I'm more used to see town Star-crossed playing more relax and just showering thoughts rather than being more investigative. It could just be a playstyle preference for this game at the moment.

So, I'm currently heavily interested in FFA/Star. I'm pretty sure I overlook something tho. I tend to town read how Star is posting, but it would make so much sense to me if reasons had to do with FFA W/W.

I tone read bugkid/Xel, but it's mostly sentence association with older games rather than calculating if intentions are real or not. tldr; gut town

DBP I'll just hold back a bit more and see how things goes. I'll just say null for now.

in this post, when you said "I'm having a bad time putting myself in your shoes, but it's cool to see some takes. I think if you explained your own takes it would help me with alignment." are you referring to FFA?

[Hakulyte]

Re: TWG 201: Game Showdown Throwdown (Excite11) - GAME THREAD

Shadow God flipping wolf here would just be major wtf moment. I can't find anything.

[Hakulyte]

Re: TWG 201: Game Showdown Throwdown (Excite11) - GAME THREAD

in this post, when you said "I'm having a bad time putting myself in your shoes, but it's cool to see some takes. I think if you explained your own takes it would help me with alignment." are you referring to FFA?

Yeah.

fmpov, I think you're just casually trying to find small things, but you got a decent balance between trying and not overly committing to thoughts. That could be either W or T, but I just have nothing that would justify W.

[ShadoWolfe]

Re: TWG 201: Game Showdown Throwdown (Excite11) - GAME THREAD

Yeah.

so since that post, did FFA's back n forth posts culminating in his townlist give you any food for thought or is it basically the same read at this point?

[Hakulyte]

Re: TWG 201: Game Showdown Throwdown (Excite11) - GAME THREAD

so since that post, did FFA's back n forth posts culminating in his townlist give you any food for thought or is it basically the same read at this point?

Leaning null at best. I could still see myself vote there.

I hate how you ask me instead of addressing the slot yourself. I also hate how people consider voting me without explaining why.


It looks bad on posterity.

[Hakulyte]

Re: TWG 201: Game Showdown Throwdown (Excite11) - GAME THREAD

I will have to vote someone tonight.

I will miss eod.

[ShadoWolfe]

Re: TWG 201: Game Showdown Throwdown (Excite11) - GAME THREAD

My only real concern with Star-crossed is if the entire gameplay is centered around finding one target and sticking to it rather than exploring what everyone has to say. I do think the attitude is generally pro-town, but I'm more used to see town Star-crossed playing more relax and just showering thoughts rather than being more investigative. It could just be a playstyle preference for this game at the moment.

So, I'm currently heavily interested in FFA/Star. I'm pretty sure I overlook something tho. I tend to town read how Star is posting, but it would make so much sense to me if reasons had to do with FFA W/W.

and then on this
I don't think I've ever seen star-crossed "play relaxed and just shower thoughts instead of being more investigative". I think she's always poked around as town. I think I believe what she said in a recent post (and is corroborated by previous conversations between us) that she tends to have an underlying anxiety in twg that results in a kind of performative pressure where she feels a need to produce results and therefore has a harder time being laid back and just shitposting. hence earlier this game I gave her slack for "not wanting to get distracted" even though we were like 40-50 posts in or so, because I expected as much from her.

is your recollection of her playstyle that much more relaxed than what you see here?

[ShadoWolfe]

Re: TWG 201: Game Showdown Throwdown (Excite11) - GAME THREAD

Leaning null at best. I could still see myself vote there.

I hate how you ask me instead of addressing the slot yourself. I also hate how people consider voting me without explaining why.


It looks bad on posterity.

I think FFA is probably town at this point, but I don't think he's outside of his wolfrange from when we were a wolfteam together. not sure how he's changed since but I think the core is likely the same from what I've seen

but my issue with your FFA/Star world is star. I think she's town at this point and would be surprised if she wasn't. obviously it's D0 or whatever, but I think there's enough of her thoughts to read to be comfortable excluding her until a much narrower list.

[ShadoWolfe]

Re: TWG 201: Game Showdown Throwdown (Excite11) - GAME THREAD

I will have to vote someone tonight.

I will miss eod.

until what time server time will you be able to play?

[Hakulyte]

Re: TWG 201: Game Showdown Throwdown (Excite11) - GAME THREAD

and then on this
I don't think I've ever seen star-crossed "play relaxed and just shower thoughts instead of being more investigative". I think she's always poked around as town. I think I believe what she said in a recent post (and is corroborated by previous conversations between us) that she tends to have an underlying anxiety in twg that results in a kind of performative pressure where she feels a need to produce results and therefore has a harder time being laid back and just shitposting. hence earlier this game I gave her slack for "not wanting to get distracted" even though we were like 40-50 posts in or so, because I expected as much from her.

is your recollection of her playstyle that much more relaxed than what you see here?

I just remember really calm behavior in general and sometimes surprisingly hindsightful posts about every players or what's going on in general.

I'm not used to see specific players being targeted Day 0. That being said, I'm not an expert on how Star-Crossed would play if wolf.

[Hakulyte]

Re: TWG 201: Game Showdown Throwdown (Excite11) - GAME THREAD

until what time server time will you be able to play?

I get home like 2-3 hours after eod. It's not even close. Next phase will also end outside of the weekend so, I'm perpetually going to fail to be here at eod.


This is encouraging me to try to do things that helps people read me and read others reading me. I'm expecting to be lacking in content during most of the game when it matters.