TWG CLXIV: Classics Man - Game Thread

[Hakulyte]

Re: TWG CLXIV: Classics Man - Game Thread

I think AA/Shado is W/T and if one flip wolf the other is town.

roundbox sounds like a potential 3rd wolf.

[thesunfan]

Re: TWG CLXIV: Classics Man - Game Thread

Trying awfully hard to divert attention off you, huh?
Your timing was awfully convenient after Haku(?) voted Witch to put DBP in KitB..

I care about you talking about why you think Haku can somehow post as a wolf
I care a lot about that point, actually

[Hakulyte]

Re: TWG CLXIV: Classics Man - Game Thread

I'm going to go ahead and say I seem to have risen a little too high in your estimation without explanation.

It's more that the rest fell down that badly.

[Witch of Certainty]

Re: TWG CLXIV: Classics Man - Game Thread

Also, Shado, if you're here, why is AA's DBP vote wolfy?

[Hakulyte]

Re: TWG CLXIV: Classics Man - Game Thread

I also think you're out of your mind for playing this way "if you're a wolf".

[AragakiAyase]

Re: TWG CLXIV: Classics Man - Game Thread

this feels very neutral to me, which I don't recall coming from town roundbox

it's in line with his statement of being satisfied with his vote for once, but it still doesn't feel good

one more point about this before I sleep for real

he feels very calm, and given yesterday's EOD I don't think any town would be calm, even given that he was supposedly satisfied with his vote. with all the rushing around of votes and wagons it was highly likely that someone other than DBP would be lynched, which I think would get roundbox to show some fire and try to pull people to the DBP wagon. this just seems like a wolf who's ok with what's happening because most likely a town is getting lynched

[Prophylaxis]

Re: TWG CLXIV: Classics Man - Game Thread

going to review things tomorrow

things i want to hit on:

1) vote/wagon analysis, more specifically how the dbp wagon formed over the other ones at EoD, plus other 4/5 vote wagons throughout day 1. there's definitely scum on the dbp train I think

2) want to reread haku/jade/witch. haku had that "is this too scummy to be scum" thing yesterday where he just majorly bandwagonned throughout all the trains but it really unnerved me. jade i still think is scum but the witch vote felt quite opportunistic and like aa said, agenda-y, but i actually want to talk to that slot and 40 minutes from EoD is /not/ the time to do it.

i still think that witch would have hopped to the wagon on me near eod if they were actually scum, but day 2 is the time for actual content to be posted. if they keep arguing about semantics and playstyle then i'm going to snap vote them.

jade harley

[Prophylaxis]

Re: TWG CLXIV: Classics Man - Game Thread

something like:

MML/proph
jade/witch
xel/roundbox
sunfan
AA/shado

From towniest to wolfiest.

okay haku, you /really/ need to explain your progression on me

how the heck do you go from townreading me mid day, to voting/scumreading me near eod, then having me near your top townreads as of right now?

i need to see some paper trails here

[AragakiAyase]

Re: TWG CLXIV: Classics Man - Game Thread

greg do you think I'm more likely to switch my vote there as a wolf or town
do you think I move my vote more as wolf or town

just think about it

[TWG Jade Harley]

Re: TWG CLXIV: Classics Man - Game Thread

hi aa!!!!

im glad your bouncing back from killing dbp :[

but i have a problem with your posts now...theyre just wrong!

your not reading the conversations around the posts your quoting and its really gross!!!

first you did it with shado when you quoted him replying to my old read list rather than my new one (which you would have easily seen if you had read the posts around that one!)

now your doing it again with my posts

let me quote the flow of conversation to make it simpler to see:

okay i think i should clear something up

i have been scumhunting!

ive been slowly building up a read list by looking at interactions and poking people for their opinions

i did that all last night! and i would have done it today too if i didnt have to work :[

the one post you found where i questioned witch again was one of the few where i legitimately missed their post, and even then its arguable if it was a bad thing since what they gave me was slightly different than before

i dont think your scum, you have a lot of good thoughts and insights! and your posts felt really natural! but maybe your on the wrong track??? revist my posts and tell me if you still think about me the same way after looking at the context of the convos! asking people repeatedly about their scumleans and townleans is how i came up with my lynch list for today <3

xel or witch!

they both refuse to elaborate on their scumleans and townleans and in the case of witch they are actively behaving anti town and avoiding questions!

i would be ok with either of them dying today

going to reread what i missed recently and post more thoughts, feel free to ask me any questions :]

Where is this magical reads list? I mustve missed it

im sad because im trying to make good reads and scumhunt and nobody is reading or noticing ;[

sooo my reads so far as im slowly filling them in...

strong town - mml prophylaxis

town lean - mello aa dbp haku

weak town - roundbox sunfan

null - witch shado

scum lean - xel charu (please answer my post charu!)

there was a flow of conversation there and you completely ignored it to vote me!

maybe calm down a bit???

this just doesn't look good, jade is super focused on one slot when it's 6 minutes to EOD and it smacks of agenda

there was an agenda there...kill someone i was suspicious of???

witch was leading in votes until you and xel threw votes at dbp and killed him instead >:[

[Hakulyte]

Re: TWG CLXIV: Classics Man - Game Thread

okay haku, you /really/ need to explain your progression on me

how the heck do you go from townreading me mid day, to voting/scumreading me near eod, then having me near your top townreads as of right now?

i need to see some paper trails here

It takes more than 3 votes to get you lynched. That was a pressure wagon. I liked your reaction and you moved up. It's that simple.

How I play is all based on gathering information. I'm pretty anti-town and opportunistic on a constant basis.

[thesunfan]

Re: TWG CLXIV: Classics Man - Game Thread

greg do you think I'm more likely to switch my vote there as a wolf or town
do you think I move my vote more as wolf or town

just think about it

I don't know about the 2nd part, I think you're tricky enough to do it pretty similar amounts as both alignments, especially during more chaotic eods, and that eod was about as crazy as it gets without a claim

I'm seeing something I don't understand, so I'm trying to understand it. Its not really coming down to town/wolf as much as it is trying to understand

things I don't understand are more wolfy, but that's not until I have an explanation/reason

[AragakiAyase]

Re: TWG CLXIV: Classics Man - Game Thread

Jade my issue is that your first reads list has witch/Xel as scumleans
Your second one then loses witch for charu, but you're quoting an old list from 18 hours ago
Then your vote ends up on witch again at the end

On phone but I'll see if there's a progression between those two

[TWG Jade Harley]

Re: TWG CLXIV: Classics Man - Game Thread

to be honest i thought it was absolutely insane that they were getting away with posting the way they were but i guess ill reset my reads and judge witch based on how today goes

their posting style kind of lent itself to that anyway since theres nothing really solid to go on from yesterday, which was why i was badgering witch to commit to a course of action and get some solid opinions out but oh well!!

[TWG Jade Harley]

Re: TWG CLXIV: Classics Man - Game Thread

my first reads list didnt have witch as a scumlean...???