jTWG LXXX - Simplicity 2.0

[Charu]

Re: jTWG LXXX - Simplicity 2.0

this isn't a damning point or anything but i found it hilarious that you made this vote and then immediately agree with funnygurl about j-rodd

It's more about how she's going about this entire game.

"It's phone posting"

Yeah, okay buddy

[Charu]

Re: jTWG LXXX - Simplicity 2.0

And you guys, don't be butts, wow!

[Tokzic]

Re: jTWG LXXX - Simplicity 2.0

too late

[choof]

Re: jTWG LXXX - Simplicity 2.0

charu

[choof]

Re: jTWG LXXX - Simplicity 2.0

nah just kidding
unvote

[choof]

Re: jTWG LXXX - Simplicity 2.0

let's not have a charu wagon pile up, since the last two wolves are xel and fg
neither of them have a vote on charu
I don't want any kind of rush

[Wineandbread]

Re: jTWG LXXX - Simplicity 2.0

Okay I've done some rereading:

Choof: Lots of meaningful contribution and rattling, pushing forward with the game. I don't think a wolf would play like this.

Sunfan: has done well in the way of questioning and providing (imo) honest comments. Pushed with a lot of evidence against dbp (mostly by comparison of his past behavior), doesn't feel like they are on the same team

Of my town reads, I am most confident in the above.

Soundwave: leaned exclusively on day1: the dialogue with him and dbp, and his vote on dbp.

Storn: voting dbp towards eod in the way he did, unlikely they were on the same team. Dbp is wolf, ergo

fg: day1 interrogation of me was relatively town-like

Suspicious fellas:

Xel: wrote about in the last post, basically a bit suspicious

dfr: fg and dfr are really going at it from what I've seen. It's unlikely both are wolf. Of the two, I favor dfr as wolf. He unvotes in post 515 when dbp is in danger of insta, focuses storn cause he went full yolo, tries to defend dbp. dfr and I had similar reasoning for not voting dbp (maybe he was just inactive, was already majority, etc.), but in the aftermath he posts this:

And about my activity at EoD, I started seeing scummy things. I still had my vote on dbp, I didn't believe he was a wolf especially after you and storn voted, I thought there was a lot to talk about. There was still 30 minutes to an hour left with people in the thread, it was super unnecessary to insta there, I'd like to know why you were trying to end it so quickly. Of course, I'm was wrong about dbp, he was a wolf, my read was wrong, sic vita est.

Some questions I have for you would be: Why did you want to end the day so fast trying to hammer super hard? Did you think dbp was a wolf or did you think dbp was a wolf because other people thought he was a wolf?

With 30 mins left and no response, dbp had it coming. I dunno why you changed your opinion of that when fg and storn voted. Which did you think is scummy? Or both?

The other people are now all neutral, based on recent posts.

Man this game is too hard for me

[choof]

Re: jTWG LXXX - Simplicity 2.0

it's only too hard since you don't have much free time

[choof]

Re: jTWG LXXX - Simplicity 2.0

I'd go pull a vendetta quote because I don't want this word in my post history, but that post was pretty milquetoast

[Soundwave-]

Re: jTWG LXXX - Simplicity 2.0

wher soundwave

actually has anyone noticed that soundwave just stopped posting... [wow somebody cares about me?]

A combination of league and having a strong gut feeling that if I wasn't lynched, vig would have shot me out of spite.

Choof is (probably) not vig.

Anywho, storn gets a town lean only because while I can't readily see the motivation behind the weird EOD posting, nothing seems off this day. Seems more like a gimmick than woof behavior.

wineandbread is a bit suspicious to me just because of the relatively little contribution, especially day 1, but I can certainly empathize with possible explanations.

Lots of rereading is in order, and I can't be bothered to do that right now. There's homework and league to be done.

[danceflashrevo]

Re: jTWG LXXX - Simplicity 2.0

He unvotes in post 515 when dbp is in danger of insta, focuses storn cause he went full yolo, tries to defend dbp. dfr and I had similar reasoning for not voting dbp (maybe he was just inactive, was already majority, etc.), but in the aftermath he posts this:

With 30 mins left and no response, dbp had it coming. I dunno why you changed your opinion of that when fg and storn voted. Which did you think is scummy? Or both?

There was no need to insta, it's silly to insta when there's still discussion that could've happened and discussion did indeed happen. I never had any intention of actually voting DBP at the end of the day, I simply had my vote on for pressure. I think it was really weird how FG voted DBP specifically trying to hammer, and the only intention that she had of voting DBP was "I like jrodd" which is kinda weird, and then she wanted pressure on you or me because she scumread both of us. She was unsure of anything, she could've easily put a vote on me or you, but instead went with DBP, with the intent to hammer. She felt unsure about me and DBP, why not vote for me instead? Her voting for DBP was simply a fact that she voted for him, it wasn't important to whether or not he got lynched.

And then on the subject of storn, storns posts as a collective was very... odd. Specifically stating what he doesn't like other people doing, and then doing that same thing, and then acknowledging that he's doing it as he's doing it. His defense was "lol this is my town game silly". He's basically saying that he can act however scummy he wants but it's okay because it's his town game. It's like he's an actual wolf and he's taunting us. At least, that's my impression.

Which do I think is scummy? Both. I'd take either one of them, right now fg. I think at least one of them is wolf though.

[thesunfan]

Re: jTWG LXXX - Simplicity 2.0

I'd go pull a vendetta quote because I don't want this word in my post history, but that post was pretty milquetoast

it wasn't bad though, right?
I thought it was pretty ok regardless of his alignment

[thesunfan]

Re: jTWG LXXX - Simplicity 2.0

@both w&b and soundwave
you've both done something that a lot of newer players do that is generally not a good idea, which is comment on who you think a power role might be. Don't do that.

Here's why: If you're right, you're giving wolves information if they don't have it already. You may be pointing out to them the roles, which is bad, because if they kill them in the night, town is worse off.

I know it conflicts with what you have been told already which is to speak your mind essentially, but this is the exception to the rule

[thesunfan]

Re: jTWG LXXX - Simplicity 2.0

w&b is henceforth referred to as wabby

[XelNya]

Re: jTWG LXXX - Simplicity 2.0

Ok friend