Hard Song Special Batch [Aug 2013]

[bmah]

Re: Hard Song Special Batch [Aug 2013] (Submissions Closed)

I really haven't felt this disappointed in a long time. The amount of time that has transpired since the deadline is absolutely unacceptable.

I've PMed those still remaining to finish everything by this weekend at the absolute latest. For everyone waiting, I really do apologize for the wait.

This thread also does not deserve to be filled with low-content posts for the duration of the wait. It will be unlocked when the full results are in.

[bmah]

Re: Hard Song Special Batch [Aug 2013] (Submissions Closed)

Thread opened again. Batch notes here: http://www.flashflashrevolution.com/...=114965&page=3

Please note that we're still waiting for notes on a few more songs from Wayward Vagabond and jimerax.

[EzExZeRo7497]

Re: Hard Song Special Batch [Aug 2013] (Submissions Closed)

5.5/5/7/7/6 - 6.1

Not hoping much... was expecting something like that as well. Kinda disappointed that some notes I've gotten aren't really precise but I'm probably going to try and improve it nonetheless.

EDIT: Choofers, if you don't mind, could you pinpoint which parts specifically that I need to work on? I understand about the PR thing (which admittedly I didn't put any effort into whatsoever, but I never had any intention to use pitch relevancy to begin with) but I want to know how do I make the percussion sections more interesting.

[bmah]

Re: Hard Song Special Batch [Aug 2013] (Submissions Closed)

Oh, and please don't hesitate to ask judges for the specifics. Choofers personally offered to go into more detail for instance.

[Choofers]

Re: Hard Song Special Batch [Aug 2013] (Submissions Closed)

hey I know

LET'S START SOME DRAMA

Sightread 5 cbs, this file is definitely FC'able but there are like two one handed parts that are total ass.

Also this file is a masterpiece. Only real complaint is how some holds are placed like traps with one handed transitions and the one hand split gallops but other than that this file is amazing.

Robotomy
- [1/10]

etcetcetc

Overall: I found some disgusting 16th minijacks, a lot of 24th bursts are actually 32nds, the jumps and hands make no sense, some parts are completely understepped, there are many missing notes (these are arbitrary though), lots of unnecessary offsetted color notes that sometimes even had the wrong rhythm to begin with, and there are too many fast one handed gallops for this file to be remotely playable without a lot of guessing especially due to color notes. I am very sure a lot of the technical errors are due to such a low BPM being used (127 BPM), which causes color madness everywhere. This is a complex song, but some recoloring can make it more readable and a unique hard file. But in its current state, it is a mess.

It took me over 20 hours, probably even 30 hours, to review this file.

okay man (O:

[Choofers]

Re: Hard Song Special Batch [Aug 2013] (Submissions Closed)

but yeah, if you have any issues with my notes, please send me a PM or a message on skype

and I will give detailed notes

[mi40]

Re: Hard Song Special Batch [Aug 2013] (Submissions Closed)

ratings are all over the place


okay dossar you can stop with the 1/10 now, you might need to reconsider the fact that some people step some parts a certain way and your definition of "x-sound needing to be at x-moment" doesn't strike true with everybody's intentions

thanks

[EzExZeRo7497]

Re: Hard Song Special Batch [Aug 2013] (Submissions Closed)

ty based fission for shooting down my average rating

jk ily

[ilikexd]

Re: Hard Song Special Batch [Aug 2013] (Submissions Closed)

choco 8/8/7/8/5 (7.2)
paraclete 7.5/7/9/9/7 (7.9)
haelequin 8.5/9/6/6/7 (7.3)

my expectations have been exceeded

ratings are all over the place

i agree
also just generally lots of low ratings

[mi40]

Re: Hard Song Special Batch [Aug 2013] (Submissions Closed)

oh well stepping stuff winnipeg and bill is hard no doubt but a random js file like love hurts doing better makes me sad

[mi40]

Re: Hard Song Special Batch [Aug 2013] (Submissions Closed)

† venetian snares for life †
† neva give up †

dossar
Where's Bill
- [2/10]
- The overlayering issue and the technical errors don’t make a good combination for this long of a song

those 'technical' errors are intentional so that the song doesn't become a 48th/64th ridden shitfest
not all those 48th/64ths are recognizable among the 10 other sounds

[rCaliberGX]

Re: Hard Song Special Batch [Aug 2013] (Submissions Closed)

at the very least most of the errors that were pointed out in my submissions were noticed within a week after submission closed. shame i wasn't able to send the newer(better) versions beforehand

can i send them to regular batch?

[Choofers]

Re: Hard Song Special Batch [Aug 2013] (Submissions Closed)

You should be able to, yeah

[Choofers]

Re: Hard Song Special Batch [Aug 2013] (Submissions Closed)

holy shit was my 6000th post really about robotomy

[GammaBlaster]

Re: Hard Song Special Batch [Aug 2013] (Submissions Closed)

yes


by the way choof



also ji