Astronomic Metal Collection 2

[N.T.M.]

Re: Astronomic Metal Collection 2

lol, well the file isnt s***ty, I find it quite fun.

Two Weeks - rejected - The offset is way off, those ARE NOT 12th drum bursts in the intro, the main solo has too many inconsistencies, and I didn't bother to look any further cuz that's enough for me to reject this.

It hurt me to play it .

Euphoric Dream - Accepted - I'm going against N.T.M. on this one and definitely accepting it. I love it!

Don't even remember that file. I'll go back and see what I said ^_^.

Valkyries - Accepted with some tweaks - Some of the layering is questionable, but I really don't have many problems with this. I might accept it if N.T.M. didn't dislike it. Also, most of your files still have gap issues.

The pitch inconsistencies don't gnaw at the back of your mind?! hmm =/

[Joe D]

Re: Astronomic Metal Collection 2

glad to c this pack aint dead

[Plan_Bsk81127]

Re: Astronomic Metal Collection 2

Two Weeks - Accepted with some tweaks - As far as I could tell, the things N.T.M. pointed out are the only errors. They're minor enough for me to accept it, but I'd prefer to see them fixed. We do need some more overstepped stuff in this pack though.

All that matters N.T.M. :P

[SulferDragon]

Re: Astronomic Metal Collection 2

The pitch inconsistencies don't gnaw at the back of your mind?! hmm =/

I guess maybe a little. You know I don't like to complain about pitch errors though. I'm also not sure if he even knows how to make patterns pitch relevant. I've never seen PR patterns in his files.

+ this:

Heretics & Killers - accep - Didn't you submit this to XOON?

[Joe D]

Re: Astronomic Metal Collection 2

no.Charlo lacks Pitch Relevancy

PS.How many songs are in the pack already?

[Charlo]

Re: Astronomic Metal Collection 2

Yes, I do lack pitch relevancy, although it's not a matter of not knowing how to do it. I don't especially care. I make simfiles the way I like them. Maybe I'll sound like a douchebag saying this, but it seems like people have gotten too obsessed with making perfectly stepped/layered/PR'ed files and forgotten that this game is supposed to be fun.

I've wanted to say that for a while. :P

That said, I'm willing to sacrifice my artistic integrity so my files can make it into this pack. Thanks for reviewing my files NTM and Sulfer.

[N.T.M.]

Re: Astronomic Metal Collection 2

All that matters N.T.M. :P

I've been outranked 0_o.

*embraces the PWNAGE*

Yes, I do lack pitch relevancy, although it's not a matter of not knowing how to do it. I don't especially care. I make simfiles the way I like them. Maybe I'll sound like a douchebag saying this, but it seems like people have gotten too obsessed with making perfectly stepped/layered/PR'ed files and forgotten that this game is supposed to be fun.

True, but stated too vaguely. If a song contains very repetitive elements then some arbitrary placement can be permitted, but if accuracy (emulating the music as perfectly as possible) results in a boring file, that's always a result of poor song choice, because the song's also boring.

That said, I'm willing to sacrifice my artistic integrity so my files can make it into this pack. Thanks for reviewing my files NTM and Sulfer.

Superimpose that kinda style if you like, but only when it's warranted (like I mentioned). And you're welcome ^_^.

[Joe D]

Re: Astronomic Metal Collection 2

NTM is a little too strict .Remember NTM that PR aint important.Sulfer said it about a trillion times

[N.T.M.]

Re: Astronomic Metal Collection 2

NTM is a little too strict .Remember NTM that PR aint important.Sulfer said it about a trillion times

It's absolutely essential for certain genres. Unfortunately their application is typically even more important with rock genres (solos, etc.). And he never said it wasn't important. He said it was negligible in some instances.

[Joe D]

Re: Astronomic Metal Collection 2

I think im gunna submit sumthing else 4 this.The Fall of an Empire by Fairyland.Its preety sweet.I hope It can make a decent chart.Ill make it in the vein of my old filez (meaning Ill make it fun and index friendly) exept with PR

[N.T.M.]

Re: Astronomic Metal Collection 2

Bumping this project.

Sulfer are you still there?


Everything got overshadowed by all the other non-genre-specific packs.

[TC_llama499]

Re: Astronomic Metal Collection 2

release this **** already

[N.T.M.]

Re: Astronomic Metal Collection 2

release this **** already

If the project ends there are actually a sufficient number of files for release. That may happen.

[SulferDragon]

Re: Astronomic Metal Collection 2

People really aren't submitting stuff. Like, the last file submitted was yours, NTM, and that was awhile ago.

This isn't dead. In fact, I was actually digging around for some files today. I honestly don't care if this isn't released for another year though.

[Joe D]

Re: Astronomic Metal Collection 2

Great my Laptop got destroyed.Thus I lost each File I had to send to Sulfer.I still think of Stepping that Fairyland song but ive been lazy.If u like any files I havent submitted Sulfer.Fell free to put it on the pack