The Brand New Top Players List

[dawg4321]

Re: The Brand New Top Players List

I don't mean to complain but I know i have more than 61. I'll send a new list and you can check it if ya want, but i'm sure i'm in the high 60's if not 70's.

[scottish]

Re: The Brand New Top Players List

I can check that for you right now.

[itmorr]

Re: The Brand New Top Players List

I wasn't supposed to be on the new list though. Oh well; you win this round, but you have yet to win the war!!

[Vote4Nixon]

Re: The Brand New Top Players List

And for the boo rule: it's only there to prevent outright mashing scores from getting points (like lump's EHHS). Having a pure score req is file IMO, since it's impossible to mash and have halfway decent PA.

That's what I am hoping for, however, if we go simply by score, then the score requirements would have to be adjusted slightly to incorporate a boo rule. The FC score requirements seem fine because they promote not just an FC, but an FC with good PA. On the other hand, the score requirements for non-AAA, non-FC scores need to be adjusted (ie -100 to allow 5 boos). The question is how much should it be adjusted...should it be the same for each song? What is the maximum we can allow (I think -300 is around the difference between a good and a perfect, so no more than that)?

Also, as far as the bonus is concerned, I agree with Shash that currently it's not a well-implemented idea since it's not treated as a bonus. For instance, 50-59 AAAs = 4 pts, which could be achieved from songs in the 1-4 difficulty range, is equivalent to something like 30 goods or less on Silence, even though a player may be able to achieve those AAAs without even being able to combo Silence. However, I like the idea of "bonus" points...it makes this whole thing more appealing and promotes well-roundedness (aside from easy offbeat ****). In addition to Jim's 3 choices, perhaps one solution is to set a non-bonus Tier requirement for each Tier (ie Tier 4 = 50 pts, no more than 4 from bonus section). That way, the bonus really acts more like a bonus.

[dawg4321]

Re: The Brand New Top Players List

I send my list to ya scott. Just saying in case you haven't looked yet

[scottish]

Re: The Brand New Top Players List

I looked, and checked twice. According to the list, you have 62 points alone, with 9 bonus. 71 points total.

[Jammer325]

Re: The Brand New Top Players List

as of now, each point requires -100 for total score than what is posted.

[dawg4321]

Re: The Brand New Top Players List

ok. I thought i had 82 or so. That's kewl though. 71 is still 9 points better. thx scott

[ieatyourlvllol]

Re: The Brand New Top Players List

The new list is awesome!

Yay, I'm officially top 15...

P.S. - I'm almost positive Darkshark is way, way higher...

[Tasselfoot]

Re: The Brand New Top Players List

ehh. my calculated list is 3 higher than what is posted... although I still have P4U in my list, so that is 2 points. and likely one of my high-boo-count points is 1 less (cutting circles is 25 or less for the point, i have 25-0-0-12).

so, yea... basically on target for me.

[dore]

Re: The Brand New Top Players List

Thanks for the recalc. Sexy #9

[Breach]

Re: The Brand New Top Players List

OK 3 choices then..

(1) All AAAs/PA scores that are worth 1 point will be added. If we add them AAA/Ave bonus will be meaningless because they are kind of double-count, so they will be taken off.

(2) like 10-20 Lv4 song will be just added to current system, AAA/Ave bonus will remain.

(3) like 10-20 Lv4 song will be added to current system, and AAA/Ave bonus will be taken off.

i basically like option 3 more, same as shash. and just a suggestion of mine, maybe ONLY AAAs of SOME Lv3 or Lv3.5 songs worth 1 or 2 points max. blackflags don't even count as points for Lv3 or Lv3.5 songs. as someone had mentioned, the difficulty of improving from a blackflag to AAA is much more difficult than improving from 2 goods to a blackflag.

[brianpage]

Re: The Brand New Top Players List

Stupidist list ever.I thought the stupidity of it it was maxed out but this new system has by far killed more brain cells than the last one and I only looked at it once.Ps Bonus points is the dumbest idea ever.

[scottish]

Re: The Brand New Top Players List

Awesome Brian, thanks for the critique.

[Tasselfoot]

Re: The Brand New Top Players List

its amusing, because all of brian's comments are based out of jealousy of NOT being on the list....

want to be on the list? GET BETTER.